Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR Menu

Can't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 12 half pie all to yourself.

Build your own 16 pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... Your Way

Can't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 16 half pie all to yourself.

Build your own 22 pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... Your Way

Can't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 22 half pie all to yourself.

This half moon turnover is stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings. Prepare to share!- toppings $2.00 each (limit 3)

Our original hand tossed dough brushed with garlic butter and covered with a pile of mozzarella. Finished with oregano and perfect for sharing.

Marinara, Ranch, Garlic Butter, Nacho Cheese, Buffalo Ranch

A New York Tribeca bread baguette, spread with a generous amount of housemade pesto, topped with mozzarella and baked till golden brown.

A single breadstick that is literally the size of your arm. Covered in garlic butter, parmesan, and dusted with oregano. Served with your choice of sauce

Need we say more? This snack is a tastebud pleaser! Served with housemade ranch

A New York Tribeca bread baguette brushed with garlic infused olive oil, topped with imported Italian sun dried tomatoes, cheese, and finished with fresh basil.

Our world class meatballs made of pork and beef are smothered in our house made marinara and topped with ricotta and basil... Mangia!*soy,milk,gluten,egg

An extra large meatball sub sandwich with our signature marinara sauce, on a toasted Tribeca bread baguette, and stuffed with the best meatballs you'll ever taste!

A simple salad made of fresh Fior di Latte mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, then drizzled with olive oil and seasoned

A small side salad with fresh spring mix, red onions, tomatoes, and sliced button mushrooms.

A tri-colored rotini pasta salad tossed with diced roma tomatoes, banana peppers, black olives, red onion, and broccoli. Finished with housemade Italian dressing.

A housemade Italian pastry filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips

An extra large staple cookie with extra chocolate

Seinfeld's favorite... a New York staple

Hands down the best you've ever had!

Coca-cola products in a reusable Goodfellas stadium cup

Goodfellas very own bottled spring water

Straight From The Barrel

60% Priced 1 oz Pour

60% Priced 1 oz Pour

60% Priced 1 oz Pour

60% Priced 1 oz Pour

2 oz pour

2 oz pour

2 oz pour

1 oz pour

%60 Priced 1 0z pour

2 oz pour

2 oz pour

Nucky Thompson approved with spinach, mushroom, sundried tomatoes, and pesto (try it with chicken)

Travel back to the old country with this margherita pie made with our signature marinara sauce, basil and fresh mozzarella

A meaty pie suitable for any gangster with pepperoni, Italian rope sausage, ground beef, and bacon.

Paulie's passion for cooking sausage inspired this pie with spicy sliced Italian sausage, garlic sausage crumble, green peppers, onions, a roasted garlic

The choice for any head of the family with pepperoni, Italian rope sausage, ground beef, bacon, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and black olives

Every available topping... Fuhgetaboutit!

a friend of the family's traditional white pie made with olive oil, ricotta, roasted garlic, and mozzarella (try it with sausage)

Two times the amount of pepperoni!

Calling the shots with chicken, tomatoes, onions, bacon, and drizzled ranch

Just how Nonna used to make pasta, except as a pizza. Meatballs, red onion, ricotta, garlic, and basil. Mangia!

This half moon turnover is stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings. Prepare to share! - toppings $2.00 each (limit 3)

A single breadstick that is literally the size of your arm. Covered in garlic butter, parmesan, and dusted with oregano. Served with your choice of sauce

Our original hand tossed dough brushed with garlic butter and covered with a pile of mozzarella. Finished with oregano and perfect for sharing.

Need we say more? This snack is a tastebud pleaser! Served with housemade ranch

Our world class meatballs made of pork and beef are smothered in our housemade marinara and topped with ricotta and basil... Mangia!

A New York Tribeca bread baguette brushed with garlic infused olive oil, topped with imported Italian sun dried tomatoes, cheese, and finished with fresh basil.

A New York Tribeca bread baguette, spread with a generous amount of housemade pesto, topped with mozzarella and baked till golden brown.

