The Ugly Pie

I have been going to the ugly pie since they opened their small shop near Brew River. The people are gems, the atmosphere is quirky and cute, and owners are wonderfully down to earth. Now, let's talk pie. The pies are PHENOMENAL. Homemade, baked with love and fresh ingredients. I haven't had a pie that I yet disliked, including their new shepherd's pies. The prices are fair for what you get, which is a pie stuffed with flavor and nostalgia. We also love their sweet potato biscuits and cookies slabs, and the pie milkshakes are just *chefs kiss*.

If you love pie a la mode get the pie milkshake! It's the best! I hope they get a drive through someday.

Seemed like a great idea... but overpriced, not friendly and a small selection

We can't get enough of Ugly Pie. Probably in there every other week. Generous portions when you buy a slice, perfect sized pints. Theres so much to choose from on any day and something for everyone. Thry even have savory pies now (meat and vegetarian!) honestly its hard to choose! Their prices are affordable and very reasonable! All the folks are super nice and friendly,, even when its really busy. Its part of why we're in so often. I work in a kitchen myself and I hype Ugly Pie to my coworkers. Its why I was in today, to get some for my team whos about to have a long, unusual shift. TL;DR: Do yourself a favor and try some Ugly Pie flavor!