Pizza My Heart Menu

4.3

(250+ Reviews)

$Pizza, Italian

Customer Favorites Pizzas Salads & Snacks Pizza Slices Drinks & Desserts Sides Utensils and Condiments

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Big Sur
  Whole cloves of roasted Gilroy garlic, hand- sliced Portobello mushrooms, California made Italian sausage and pepperoni. Accented with green onions and our own spice blend. Our most popular pizza.
  $25.92+
- Old-School Pepperoni Pizza
  Artisan pepperoni you can feel good about. It's nitrate and nitrite free. A Santa Cruz surfer's favorite.
  $21.06+
- Cheese Pizza or Create Your Own
  Delicious as is, or choose your own toppings
  $19.44+
- Old-School Pepperoni Slice
  Delicious cupping pepperoni with lots of cheese on hand-tossed crust
  $5.94+
- Big Sur Slice
  A slice of our most popular pizza, with lots of roasted garlic cloves, pepperoni, sausage and portobello mushrooms.
  $6.48+
- Cheese Slice
  Made with real California cheese and classic great taste
  $5.40+
- Chicken Wings
  Oven-roasted chicken wings with a side of buffalo sauce or BBQ sauce. Ask for our house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing.
  $11.87+
- Maui Wowie
  Aloha! Real Canadian Bacon with lots of juicy Pineapple.
  $22.68+
- Maui Wowie Slice
  Real Canadian Bacon and juicy pineapple
  $6.48+
- Cheesy Stix
  Our Bread Stix baked with a generous helping of California mozzarella cheese.
  $11.34+
Pizzas
- Cheese Pizza or Create Your Own
  Delicious as is, or choose your own toppings
  $19.44+
- Create Your Own Heart Shaped Pizza
  A heart shaped cheese pizza with up to two toppings to give someone a pizza your heart!
  $32.13+
- Vegan Big Sur
  40 Cloves of Roasted Garlic, Field Roast Vegan Pepperoni, Beyond Meat Italian Sausage, Portobello Mushrooms, and Green Onions. Made with Miyoko's plant-based mozzarella.
  $25.92+
- Old-School Pepperoni Pizza
  Artisan pepperoni you can feel good about. It's nitrate and nitrite free. A Santa Cruz surfer's favorite.
  $21.06+
- Mt. Diablo (v)
  Miyoko's vegan mozzarella, Beyond Meat Italian Sausage, freshly sliced mushrooms, pickled peppers, fresh parsley and Italian seasonings.
  $25.92+
- Vegan CYO
  Delicious as is, or choose your own toppings
  $21.06+
- Big Sur
  Whole cloves of roasted Gilroy garlic, hand- sliced Portobello mushrooms, California made Italian sausage and pepperoni. Accented with green onions and our own spice blend. Our most popular pizza.
  $25.92+
- Cowell's Combo
  A legendary surf break and pizza. Pepperoni, Sausage, Olives, Mushrooms, Onions & Bells.
  $25.92+
- Maui Wowie
  Aloha! Real Canadian Bacon with lots of juicy Pineapple.
  $22.68+
- Maverick's All Meat
  A Carnivore’s delight. Pepperoni, Sausage, Salami & Canadian Bacon.
  $25.92+
- D'Lex Chicken & Bacon
  Grilled, hormone-free chicken breast, all-natural bacon, local mushrooms, parmesan cheese, green onions with a creamy garlic white sauce.
  $25.92+
- Fort Point
  Light Tomato & Pesto Sauce (contains almonds) with Roma Tomatoes, Chicken, Ricotta, Sausage, Artichoke, Basil & Herbs.
  $25.92+
- Watsonville Apple
  Green Apple Slices, Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Green Onions, Gorgonzola, Olive Oil, & Garlic.
  $25.92+
- Rockaway BBQ Chicken
  BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Red Onion, Cilantro.
  $25.92+
- Doheny Sweet Heat
  Savory & Sweet with Pepperoni, Sausage, Pickled Peppers, Ricotta and a drizzle of Hot Honey
  $25.92+
- Figgy Piggy
  Bacon, Feta Cheese, Black Figs, Sage, Olive Oil & Garlic.
  $25.92+
- Sunset Beach
  Canadian Bacon, Bacon, Red Onions, Bells & Pineapple.
  $25.92+
- Depot Hill
  Sundried Tomatoes, Pesto & Chicken.
  $25.92+
- Davenport
  Sausage, Spinach, Garlic, Mushrooms & Onions.
  $25.92+
- Pleasure Point
  Garlic, Roma Tomatoes, Spinach & Chicken.
  $25.92+
- The Hook
  Super Veggie Special - Tomatoes, Olives, Bells, Mushrooms, Artichoke, Red Onion & Parmesan.
  $25.92+
- Virgin Creek
  Fresh Basil, Garlic, Ricotta & Roma Tomatoes.
