Fit Vine: Fit Vine wines are low in calories, sugars and carbohydrates.
$12.00
Sauvignon Blanc
Paumanok Vineyards
$14.00
Rosé
Wölffer Estate
$13.00
Rosé
Whispering Angel
$16.00
Pinot Noir
Meomi
$16.00
Cabernet Sauvignon
Fit Vine: Fit Vine wines are low in calories, sugars and carbohydrates.
$12.00
MARGARITAS
Cuervo Classic Margarita
$13.00
1800 Silver Margarita
$14.00
1800 Reposado Margarita
$15.00
Montaukila Margarita
$16.00
Patron Margarita
$18.00
Don Julio Margarita
$18.00
Casamigos Añejo Margarita
$20.00
Blood Orange Margarita
On the rocks with imported blood orange juice
$14.00
Andrea's Guilt-Free Margarita
On the rocks with imported blood orange juice
$14.00
Montaukila Margarita
Made with Montaukila, lime juice, Cointreau, and a splash of pineapple juice. Served on the rocks!
$16.00
"The Affair" Margarita
Sinfully good! Made with Montaukila and Cointreau on the rocks or frozen.
$16.00
DAIQUIRIS
Classic Bacardi Daiquiri
$12.00
Bacardi Peach Daiquiri
$14.00
Bacardi Mango Daiquiri
$14.00
FROZEN PIÑA COLADAS
Classic Bacardi Colada
$12.00
Malibu Colada
$12.00
Montauk Coconut Colada
$14.00
Bacardi Peach Colada
$14.00
Bacardi Mango Colada
$14.00
Banana Bailey's Colada
$14.00
RUM COCKTAILS ON THE ROCKS
Bacardi Summer Splash
Our homemade punch on the rocks with Bacardi rum
$12.00
Bacardi Limón Summer Splash
$12.00
Malibu Coconut Splash
$12.00
Captain Morgan Summer Splash
$14.00
Montauk Coconut Summer Splash
$14.00
Myer's Summer Splash
$15.00
VODKA COCKTAILS ON THE ROCKS
Tito's Summer Splash
Tito's vodka and our homemade punch on the rocks
$12.00
Tito's Bloody Mary
Tito's vodka with our homemade spicy Bloody Mary mix.
$12.00
Tito's 19th. Hole
Tito's vodka, lemonade and iced tea.
$12.00
East End Bloody Mary!!!!!
Tito's vodka with our homemade Bloody Mary mix, garnished with a shrimp, olive, pickle, lemon, and a celery stick. Served with an Old Bay rim.
$18.00
VODKA MARTINIS
Tito's Martini
$14.00
Tito's Mango Martini
$14.00
Tito's Hampton Cosmo
$14.00
Absolut Martini
$15.00
Ketel One Martini
$16.00
Grey Goose Martini
$18.00
GIN COCKTAILS
Classic Beefeater And Tonic
$12.00
Montauk Citrus Gin And Tonic
$12.00
Classic Tanqueray And Tonic
$13.00
GIN MARTINIS
Beefeater Martini
$13.00
Montauk Citrus Martini
$13.00
Bombay Sapphire Martini
$15.00
Hendricks Martini
$16.00
THE ESSENTIALS
Andrea's Amagansett
A house favorite! Muddled cherry, orange & lime, topped with Maker's Mark and Ginger ale.
$14.00
Manhattan
Maker's Mark, sweet vermouth, bitters, muddled together with a cherry.
$14.00
Old Fashioned
Maker's Mark with sugared bitters.
$14.00
PROSECCO COCKTAILS
By The Glass
$10.00
Classic Peach Bellini
$12.00
Mango Bellini
$12.00
Classic Mimosa
$12.00
APPETIZERS
ANDREA'S GARDEN SALAD
Golden fresh baby kale, crisp romaine, carrots, red cabbage, feta cheese, grape tomatoes, dried cranberries and pistachio nuts.
