Pizza Man Milwaukee

Great pizza. We had a great time.

Recommend getting a booth, as the chairs are pretty uncomfortable. Crust on pizza is good as was the sauce and cheese flavor, but fyi the veggies are barely cooked, if at all. We thought it was a fluke the first time, but I guess that's just how they put veggies on their pizza? Eggplant fries were delicious, but the skin falls off a little easy. Server was fast, and polite, and honest in letting us know a smaller portion of the eggplant fries would be a good portion for four as opposed to trying to upsell. More of an ambience restaurant than a place for good grub, but if a steam punk atmosphere with empty bottle chandeliers is more important than food quality (no judgement, some people go out for ambience more than the food), maybe this place is for you.

Too greasy (from the apps to the pasta and pizza). Not appetizing no vegan options. My toddler vomited immediately eating their pizza and fries.

Friendly service. Delicious food came out quickly. What more could you want?

Pretty fair experience across the board. Topher pizza was fire. Good weekly specials. Huge place that’s great to stop for groups. There were two birthday parties when we were there. Careful parking around here. Myself and two others in my party parked right in front of the front door of the place on Friday, 2/16. Multiple car windows were smashed.

Honestly went into Pizza Man a little hesitant because I loved Stubbys so much and was sad to see them go. But Pizza Man was excellent wow. Chicken parm was very tasty. Light on the marinara which was nice. The eggplant fries were pretty incredible and the large would feed 4 people for sure. Wine was delicious and the bbq chicken pizza was perfectly done. Nothing bad to say :) Will be returning Kid-friendliness: brought out high chair

Not the same vibe as the original, but great pizza and service!