Serafina's Pizzeria

I know everyone has their own opinion - so let's just start THERE. In MY opinion - Serafina has the best NY pizza in Jacksonville. Probably the best pizza in all of NE Florida. Yes, others try and come remarkably close SOMETIMES - Serafina's is consistently EXCELLENT. yes, I'm a pizza snob. you got a problem wit dat?

I wanted to try this pizzeria based on others’ suggestions on a Jax foodie Facebook page. I told my friends and family to meet us to try it. From the minute we walked in, they made us feel so welcomed. The garlic knots are HUGE!! I’ve never seen garlic knots this big! They were delicious. Each one was the size of a biscuit and really buttery. There were six of us so we ordered slices and also a pie. The hot honey pizza was huge!! Each bite was delicious. The crust was perfectly crispy and stayed crispy with each bite. This is a true NY pizzeria and the slices taste just like the slices in NYC. My husband’s family lives in midtown Manhattan and this is as close as you’re going to get to a NY slice. The owners are from Brooklyn and so friendly. Cathy spent some time talking to us and is such a lovely lady. We will definitely be back. My new favorite pizzeria. I also like the service a lot better than Tony D’s which was our go to for so many years. We all agreed that this place is a lot friendlier with better pizza. As buisness owners ourselves, we love to spend money where we feel appreciated as customers. 5 stars from start to finish! ⭐️

The best ever. We love this place and the owners/staff. Xoxo

BEST GLUTEN-FREE PIZZA***** We had an incredible experience at Sarafinas today. The service was amazing and the food was SOOO delicious. The gluten-free pizza was the best pizza I’ve had in Florida. My family ordered a large pepperoni pizza pie and some specialty slices. They kept saying it was the best pizza they’ve had as well. We have visited many “Italian” places around here and this is by far the best. We have been to Italy a couple of times and this is definitely an authentic taste of Italy. We loved the friendly and welcoming staff. This is our new favorite pizza place thanks to some great friends who introduced us to Sarafinas!❤️

Real Brooklyn pizza

First time there. Felt like we had known them forever. The owner, Cathy was wonderful. She made sure we had everything we needed and was warm and friendly. Pizza is excellent! Caprese salad excellent (nice touch with the peppers) and zeppolis were outstanding. We will be back.

They have the Best Buffalo chicken pizza in town! I can not drive bye without stopping in for a slice!

Delicious food and amazing customer service! Really enjoyed eating here!

The dough is great! Sauce Is lacking and very bland. Garlic rolls are over cooked and under sauced. The meatballs were over worked to the point of borderline a patty but over cooked. Little to no flavor with meatballs. We spent over $106 and drive 20 minutes because of the reviews. We will not again.

Me and my son love this place!