$13.95
MIXED GREEN SALAD
Fresh greens with your choice of dressing
$6.50
SHRIMP COCKTAIL
Six succulent shrimp served with a zesty cocktail sauce
$16.95
STEAMERS & BROTH
A full quart! The South Fork classic "soft shell" clam
$24.00
MUSSELS MARINARA
A full quart! Plump mussels with Paul's zest marinara sauce
$13.95
PLUMP MUSSELS
A full quart! Served in an herbed garlic butter
$13.95
CRAB CAKE APPETIZER
Grilled and served with our homemade remoulade sauce
FRIED CALAMARI
(Great to share!) Lightly seasoned and served with Paul's own homemade zesty marinara sauce. Buffalo Style - served with hot sauce and blue cheese +$1.00
$16.50
CHICKEN TENDERS
Tender chicken fried crispy and golden. Served with BBQ sauce.
$9.95
BATTERED ONION RINGS
Sweet large onions fried golden brown
$9.50
CHOWDERS, BISQUE & CHILI
SEAFOOD CHILI
Paul's Famous Seafood Chili - a spicy blend of shrimp, lobster, scallops, and beans. Topped with melted cheddar cheese, sour cream, and scallions. Served with tortilla chips.
$16.95
LOBSTER ROLLS
CLASSIC LOBSTER SALAD ROLL
CLASSIC LOBSTER SALAD ROLL 100% pure, cold-water lobster meat mixed with the finest mayonnaise and just enough celery for texture! Served cold on a hot toasted split-top bun and w/4 lb. of our homemade creamy coleslaw Add fries +2.75
$27.95
LOBSTER SALAD SLIDER
A "mini" version of the Classic Lobster Roll. Add fries +2.75
$13.95
HOT LOBSTER ROLL
Hot, tasty chunks of claw and knuckle meat served in a drawn butter with a toasted split-top bun on the side and 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy coleslaw. Add fries +2.75
$29.95
LOBSTER SALAD BOWL
Cold Lobster Salad atop our small mixed green salad. Served with crackers and your favorite dressing on the side. Served with 1/4 lb of homemade coleslaw. Add fries +2.75
$29.95
"PUB" SANDWICH SPECIALTIES
CHAR-BROILED TUNA STEAK SANDWICH
Fresh tuna loin steak on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato, and remoulade sauce
$15.95
GRILLED CRABCAKE SANDWICH
"Blue claw" crabcake served on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato, and remoulade sauce
$15.95
FRIED FLOUNDER FILET SANDWICH
Breaded, deep fried on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato, and tartar sauce
$16.95
CHAR-BROILED BEEF BURGER
Half pound Angus beef burger, with lettuce, tomato, and a pickle
$13.95
DR. PRAEGER'S GRILLED VEGGIE BURGER
A healthful blend of select veggies, deliciously seasoned, with lettuce, tomato, a pickle, and honey mustard.
$13.95
CHAR-BROILED CHICKEN BREAST SANDWICH
Herbed chicken cutlet on a toasted roll, with lettuce, tomato, a pickle, and honey mustard.
$14.95
GOLDEN GRILLED CHEESE
The old "standby" grilled golden brown. Served with a pickle.
$7.95
ALL-BEEF SABRETT'S HOT DOG
Grilled classic on a buttery toasted roll, served with a pickle.
$8.50
ALL INCLUSIVE SPECIALS
FRIED CLAM STRIP PLATTER
Includes cup of Manhattan or New England chowder, your choice of an accompaniment (french fries, roasted potatoes or corn) and a 1/4 lb of homemade creamy coleslaw
$24.95
POPCORN SHRIMP PLATTER
Includes cup of Manhattan or New England chowder, your choice of an accompaniment (french fries, roasted potatoes or corn) and a 1/4 lb of homemade creamy coleslaw
$24.95
ENTREE PLATTERS
FISH N' CHIPS
Atlantic cold-water cod dipped in tempura batter and fried to crunchy perfection! Served with zesty tartar sauce. Malt vinegar completes this dish!
$19.95
CHICKEN TENDERS N' CHIPS
Chicken tenders fried crispy and golden. Served with 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy coleslaw, crispy crinkle cut fries, and tangy BBQ sauce.