  $25.92+
- Manresa
  Fresh, locally-grown basil, garlic, sliced Roma tomatoes topped with hand-scooped mounds of creamy Ricotta cheese.
  $24.30+
- Pesto
  Our own recipe, made with Basil, Garlic, Parmesan & Almonds.
  $22.68+
- Little Sur
  Award Winning! 40 Cloves of Roasted Garlic, Organic Tomato Pizza Sauce, Roasted Red Peppers, Portobello Mushrooms, Green Onions, Cherry Tomatoes & Herbs.
  $25.92+
- Castroville
  Pesto, Spinach, Artichoke, Cherry Tomatoes & Feta Cheese.
  $25.92+
- Prima
  Roma Tomatoes, Feta, Olives and Parmesan.
  $22.68+
- Linda Mar
  Spinach, Garlic, Artichokes, Broccoli, Olives & Romas.
  $25.92+
Salads & Snacks
- Mixed Greens
  Mixed Baby Greens, Carrots, Cucumbers, Tomatoes & Broccoli
  $8.10+
- Greek Salad
  Romaine Lettuce, Onions, Kalamata Olives, Feta Cheese, Artichokes, Red Onion & Tomatoes.
  $8.10+
- Classic Caesar Salad
  Romaine Lettuce, Garlic Croutons, Parmesan & a Great Classic Caesar Dressing.
  $8.64+
- Chicken Caesar Salad
  Grilled Chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Garlic Croutons, Parmesan & a Great Classic Caesar Dressing
  $10.53+
- Chicken Walnut Salad
  Mixed Baby Greens, Candied Walnuts, Chicken, Gorgonzola with our own Balsamic Dressing
  $10.53+
- Bread Stix
  Our own bread stix, freshly baked with olive oil, California cheese and a dusting of our own spice blend. Ask for ranch dressing or pizza sauce.
  $9.18+
- Cheesy Stix
  Our Bread Stix baked with a generous helping of California mozzarella cheese.
  $11.34+
- 50/50 Wings
  6 Bone-In and 6 Boneless Wings
  $19.43+
- Chicken Wings
  Oven-roasted chicken wings with a side of buffalo sauce or BBQ sauce. Ask for our house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing.
  $11.87+
- Boneless Wings
  Oven baked breaded boneless wings made from 100% all white meat.
  $11.87+
Pizza Slices
- Cheese Slice
  Made with real California cheese and classic great taste
  $5.40+
- Old-School Pepperoni Slice
  Delicious cupping pepperoni with lots of cheese on hand-tossed crust
  $5.94+
- Big Sur Slice
  A slice of our most popular pizza, with lots of roasted garlic cloves, pepperoni, sausage and portobello mushrooms.
  $6.48+
- Maui Wowie Slice
  Real Canadian Bacon and juicy pineapple
  $6.48+
- Super Veggie Slice
  Tomatoes, Olives, Bells, Mushrooms, Artichoke, Red Onion & Parmesan.
  $6.48+
- DLex Chicken & Bacon Slice
  Hormone-Free Chicken, Bacon, mushrooms, garlic and green onions with white sauce
  $6.48+
- Manresa Slice
  White Pizza with Fresh Basil, Garlic, Romas & Ricotta
  $5.94+
- Pepperoni Sausage Slice
  Delicious old-school pepperoni and zesty Italian sausage
  $6.48+
- Doheny Slice
  Dohney Slice
  $5.94+
- Classic $5 T-shirt!
  Iconic PMH t-shirt!
  $6.48+
Drinks & Desserts
- Kook-ie
  Freshly baked oversized Chocolate Chip cookie with 6 delicious slices.
  $8.10+
- Cinna-Bomb
  Pizza dough baked with cinnamon and spices to a rich, bubbly goodness, then topped with a drizzle of icing. Sliced for sharing.
  $8.10+
- 20oz Coke
  20oz Coke
  $3.35+
- 20oz Diet Coke
  20oz Diet Coke
  $3.35+
- 20oz Sprite
  20oz Sprite
  $3.35+
- Bottled Water
  20oz Dasani
  $2.81+
- Milk
  8oz Horizon Organic Low Fat Milk
  $2.81+
- Chocolate Milk
  8oz Horizon Chocolate Organic Low Fat Milk
  $2.81+
- Bottled Rootbeer
  Bottled Rootbeer
  $3.35+
- Topo Chico
  12oz Sparkling Water
  $3.35+
Sides
- Side of BBQ Sauce
  Side of BBQ Sauce
  $0.54+
- Side of Pizza Sauce
  Side of Pizza Sauce
  $0.54+
- Side of Ranch
  Side of Ranch
  $0.54+
- Side of Pesto Ranch
  Side of Pesto Ranch
  $0.54+
- Side of Bleu Cheese
  Side of Bleu Cheese
  $0.54+
- Side of Jalapenos
  Side of Jalapenos
  $0.54+
- Side of Olives
  Side of Olives
  $0.54+
- Side of Pesto
  Side of Pesto
  $1.08+
- Side of Pineapple
  Side of Pineapple
  $0.54+
- PMH Hot Sauce
  PMH Hot Sauce
  $1.62+
Utensils and Condiments
- Parmesan and Peppers
  Add on packets of parmesan and/or peppers
- Plates/Napkins/Utensils
  Add on utensils, plates. or napkins