Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Sibie's Pizza Menu

4.5
(125+ Reviews)
$Pizza, Sandwich shop, Vegan
Order Online
Call
(413) 256-6100
Order Online

  • Apps & Sides

    • Chicken Fingers with Fries

      Chicken tenders, fried golden brown and tossed on a bed of french fries.
      $11.45

    • French Fries

      Perfection.
      $5.20

    • Onion Rings

      Rings of onion, breaded and fried.
      $5.20

    • Sampler

      Wings, fries, jalapeño poppers, mozzarella sticks. Plus all the sides for dipping (bleu cheese, honey mustard, marinara).
      $10.90

    • Breadsticks

      Topped with, oil & garlic sauce, Romano & mozzarella cheese (these are not mozzarella sticks). Served with a side of marinara.
      $6.25

    • Side of Marinara

      Red sauce, pizza sauce, marinara...
      $1.15

    • Side of Bleu Cheese

      Sibie's house-made bleu cheese - goes with just about anything.
      $2.30

    • Side of Wings Sauce

      We make our own Buffalo sauce... And its extra, extra hot sibling, 1m.
      $1.15

    • Side of Dressing

      Get your dressing on.
      $1.15

    • Side of Vegan Ranch

      The very popular, house-made vegan ranch dressing.
      $2.30

    • Deep River Potato Chips

      A Single bag of deep river potato chips.
      $2.60

    • Potato Skins

      Five to an order, served with a cup of sour cream. Pro tip: great with bacon & cheddar. Vegan option comes with vegan cheddar & sour cream.
      $9.15

    • Mozzarella Sticks

      Six to an order, served with a cup of sauce (these are not breadsticks).
      $7.50

  • Salads

    • Caesar Salad

      Romain, onion, homemade crouton served with Caesar dressing on the side.
      $10.05

    • Spinach Salad #1

      Spinach, bleu cheese crumbles, onion, mushroom, peppers, and croutons. Your choice of dressing, on the side.
      $10.35

    • Party Size Tossed Salad

      An extra large version of our tossed salad. Serves roughly 7-10 people. All salads are served with choice of dressing. *Temporarily out of garlic bread*.
      $26.45

    • Party Size Greek Salad

      An extra large version of our Greek salad. Serves roughly 7-10 people. Served with Greek dressing. *Temporarily out of garlic bread*.
      $27.60

    • Greek Salad #2

      Vegan. Romain, tomato, onion, kalamata olive, and vegan Parmesan. Served with Greek dressing on the side.
      $12.10

    • Spinach Salad #2

      Vegan. Spinach, vegan bleu cheese crumbles, onion, mushroom, peppers, and croutons. Your choice of dressing, on the side.
      $12.10

    • Tossed Salad

      Sibie's house salad. Served with your choice of dressing.
      $10.05

    • Greek Salad #1

      Romain, tomato, onion, kalamata olive, and feta served with Greek dressing on the side.
      $10.65

  • 12' Cheese or Custom Pizza

    • 12' Cheese Pizza

      Plain cheese Pizza cut into 6 slices.
      $14.40

    • 12' Custom Pizza

      Select your own toppings.
      $14.40

  • 12' Specialty Pizza

    • 12' Florentine

      Vegan. Baby spinach, artichoke, vegan chick'n, onion, tomato, vegan mozzarella, with oil & garlic sauce.
      $21.85

    • 12' Southwest

      Vegan. Beefy crumbles, sautéed onion & green pepper, jalapeño, corn, spices, with vegan cheddar & sour cream.
      $21.85

    • 12' Mediterranean

      Vegan. Freshly picked baby spinach, kalamata olive, onion, garlic, oregano, tomato, with vegan mozzarella and vegan feta.
      $21.85

    • 12' Vegetarian

      Vegetarian. Mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive, broccoli.
      $18.95

    • 12' Mediterranean Veg

      Spinach, black olive, onion, garlic, oregano, feta tomato.
      $18.95

    • 12' Spicy Bleu

      Spicy. Bleu cheese, spicy Buffalo chicken, onion.
      $18.95

    • 12' Mexican

      Hamburger, onion, tomato, jalapeño, black olive, cheddar, Mexican spices.
      $18.95

    • 12' Shepherd's Pie

      Hamburger, potato, corn, cheddar, garlic.
      $18.95

    • 12' Combo

      Pepperoni, sausage, Hamburger, mushroom, onion, green pepper.
      $18.95

    • 12' Ranch

      Bacon, tomato, ranch dressing, mozzarella, Romano cheese.
      $18.95

    • 12' Chicken Taco

      Spicy chicken, onions, tomatoes, tortilla chips, sour cream, cheddar, jalapeño.
      $18.95