$13.95
GRANDMA'S CRABCAKES
Grilled premium blue claw crabmeat, bread crumbs, spices, and herbs. Served with our homemade remoulade sauce.
$24.95
SALMON FILET
Prepared with a garlic herb sauce
$26.95
SCALLOPS
Sweet tender sea scallops in a scampi butter
$26.95
TUNA STEAK
Select loin-cut steak lightly marinated in garlic & herbs
$24.95
CHICKEN CUTLET PLATTER
Pure white meat chicken filet brushed with a garlic herb sauce
$21.95
WHOLE STEAMED LOBSTER
1 1/2 lb steamed whole lobster
$36.20
ENTREE GARDEN SALAD PLATTERS
TUNA STEAK GARDEN SALAD
Marinated & Char-broiled
$24.95
CHICKEN GARDEN SALAD
Char Broiled & marinated chicken breast filet
$21.95
SALMON FILET GARDEN SALAD
Broiled Salmon
$26.95
VEGGIE BURGER GARDEN SALAD
$20.95
LOBSTER SALAD GARDEN SALAD
A scoop of Lobster Salad
$30.95
HOT LOBSTER GARDEN SALAD
$39.95
COMBINATIONS
CAPTAIN'S FRIED COMBO
Breaded shrimp, scallops & flounder. Served with tartar & cocktail sauce.
$26.95
BROILED SEAFOOD COMBO
Succulent shrimp, scallops and flounder. Served with scampi butter.
$26.95
FIRST MATE'S FRIED COMBO
Breaded shrimp, clam strips and flounder. Served with tartar & cocktail sauce.
$26.95
FRIED SELECTIONS
FRIED CLAM STRIPS
Crispy strips of cold water deep sea clams fried golden. Served with tartar or cocktail sauce.
$17.95
FRIED SEA SCALLOPS
Lightly dusted and fried to perfection. Served with tartar sauce.
$26.95
GOLDEN FRIED SHRIMP
Succulent shrimp, butterflied, lightly breaded and fried golden. Served with tartar or cocktail sauce.
$22.95
FRIED FILET OF FLOUNDER
Lightly breaded, fresh boneless filet. Served with tartar sauce.
Garden fresh baby kale, crisp romaine, carrots, red cabbage, feta cheese, grape tomatoes, dried cranberries and pistachio nuts. Served with a homemade roasted garlic vinaigrette
$13.95
GF MIXED GREEN SALAD
Fresh greens with your choice of salad dressing. Add Pistachios/Craisins/Feta Cheese 1.00 ea
$6.50
GF STEAMERS AND BROTH
A full quart! The South Fork classic "soft shell" clam.
$24.00
GF SHRIMP COCKTAIL
Six succulent shrimp served with a zesty cocktail sauce.
$16.95
GF MUSSELS MARINARA
A full quart! Plump mussels with Paul's zesty marinara sauce.
$13.95
GF PLUMP MUSSELS
A full quart! Plump mussels with herbed garlic butter.
$13.95
GF CHICKEN TENDERS
Tender chicken fried crispy and golden. Served with BBQ sauce.
$9.95
GF SEAFOOD CHILI
A spicy blend of shrimp, lobster, scallops, and beans. Topped with melted cheddar cheese, sour cream, and scallions. Served with tortilla chips.
$16.95
GF CLASSIC LOBSTER SALAD ROLL
100% pure, cold-water lobster meat mixed with the finest mayonnaise and just enough celery for texture! Served cold on a hot toasted split-top bun and ¼ lb. of our homemade creamy coleslaw. Add fries + 2.75
$26.95
GF LOBSTER SALAD SLIDER
a "mini" version of the Classic Lobster Roll. add fries + 2.75
$14.95
GF HOT LOBSTER ROLL
Hot, tasty chunks of claw and knuckle meat served in drawn butter with a toasted split-top bun on the side and ¼ lb. of our homemade creamy coleslaw. Add fries + 2.75
$28.95
GF LOBSTER SALAD BOWL
Cold Lobster Salad atop our small mixed green salad. Served with crackers and your favorite dressing on the side. Add fries + 2.75
$28.95
GF CHAR-BROILED TUNA STEAK
Fresh tuna loin steak on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato, and remoulade sauce.
