The Tin Cup Tavern

1st time there and Love it everything was fantastic Thank you for a enjoyable meal Cat McIntyre

Nice place, with nice prices & cold beer

Love the food and staff! A fun date night!!

First visit: 8/10 Second visit: 2/10 TLDR; Long wait times for food, excessive "fees" added to the bill, kids seem to get their food last. Won't be going back. We recently discovered this place via Facebook and decided to try it out on a Thursday evening. We arrive at 5:30 (30 mins after open) and were the only customers. We were greeted promptly and ordered drinks. The appetizer chips & queso was pretty good. The wait time for the food was a little long, but there was probably only one cook. Understandable. My wife and I got our entrees, but my daughter's grilled cheese took an additional 10 minutes at least. Our waitress said the flat iron wasn't working correctly. Slightly annoying, but understandable. Not in their control necessarily. We finish, pay, and leave. We thought the pricing was fair, atmosphere was nice, and food was ok depending on what it was. I had the 2 meat plate with sliced brisket & sausage. The brisket was very dry, and was about 1/3 fat. Decent flavor. Sausage & sides were good. My wife had the brisket potato. Definitely not a fan. I also ordered a margarita, which was lackluster, but it was cheap. We pay, leave, and intended to come back. Not a bad experience, but some annoyances for sure. A few weeks later, we come back with my parents. This is where things went off the rails. We arrive, are quickly seated, and start looking at the menu. Again, very empty when we arrived, but there were a few at the bar. After sitting down, I noticed there were two different menus, with two different prices. The cheaper one was what we had last time, the more expensive one was new. Everything was 3,4,5 dollars higher than the other menu. We had 1 expensive menu, and 3 cheap menus. Strange. I ordered the same 2 meat plate once again, in hopes that the brisket would be better and less fatty. It wasn't. Still very dry and very fatty. My wife got the wrap, and said it was good. My mom had the meatloaf, which looked like a cowpie (not joking). My dad had the same 2 meat plate with different sides. Again, same case with the meat. And wouldn't you know it, my daughter's mac & cheese is late once again. No reason this time other than that "I'm rushing him to get it out" - Our waitress. 10-15 minutes late once again. We get the bill, and it's not split for 2 parties. She never asked, but we never said anything. I can take ownership of that. We asked her to split, and she did. However, there were new strange "fees" added to the bottom of our receipt. The original single ticket had 3 fees listed at the bottom. 2.36%, 1.00%, and 3.29% (Amex). How did they know I was paying with an amex? Well, I did anyways since they charged me the fees, and I'll get 3x points for it anyways. All in all, it was just shy of $3 added to split our bills BEFORE TAX. I never saw any disclaimer or notice about this on the receipt, or menu. That seems extremely shady. It was also my parents second visit, and they had a very similar 1st experience as well. I now understand why nobody is ever here. Also why the business is up for sale (a quick search found that). We unfortunately won't be going back. Slow, shady, food is subpar at best. Full disclosure: I hate leaving bad reviews for small businesses. I actually work for 2 of them myself. However, it seems slightly misleading that this place has a 4.5 star rating at the time of this review.

Wonderful place to spend an evening