    • 12' Greek

      Spinach, garlic, onion, mushroom, feta on spinach crust.
      $18.95

    • 12' Garden Potato

      Potato, broccoli and cheddar on whole wheat crust.
      $18.95

    • 12' Basil & Tomato

      Fresh basil, tomato, garlic, Romano.
      $18.95

    • 12' Lauri's Favorite

      Fresh spinach, broccoli, mushroom, artichoke & tomato, on our original, house-made spinach crust.
      $18.95

    • 12' The Supreme

      Pick any 10 toppings - Like a Boss.
      $25.55

    • 12' Basil Tomato

      Vegan. Freshly picked basil, tomato, and fresh garlic, with vegan mozzarella & vegan Parmesan.
      $21.85

    • 12' Combo

      Vegan. Onion, green pepper, mushroom, vegan pepperoni, vegan sausage, and beefy crumbles, with vegan mozzarella.
      $21.85

    • 12' Taco

      Vegan. Spicy vegan chick'n, onion, tomato, tortilla chips, jalapeño, with vegan cheddar & sour cream.
      $22.15

  • 16' Cheese or Custom Pizza

    • Two Large Cheese Special

      Our classic two large cheese pizza special. *Requests for additional toppings are politely declined. (No additional toppings allowed)*.
      $26.45

    • 16' Cheese Pizza

      Plain cheese Pizza cut into 8 slices. (For the two large cheese special, pick 'Two large cheese special' - to add toppings, pick '16' custom pizza').
      $18.65

    • 16' Custom Pizza

      Select your own toppings.
      $18.65

  • 16' Specialty Pizza

    • 16' Florentine

      Vegan. Baby spinach, artichoke, vegan chick'n, onion, tomato, vegan mozzarella, with oil & garlic sauce.
      $28.99

    • 16' Mediterranean

      Vegan. Freshly picked baby spinach, kalamata olive, onion, garlic, oregano, tomato, with vegan mozzarella and vegan Parmesan.
      $28.99

    • 16' Southwest

      Vegan. Beefy crumbles, onion, green pepper, jalapeño, corn, spices, with Vegan cheddar & sour cream.
      $28.99

    • 16' Vegetarian

      Vegetarian. Mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive, broccoli.
      $26.69

    • 16' Mediterranean Veg

      Spinach, black olives, onion, garlic, oregano, feta tomato.
      $26.69

    • 16' Spicy Bleu

      Spicy. Bleu cheese, spicy Buffalo chicken, onion.
      $26.69

    • 16' Mexican

      Hamburger, onion, tomato, jalapeño, black olive, cheddar, Mexican spices.
      $26.69

    • 16' Shepherd's Pie

      Hamburger, potato, corn, cheddar, garlic.
      $26.69

    • 16' Combo

      Pepperoni, sausage, Hamburger, mushroom, onion, green pepper.
      $26.69

    • 16' Ranch

      Bacon, tomato, ranch dressing, mozzarella, Romano cheese.
      $26.69

    • 16' Chicken Taco

      Spicy chicken, onion, tomato, tortilla chips, sour cream, cheddar, jalapeño.
      $26.69

    • 16' Greek

      Spinach, garlic, onion, mushroom, feta on spinach crust.
      $26.69

    • 16' Garden Potato

      Potato, broccoli and cheddar on whole wheat crust.
      $26.69

    • 16' Basil & Tomato

      Fresh basil, tomato, garlic, Romano.
      $26.69

    • 16' Lauri's Favorite

      Fresh spinach, broccoli, mushroom, artichoke & tomato, on our original, house-made spinach crust.
      $26.69

    • 16' the Supreme

      Pick any 10 toppings - Like a Boss.
      $35.95

    • 16' Basil Tomato

      Vegan. Freshly picked basil, tomato, and fresh garlic, with vegan mozzarella & vegan Parmesan.
      $28.99

    • 16' Vegan Combo

      Vegan. Onion, green pepper, mushroom, vegan pepperoni, vegan sausage, and beefy crumbles, with vegan mozzarella.
      $28.99

    • 16' Taco

      Vegan. Spicy vegan chick'n, onion, tomato, tortilla chips, jalapeño, with vegan cheddar & sour cream.
      $29.25

  • Vegan (All)

    • Buffalo Tempeh

      Vegan. Buffalo tempeh served with a side of vegan ranch.
      $7.99

    • Crispy Tofu Bites

      Vegan. Fried* tofu bites covered in your choice of sauce, served with a side of vegan ranch. *Fried in a vegan-only fryer.
      $7.75

    • Eggplant Parm Sub

      Vegan. House-made breaded eggplant, fried*, with marinara, sautéed onion, and green pepper, and topped with vegan mozzarella, toasted. *Fried in a vegan-only fryer.
      $9.79

    • Chicken Parm Sub

      Vegan. Vegan chicken patty with house-made marinara, sautéed onion, and green pepper, and topped with vegan mozzarella, toasted.
      $9.79