$16.95
GF CHAR-BROILED BEEF BURGER
Half pound Angus beef burger, with lettuce, tomato, and a pickle.
$14.95
GF DR. PRAEGER'S GRILLED VEGGIE BURGER
A healthful blend of select veggies, delicately seasoned, with lettuce, tomato, a pickle, and honey mustard.
$14.95
GF CHAR-BROILED CHICKEN BREAST SANDWICH
Herbed chicken cutlet on a toasted roll, with lettuce, tomato, a pickle, and honey mustard.
$15.95
GF GRILLED CHEESE
The old "standby" grilled golden brown. Served with a pickle
$8.95
GF ALL-BEEF SABRETT'S HOT DOG
Grilled classic on a buttery toasted roll, served with a pickle
$9.50
GF CHICKEN TENDERS-N-CHIPS
Chicken tenders fried crispy and golden. Served with ¼ lb. of our homemade creamy coleslaw, crispy Crinkle-Cut French Fries, and tangy BBQ sauce.
$13.95
GF SALMON FILET
Prepared with a garlic herb sauce.
$26.95
GF SCALLOPS
Sweet tender sea scallops in a scampi butter.
$26.95
GF TUNA STEAK
Select loin-cut steak lightly marinated in garlic and herbs.
$24.95
GF CHICKEN CUTLET PLATTER
Pure white meat chicken filets brushed with a garlic herb sauce.
$21.95
GF WHOLE STEAMED LOBSTER
1 1/2 lb steamed whole lobster.
$38.95
GF BROILED SEAFOOD COMBINATION
Succulent shrimp, scallops and flounder. Served with scampi butter.
$26.95
GF TUNA STEAK GARDEN SALAD
Tuna Steak served on top of baby kale, crisp romaine, carrots and red cabbage. Served with 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy coleslaw and your favorite salad dressing.
$24.95
GF CHICKEN GARDEN SALAD
Chicken Breast Filet served on top of baby kale, crisp romaine, carrots and red cabbage. Served with 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy coleslaw and your favorite salad dressing.
$21.95
GF SALMON FILET GARDEN SALAD
Salmon Filet served on top of baby kale, crisp romaine, carrots and red cabbage. Served with 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy coleslaw and your favorite salad dressing.
$26.95
GF VEGGIE BURGER GARDEN SALAD
Veggie burger served on top of baby kale, crisp romaine, carrots and red cabbage. Served with 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy coleslaw and your favorite salad dressing.
$20.95
GF LOBSTER SALAD GARDEN SALAD
1 Scoop of Lobster Salad served on top of baby kale, crisp romaine, carrots and red cabbage. Served with 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy coleslaw and your favorite salad dressing.
$30.95
GF HOT LOBSTER GARDEN SALAD
1 Scoop of Hot Lobster served on top of baby kale, crisp romaine, carrots and red cabbage. Served with 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy coleslaw and your favorite salad dressing.
$39.95
GF SIDE FRIES
$5.50
GF SIDE SWEET CORN ON THE COB
$3.00
GF SIDE ROASTED NEW POTATOES
$5.50
GF SIDE SWEET POTATO FRIES
$7.50
GF KID BURGER
$7.95
GF KID HOT DOG
$7.50
GF KID CHICKEN TENDERS
$7.50
GF KID GRILLED CHEESE
$7.50
GF KID MANHATTAN CHOWDER-N-CRACKERS
$6.50
GF ICE CREAM
2 scoops. Choice of Cinnamon or Vanilla
$7.95
GF CHOCOLATE CUPCAKE
Chocolate cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla butter cream frosting OR Andrea's homemade chocolate ganache frosting
$6.95
Desserts
Vanilla Milkshake
$8.50
Malted Milkshake
$8.50
VANILLA CUPCAKE
Vanilla cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting
$4.95
CHOCOLATE CUPCAKE
Devil's food cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade chocolate ganache frosting
$4.95
BLACK & WHITE CUPCAKE
Devil's food cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting
$4.95
WHITE & BLACK CUPCAKE
Vanilla cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade chocolate ganache frosting
$4.95
OREO CUPCAKE
Devil's food cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting, and oreo cookies
$4.95
COCONUT CREAM CUPCAKE
Vanilla cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade coconut cream frosting
$4.95
"LUNCH" CUPCAKE
Vanilla cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting decorated with a gummy lobster
$4.95
GLUTEN-FREE CHOCOLATE CUPCAKE
Chocolate cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting OR Andrea's homemade chocolate ganache frosting.
