Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR

This place was great. The food was good, cool souvenir cup with drink purchase and staff was wonderful. Will definitely return next time I'm in Cincinnati.

First time here and it was great I will return. The slices were large I bought 2 slices but should have gotten 1.

Have enjoyed their pizza for years. Best late night slice (a good sign is the line near closing time, so get there 30 minutes before). You can get whole pies, subs and calzones. I love their Al Pacino meatball sub. If you have a taste for good salads, they also got you covered. Same for desserts. There's a bar upstairs (Wiseguy Lounge) if you want that and you can eat wherever there's a table, including a balcony and courtyard out back.

Great pizza. It's New York style pizza without the floppy crust. The bottom is crispy but not burnt, perfect! The ready to go meatball sub is huge and delicious! The bread sticks are very tasty and have to be folded to copy in the pizza box.

Disgusting people and food

Great service and good quick downtown pizza

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had, and service is engaging and friendly!