    • Meatball Sub

      Vegan. Vegan meatballs with house-made marinara sauce and vegan mozzarella, toasted.
      $9.79

    • Taco Pizza

      Vegan. Spicy vegan chick'n, onion, tomato, tortilla chips, jalapeño, with vegan cheddar & sour cream.
      $22.15

    • Florentine Pizza

      Vegan. Baby spinach, artichoke, vegan chicken, onion, tomato, vegan mozzarella, with Oil & garlic sauce.
      $21.85

    • Mediterranean Pizza

      Vegan. Freshly picked baby spinach, kalamata olive, onion, garlic, oregano, tomato, with vegan mozzarella and vegan Parmesan.
      $21.85

    • Southwest Pizza

      Vegan. Burger bits, onion, green pepper, jalapeño, corn, spices, with vegan cheddar & sour cream.
      $21.85

    • Side of Vegan Ranch

      Vegan. Sibie's house-made vegan ranch. #Staffpick.
      $2.30

    • Greek Salad

      Vegan. Romain, tomato, onion, kalamata olive, and vegan Parmesan. Served with Greek dressing on the side.
      $12.10

    • Spinach Salad

      Vegan. Spinach, vegan bleu cheese crumbles, onion, mushroom, peppers, and croutons. Your choice of dressing, on the side.
      $12.10

  • Wings

    • Boneless Wings

      Comes in 5's, with a side of bleu cheese.
      $7.99

    • Bone-in Wings

      Comes in 6's, with a side of house-made bleu cheese.
      $10.35

  • Subs

    • Eggplant Parm Sub

      House-made breaded eggplant, fried and topped with fresh marinara, provolone cheese, toasted.
      $8.65

    • Ham & Cheese Sub

      Slices of ham, topped with provolone cheese - you pick the rest!
      $8.65

    • Hot Sausage Sub

      Hot sausage links, topped with marinara & provolone cheese - toasted.
      $8.65

    • Italian Sub

      Slices of ham & hard salami, topped with provolone cheese - you pick the rest!
      $8.65

    • Meatball Sub

      Delicious balls of meat, topped with marinara & provolone cheese - toasted.
      $8.65

    • Turkey Sub

      Sliced Turkey breast - you pick the rest!
      $8.65

    • Buffalo Chicken Sub

      Spicy chicken, bleu cheese dressing, provolone cheese.
      $9.45

    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

      Sliced chicken, bacon, provolone cheese, onion, lettuce, tomato.
      $9.45

    • Chicken Caesar Sub

      Caesar dressing, sliced chicken breast, lettuce, onion, provolone cheese.
      $9.45

    • Chicken Pesto Sub

      Sliced chicken breast, homemade pesto, sautéed onions, mushrooms, green peppers, provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
      $9.45

    • Tuna Lovers Sub

      Fresh made tuna salad, cheddar cheese and you pick the rest!
      $10.00

    • BLT Sub

      Bacon, lettuce & tomato.
      $8.65

    • Chicken Parm Sub

      Crispy chicken cutlets, topped with marinara & provolone cheese - toasted.
      $8.65

  • Stuffed Breads

    • Pepperoni Stuffed Bread

      Mozzarella and provolone stuffed bread.
      $6.85

    • Choose 1 Topping Stuffed Bread

      Mozzarella and provolone stuffed bread.
      $6.85

    • Broccoli & Cheddar Stuffed Bread

      Mozzarella and provolone stuffed bread.
      $6.85

    • Ham & Cheese Stuffed Bread

      Mozzarella and provolone stuffed bread.
      $6.85

  • Calzones

    • Create Your Own Calzone

      Choose up to 3 ingredients. All calzones come with ricotta and mozzarella cheese and a side of homemade marinara.
      $10.35

    • Create Two Calzones

      Choose up to 3 ingredients. Served with ricotta and mozzarella cheese (inside) and a cup of marinara (outside).
      $18.95

    • Jumbo Calzone

      This jumbo calzone is made with the dough of a large pizza. Choose up to 3 ingredients. Served with ricotta and mozzarella cheese (inside) 3 cups of marinara (outside).
      $18.90

    • Plain Cheese Calzone

      A calzone stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella cheese and a side of homemade marinara.
      $10.05

    • Specialty Calzones

      Pick your specialty calzone. All calzones come with ricotta and mozzarella cheese (unless vegan) and a side of homemade marinara.
      $12.65

  • Party Size Cheese / Custom Pizza

    • Cheese Party Pizza

      16' x 24' sheet pizza, cut into 28 square slices. Serves roughly 7-10 people. Plain cheese pizza.
      $28.20

    • Custom Party Pizza

      16' x 24' sheet pizza, cut into 28 square slices. Serves roughly 7-10 people. Select your own toppings.
      $28.20

