Primo Water Ice of Short Hills

This place is fantastic and open all year!

Today, I got the brownie ice-cream on a waffle cone! It was super delicious. There’s some seating in there too, if you want to hang around and eat your ice cream there! I highly recommend.

I ordered a Cherry Gelato and was served a melting, leaking mess. It was so bad I threw in the trash outside the store.

I have been to this place over 100 times. Amazing Ice cream, for very cheap. Love all of the workers here too.

Is this supposed to be home made ice cream? The butter pecan and the cookies and cream tastes high in sugar. The two flavors I tried did not have that buttery homemade taste. 2 tries and I’m done. I will drive elsewhere for that homemade taste.

Water ice was mediocre at best. Had mint chocolate chip and chocolate chocolate chip. Although they have dairy, the consistency was somewhat grainy. Blah flavors. Nowhere near the quality of Sundaes in Berlin.

Good ice cream, this ice cream place however isn't that special, there certainly are better places around the area.