$6.95
FROZEN KEY LIME PIE
Creamy, tangy and refreshing filling with a slightly sweet graham cracker crust
$7.50
STRAWBERRY RHUBARB PIE
ala mode +1.50
$6.95
APPLE CRUMB PIE
ala mode + 1.50
$6.95
ICE CREAM
2 Scoops. Choice of Vanilla or Cinnamon.
$7.95
BOTTLED BEER AND WINE
Montauk Summer Ale
$5.00
Montauk Watermelon
$5.00
Corona Extra
$5.00
Budweiser
$5.00
Miller Lite
$5.00
Gluten Free
$5.00
Non-Alc
$5.00
Prosecco
$10.00
La Crema Chardonnay
$27.50
Fit Vine Sauvignon Blanc
$27.50
Paumanok Sauvignon Blanc
$27.50
Wolffer Estate Rose
$27.50
Meiomi Pinot Noir
$27.50
Fit Vine Cabernet
$27.50
Draft Beer
Montauk IPA
$5.00
Montauk Pilsner
$5.00
Brooklyn Summer Ale
$5.00
Peroni
$5.00
Blue Moon Ale
$5.00
Hazy Little Thing IPA
$5.00
Cocktails
EAST END BLOODY MARY
Tito's vodka with our homemade Bloody Mary mix. Garnished with a shrimp, olive, pickle, lemon and a celery stick. Served with an Old Bay seasoned rim!
$18.00
MONTAUKILA MARGARITA
Made with Montaukila, lime juice, Contreau and a splash of pineapple juice. Served on the rocks.
$16.00
"THE AFFAIR" MARGARITA
Sinfully good! Made with Montaukila and Cointreau, on the rocks or frozen.
$16.00
CUERVO MARGARITA
Made with Cointreau. Served on the rocks or frozen
$13.00
1800 REPOSADO MARGARITA
Made with Cointreau. Served on the rocks or frozen
$14.00
PATRON MARGARITA
Made with Cointreau. Served on the rocks or frozen.
$18.00
DON JULIO MARGARITA
Made with Cointreau. Served on the rocks or frozen
$18.00
BLOOD ORANGE MARGARITA
On the rocks with imported blood orange juice.
$14.00
ANDREA'S GUILT-FREE MARGARITA
On the rocks with no sugar added. Cuervo, Cointreau and citrus juices
$14.00
BACARDI SUMMER SPLASH
Our homemade punch on the rocks with Bacardi Rum
$12.00
CAPTAIN MORGAN SUMMER SPLASH
Our homemade punch on the rocks with Captain Morgan.
$14.00
Malibu Summer Splash
Our homemade punch on the rocks with Malibu
$12.00
MYERS SUMMER SPLASH
Our homemade punch on the rocks with Myers
$15.00
BACARDI COLADA
Frozen Pina Colada with Bacardi
$12.00
MALIBU COLADA
Frozen Pina Colada with Malibu
$12.00
BACARDI MANGO COLADA
$14.00
BANANA BAILEY'S COLADA
$14.00
BACARDI DAIQUIRI
$12.00
BACARDI MANGO DAIQUIRI
$14.00
TITO'S SUMMER SPLASH
Tito's vodka & our homemade punch on the rocks
$12.00
KETEL ONE SUMMER SPLASH
Ketel One vodka & our homemade punch on the rocks
$14.00
TITO'S BLOODY MARY
Tito's vodka with our homemade spicy Bloody Mary Mix!
$12.00
KETEL ONE BLOODY MARY
Ketel One vodka with our homemade spicy Bloody Mary Mix!