An extra large meatball sub sandwich with our signature marinara sauce, on a toasted Tribeca bread baguette, and stuffed with the best meatballs you'll ever taste!

A small side salad with fresh spring mix, red onions, tomatoes, and sliced button mushrooms.

A tri-colored rontini pasta salad tossed with diced roma tomatoes, banana peppers, black olives, red onion, and broccoli. Finished with housemade Italian dressing.

A simple salad made of fresh Fior di Latte mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, then drizzled with olive oil and seasoned

A housemade Italian pastry filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips

Seinfeld's favorite... a New York staple

An extra large staple cookie with extra chocolate

Served with house made ranch

Pork and beef meatballs, marinara, ricotta, and basil

A New York Tribeca baguette, garlic infused olive oil, sun dried tomatoes, cheese, and basil

A New York Tribeca baguette, pesto, and mozzarella

Four Roses Bourbon, Orange, Hazelnut, Black Walnut, Rye Bitters, Cinnamon, Creme Brulee

Old Grand Dad BiB Bourbon, Blueberry, Blue Maple Agave, Aromatic Bitters, Allspice Dram, Leather and Tobacco Bitters, Maple Smoke

Monte Alban Tequila, Cucumber, Raspberry, Rosemary, Lemon, Raw Egg White*

Benchmark Bourbon, Demarara Gomme, Lemon, Mint

Gin, Strawberry, Dry Vermouth, Lime, Simple, Angostura Bitters

Gin, Lemon, Lime, Strawberry, Pineapple, Whole Milk, Fruity Pebbles, Strawberry Banana Nectar

Raspberry-Infused Vodka, Limoncello, Lemon, Fig Vanilla Simple

Eastern Gin, Mezcal, Lemon, Peppercorn Infused Agave

Gin, Amaro, Campari, Pineapple, Habanero

Dark Rum, Apple Cider Demerara Simple, Lemon, Angostura Bitters, Black Walnut Bitters

Cognac, Rye, Banana Liqueur, Coffee Liqueur, Orange Bitters, Walnut Bitters

Bourbon, Simple, Angostura Bitters, Orange Zest, Brandied Cherry

Rittenhouse Rye, Sweet Vermouth, Angostura Bitters, Brandied Cherry

Cognac, Dry Curacao, Lemon

Rye Whiskey, Cognac, Sweet Vermouth, Benedictine, Peychaud's and Angostura Bitters

Beefeater Gin, Campari, Sweet Vermouth

Choose your Spirit, Lime, Ginger Beer

Rittenhouse Rye, Simple, Peychaud's Bitters

Amaretto, Simple, Lemon, Raw Egg White*

Wiseguy Lounge Private Selection Bourbon, Sazerac Rye, Demerara Gomme, Jerry Thomas & Orange Bitters, Bourbon Barrel Smoke

Bourbon Barrel Aged Corazon Reposado, Dry Curacao, Agave Nectar, Lime

Vodka, Limoncello, Peach, Agave, Sour, Rhubarb Bitters

Vodka, Pomegranate, Rhubarb, Sour, Lemon Bitters

Gin, Elderflower, Lime, Cucumber Basil

Pinnacle Vodka, Vanilla, Coffee, Espresso

Peanut Butter Tequila, Cafe Coffee, Creme de Cacao, Chocolate Bitters, Espresso

Housemade Peanut Butter Infused Tequila

Belgian Style White Ale - 5%

Lager - 5%

American-Style Lager -5%

Rotating

Rotating

Rotating

Rotating

Rotating

Rotating

Rotating

San Pellegrino Aranciata Rossa, Vanilla Demerara, Honey, Lime, Tonic

San Pellegrino Pompelmo, Mint, Lime, Ginger Beer, Tonic

Seedlip Garden 108, Blueberry Puree, Honey, Basil, Lemon

500 mL

11.15 fl oz

11.15 fl oz

Regular, Sugar Free, Tropical

Try with one of our house made syrups