  • Party Size Specialty Pizza

    • Party Florentine

      Vegan. Baby spinach, artichoke, vegan chicken, onion, tomato, vegan mozzarella, with oil & garlic sauce.
      $40.49

    • Party Mediterranean

      Vegan. Freshly picked baby spinach, kalamata olive, onion, garlic, oregano, tomato, with vegan mozzarella and vegan feta.
      $40.49

    • Party Southwest

      Vegan. Burger bits, sautéed onion & green pepper, jalapeño, corn, spices, with Vegan cheddar & sour cream.
      $40.49

    • Party Vegetarian

      Vegetarian. Mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive, and broccoli. Served sheet-style in squares.
      $37.60

    • Party Mediterranean Veg

      Spinach, black olives, onion, garlic, oregano, and feta tomato. Served sheet-style in squares.
      $37.60

    • Party Spicy Bleu

      Bleu cheese, spicy Buffalo chicken, and onion. Served sheet-style in squares.
      $37.60

    • Party Mexican

      Hamburger, onion, tomato, jalapeño, black olives, cheddar, Mexican spices. Served sheet-style in squares.
      $37.60

    • Party Shepherd's Pie

      Hamburger, potato, corn, cheddar, and garlic. Served sheet-style in squares.
      $37.60

    • Party Combo

      Pepperoni, sausage, Hamburger, mushroom, onion, green pepper. Served sheet-style in squares.
      $37.60

    • Party Ranch

      Bacon, tomato, ranch dressing, mozzarella, and Romano cheese. Served sheet-style in squares.
      $37.60

    • Party Chicken Taco

      Spicy chicken, onion, tomato, tortilla chips, sour cream, cheddar, and jalapeño. Served sheet-style in squares.
      $37.60

    • Party Greek

      Spinach, garlic, onion, mushroom, and feta on spinach crust. Served sheet-style in squares.
      $37.60

    • Party Garden Potato

      Potato, broccoli and cheddar on whole wheat crust. Served sheet-style in squares.
      $37.60

    • Party Basil & Tomato

      Fresh basil, tomato, garlic, Romano. Served sheet-style in squares.
      $37.60

    • Party Supreme

      Pick any 10 toppings - Like a Boss. Served sheet-style in squares.
      $50.25

    • Party Basil Tomato

      Vegan. Freshly picked basil, tomato, and fresh garlic, with vegan mozzarella & vegan Parmesan.
      $40.49

    • Party Combo

      Vegan. Onion, green pepper, mushroom, vegan pepperoni, vegan sausage, and beefy crumbles, with Vegan mozzarella.
      $40.49

    • Party Taco

      Vegan. Spicy vegan chick'n, onion, tomato, tortilla chips, jalapeño, with vegan cheddar & sour cream.
      $40.75

  • Gluten Free Pizza

    • 10' Gluten Free Cheese Pizza

      Gluten free. Plain cheese pizza. *Gluten Free crust is prepared in a kitchen where there are also flour products*.
      $12.35

    • 10' Gluten Free Custom Pizza

      Gluten free. Select your own toppings. *Gluten Free crust is prepared in a kitchen where there are also flour products*.
      $12.35

  • Dessert (The Sweet Stuff)

    • Maple Valley Ice Cream (1 Pint)

      Maple valley creamery is a local (Hadley) company selling delicious ice cream from happy healthy cows! Flavors vary and sell out - *you can write a second choice in the notes section.
      $6.90

    • Maple Valley Ice Cream (2 Pints)

      Maple valley creamery is a local (Hadley) company selling delicious ice cream from happy healthy cows! Flavors vary. Please select your first & second choice.
      $12.65

  • Beverages

    • 2-Liter Soda

      $4.00

    • 12 Oz Can

      $2.00

    • 20 Oz Bottle

      $3.15

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Mission Cantina
Mission Cantina
4.4
(898 Reviews)
Mexican, Burrito, Cocktail bar
The Moan & Dove
The Moan & Dove
4.6
(264 Reviews)
Bar
El Comalito (Amherst)
El Comalito (Amherst)
4.6
(718 Reviews)
Salvadoran, Mexican
Lemon Bakery
Lemon Bakery
4.8
(26 Reviews)
Bakery
Kern Kafe
Kern Kafe
4.6
(11 Reviews)
Cafe
The Bridge
The Bridge
4.0
(7 Reviews)
Cafe
Prescott Tavern
Prescott Tavern
3.8
(13 Reviews)
Lounge
Atkins Farms Country Market
Atkins Farms Country Market
4.6
(2,606 Reviews)
Bakery, Deli
Atkins Farms Bakery
Atkins Farms Bakery
4.7
(158 Reviews)
Bakery
Orchard Run Ice Cream
Orchard Run Ice Cream
4.8
(13 Reviews)
Ice cream shop
https://www.sibiespizza.com/
(413) 256-6100

481 West St, Amherst, MA 01002

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms