Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Tony’s New York Style Pizza Menu

$$Pizza, Cocktail bar
412 W Dickson St, Fayetteville, AR 72701
Order Online

  • Specialty Pizza

    • NY Style Pizza Margherita

      Italian pizza with fresh sliced tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil leaves
      $15.95

    • Fat Tony's Alfredo

      Fresh spinach, garlic chicken, Feta cheese, Bacon & fresh, rich, real cream house made Alfredo
      $18.95

    • The Bigg Pigg

      Pepperoni, ham, sausage, hamburger and bacon
      $18.95

    • 4 Cheese Gold Rush

      For the cheese lover-mozzarella, provolone, ricotta and Parmesan Reggiano
      $17.95

    • Hager's Buffalo Chicken

      Fresh made spicy Buffalo sauced tossed with chicken, fresh jalapenos, purple onions and bacon with both shredded provolone and mozzarella
      $15.95

    • The Hawaiian

      Classic pineapple and ham
      $18.95

    • The Works

      Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, hamburger, mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, and black olives
      $19.95

    • Classic Margherita

      Fresh sliced tomatoes, fresh mozzalla and basil
      $15.95

    • Vegetarian Pizza

      Various fresh seasonal vegetables. Ask your server.
      $15.95

    • Create Your Own Pizza 14"

      Our delicious NY style pizza with any toppings you desire (+$1.50)
      $14.95

    • Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza(10" Individual Size)

      Hard to believe it is Gluten Free. Low carb. Extra toppings $1 each.
      $11.95

    • Vegan Cheese On Any Pizza Or Hoagie

      10" pizza 2.00 14" pizza 4.00 18" pizza 5.00 Hoagie 1.00
      $2.00

  • Big NY Style Slices--available at ALL the time

    • Specialty Slice

      We switch it up each week . Ask your server or see blackboard.
      $5.99

    • Pepperoni Slice

      Everyone's favorite! A Big pepperoni slice
      $5.00

    • Classic Cheese

      A Big NY style slice of cheese heaven
      $4.50

  • Calzones--hand folded perfection

    • Original

      Stuffed with our blend of Ricotta and Mozzarella cheese. Served with house made marinara.
      $9.95

    • Bigg Pigg Calzone

      Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, bacon & Italian ham blended with our special cheese & served with marinara
      $11.95

    • Spicy Italian

      An Italian classic—pepperoni & Genoa salami with our blend of Ricotta & Mozzarella cheese & served with marinara
      $10.99

    • Hager's Buffalo Chicken Calzone

      Chef made spicy Buffalo style pizza sauce with chicken, fresh jalapenos, purple onions, bacon, shredded provolone cheese added to our blended cheese & served with ranch
      $12.99

    • Customized Calzone

      Customize with any extra item for only $1
      $1.00

  • Toppings

    • PEPPERONI, SALAMI, BACON, HAM, GARLIC CHICKEN, HAMBURGER, SAUSAGE, MUSHROOMS, BELL PEPPERS, ONIONS, SPINACH, MEATBALLS, PINEAPPLE, FRESH JAL

  • Salads

    • House Salad

      Simple & fresh: romaine, tomatoes, croutons & parmesan Large size 7.95
      $4.95

    • Antipasto Salad

      Romaine, tomatoes, onions, pepperoni, salami, ham, olives, pepperoncini, house Italian dressing, grated Parmesan & crunchy croutons Large size 12.95
      $8.45

    • Chicken Caesar Salad

      Garlic chicken, romaine, croutons & fresh grated Parmesan Large size 11.95
      $7.45

  • Italian Hoagies (Full size is 12" long)

    • Vegetarian

      Spinach, romaine, mushrooms, sweet onions, bell peppers, tomatoes & provolone cheese Large size 11.95
      $5.95

    • Meatball

      Meatballs topped with our blended herbs, parmesan, house made marinara and melted mozzarella. Large size 10.95
      $7.95

    • Hot Ham And Cheese

      Fresh sliced smoked Italian ham & provolone cheese topped with romaine, tomatoes & purple onions. Served toasted Large size 11.95
      $8.45

    • Overstuffed Italian Hoagie

      Pepperoni, Genoa salami, Italian ham, mozzarella, provolone, romaine, tomatoes, purple onions & house Italian dressing Large size 12.95
      $8.95

  • Appetizers

    • Wings By The Pound

      Chicken wings tossed in your choice of BBQ, buffalo, garlic-Parmesan or teriyaki. Served with celery & blue cheese or ranch
      $9.95

    • Bread Sticks

      Our house made NY dough brushed with garlic butter and topped with our house blended herb Parmesan cheese. Served with fresh marinara.
      $5.95

    • Pizza Bread

      Our bread sticks covered in house marinara, mozzarella & pepperoni topped with our herb-parmesan & served with ranch.
      $7.95

  • Decadent Desserts

    • NY Style Cheesecake

      Traditional thick slice of NY Cheesecake--freshly made in-house drizzled with Ghiardelli chocolate & sprinkled with powdered sugar. Big enough to share.
      $6.95

    • Cannoli Siciliani

      Crunchy pastry dough dipped in creamy chocolate and filled to order with sweet Ricotta cheese & drizzled iwth Ghiardelli chocolate and sprinkled with powder sugar. (Add a second one 2.50)
      $3.45

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms