Pizza 51 Menu

4.5

(925+ Reviews)

BYO Slice BYO Pizza Slice 14"18"26"1/2 1/2 Specialty Pizza 16oz Drink 2 ltr 24oz Drink Btl/Can Beverages Salads Sandwiches or Wraps Calzones Appetizers Wine Extras Pastries

BYO Slice
- BYO Slice Cheese
  $5.25
BYO Pizza
- BYO 14"
  Cut into 8 slices, roughly feeds 2-3 adults, based on toppings applied.
  $15.99
- BYO 18"
  Cut into 8 slices, roughly feeds 3-4 adults, based on toppings applied.
  $21.25
- BYO 26"
  Cut into squares for easier handling, feeds roughly 7-8 adults, based upon amount of toppings applied.
  $36.25
- Gluten Free BYO 7.5"
  Individual 7" serving
  $9.99
- .
Slice
- Slice Highway
  Our supreme specialty slice, topped with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives. Limit one substitution per specialty item.
  $7.51
- Slice Cowtown
  Our meatlover's specialty slice, topped with pepperoni, sausage, beef, Canadian bacon, Romano cheese. Limit one substitution per specialty item.
  $7.51
- Slice Veggie
  Our veggie lover's specialty slice, topped with mushrooms, black olives, broccoli, onions, green peppers, spinach. Limit one substitution per specialty item.
  $7.51
- Custom 5 Slice
  Any 5 toppings of your choice!
  $7.51
14"
Our smallest whole pie, cut into 8 slices, typically serves 3-5.
- Highway Special 14"
  Our specialty supreme, topped with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives. Cut into 8 slices, serves 3-5.
  $24.51
- Cowtown Lovers 14"
  Our specialty Meatlover's whole pie, topped with pepperorni, sausage, canadian bacon, beef, romano cheese. Cut into 8 slices, feeds roughly 3-4 adults.
  $24.51
- Veggie Delight 14"
  Our specialty veggie lover's 14" whole pie, topped with mushrooms, black olives, broccoli, onions, green peppers, spinach. Cut into 8 slices, serves 3-5.
  $24.51
18"
Our smallest whole pie, cut into 8 slices, typically serves 3-5.
- Highway Special 18"
  Our specialty supreme, topped with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives. Cut into 8 slices, serves 3-5.
  $29.99
- Cowtown Lovers 18"
  Our specialty Meatlover's whole pie, topped with pepperorni, sausage, canadian bacon, beef, romano cheese. Cut into 8 slices, serves 3-5.
  $29.99
- Veggie Delight 18"
  Our specialty veggie lover's 14" whole pie, topped with mushrooms, black olives, broccoli, onions, green peppers, spinach. Cut into 8 slices, serves 3-5.
  $29.99
26"
Our smallest whole pie, cut into 8 slices, typically serves 3-5.
- Highway Special 26"
  Our specialty supreme, topped with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives. Cut into squares for easier handling, feeds roughly 7-8 adults.
  $53.51
- Cowtown Lovers 26"
  Our specialty Meatlover's whole pie, topped with pepperorni, sausage, canadian bacon, beef, romano cheese. Cut into squares for easier handling, feeds roughly 7-8 adults.
  $53.51
- Veggie Delight 26"
  Our specialty veggie lover's 14" whole pie, topped with mushrooms, black olives, broccoli, onions, green peppers, spinach. Cut into squares for easier handling, feeds roughly 7-8 adults.
  $53.51
1/2 1/2 Specialty Pizza
- BYO Spec. Pizza 14"
  $24.51
- BYO Spec. Pizza 18"
  $29.99
- BYO Spec. Pizza 26"
  $53.51
- .
- .
16oz Drink
DINE-IN ONLY Please only order 16oz drinks via online ordering while on-site, using the QSR Code. Thank you
- 16oz Coke
  $2.49
- 16oz Diet Coke
  $2.49
- 16oz Sprite
  $2.49
- 16oz Diet Dr. Pepper
  $2.49
- 16oz Dr. Pepper
  $2.49
- 16oz Barq's Root Beer
  $2.49
- 16oz Minute Maid Lemonade
  $2.49
- 16oz Coke zero
  $2.49
2 ltr
A limited selection of Coca-Cola's best-selling 2 liters. Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr Pepper. Take one home today!
- Coke
  $4.25
- Dt Coke
  $4.25
- Sprite
  $4.25
24oz Drink
DINE-IN ONLY Please only order 24oz drinks via online ordering while on-site, using the QSR Code. Thank you.
- 24oz Coke
  $2.69
- 24oz Diet Coke
  $2.69
- 24oz Sprite
  $2.69
- 24oz Dr. Pepper
  $2.69
- 24oz Diet Dr. Pepper
  $2.69
- 24oz MinuteMaid Lemonade
  $2.69
- 24oz Barq's RootBeer
  $2.69
- 24oz Coke Zero
  $2.69
Btl/Can Beverages
- Red Bull
  $2.99
- IZZE
  $2.51
- Juice Box
  Pick your flavor, Fruit Punch, Crisp Apple, or Apple Grape!
  $0.99
- Powerade
  $2.75
- Btl Water
  $0.99
- Root 66 Root Beer
  $2.75
- Root 66 Cream Soda
  $2.75
- Route 66 Orange
  $2.75
- Route 66 Bl Cherry
  $2.75
- Blue Rasberry
  $2.75
- Monster
  $3.50
Salads
- Garden
  A larger version of the side salad. Large enough to be eaten as an entree alone or shared between 2 people who may be ordering additional items. A mixture of iceberg and romaine lettuces, topped with onions, mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, tomatoes, mozzarella and house-made croutons. All salads made to order allowing toppings to be withheld upon request.
  $5.75
- Side Salad
  A smaller version of the Garden salad, the side salad is a mixture of iceberg and romaine lettuces, topped with onions, mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and house-made seasoned croutons. A good portion for one person before enjoying a main entree. All salads made to order allowing toppings to be withheld upon request.
  $3.99
- Caesar
  Available as larger entree size only, the Caesar is a hearty portion of romaine lettuce topped with parmesan cheese and seasoned house-made croutons.
  $5.99
- Spring Mix
  Available as a larger entree size only, the Spring Mix is a mixture of baby greens topped with feta, roma tomatoes, mushrooms and house-made seasoned croutons.
  $5.99
- Salad Tray
  $25.51
Sandwiches or Wraps
All served on your choice of 8" hoagie, either sourdough or wheat, with choice of Swiss, American, or Provolone cheese. Except for the always-toasted Meatball and Chicken Subs, all come with choice of lettuce, onion, tomato, mayo, and mustard. Served warm or cold. All sandwiches served with deli chips and a pickle spear on the side.
- Ham Sub
  Served on 8" hoagie, either sourdough or wheat, or in a sun-dried tomato wrap, with choice of Swiss, American, or Provolone cheese and choice of lettuce, onion, tomato, mayo, and mustard. Served with deli chips and a pickle spear on the side. Served warm or cold.
  $8.51
- Turkey Sub
  Served on 8" hoagie, either sourdough or wheat, or in a sun-dried tomato wrap, with choice of Swiss, American, or Provolone cheese and choice of lettuce, onion, tomato, mayo, and mustard. Served with deli chips and a pickle spear on the side. Served warm or cold.
  $9.51
- Roast Beef Sub
  Served on 8" hoagie, either sourdough or wheat, or in a sun-dried tomato wrap, with choice of Swiss, American, or Provolone cheese and choice of lettuce, onion, tomato, mayo, and mustard. Served with deli chips and a pickle spear on the side. Served warm or cold.
  $9.51
- G3 Sub
  Includes meats of ham, turkey, roast beef, served on 8" hoagie of sourdough or wheat bread, or a sun-dried tomato wrap. Choice of Swiss, American, or Provolone cheese and choice of lettuce, onion, tomato, mayo, and mustard. Served either warm or cold with deli chips and a pickle spear on the side.
  $9.99
- Italian Sub
  Includes meats of capicola, ham, and pepperoni, served on 8" hoagie of sourdough or wheat bread, or a sun-dried tomato wrap. Choice of Swiss, American, or Provolone cheese and choice of lettuce, onion, tomato, mayo, and mustard. Served either warm or cold with deli chips and a pickle spear on the side.
  $9.51
- Chicken Sub
  Always toasted and served on 8" sourdough or wheat hoagie, topped with choice of melted Swiss, American, provolone, or mozzarella, and house-made marinara. Served with chips and a pickle spear. (Not available as a wrap.)
  $7.51
- Meatball Sub
  Always toasted and served on 8" sourdough or wheat hoagie, topped with choice of melted Swiss, American, provolone, or mozzarella, and house-made marinara. Served with chips and a pickle spear. (Not available as a wrap.)
  $7.51
Calzones
- Calzones
  hand-tossed: please allow extra prep time Mozzarella & Ricotta cheese additional toppings .75
  $10.99
Appetizers
- Breadsticks
  3 sticks of seasoned, house-made dough, cut into 6 pieces, served with a side of marina sauce. Top with garlic, mozzarella, or both!
  $3.15
- Toasted Ravioli
  6 seasoned pasta squares filled with meat and cheese, served with a side of house-made marinara sauce for dipping.
  $5.25
- Plain Stx W/ Soup
  $5.75
- 6 Count Wings
  $10.00
- 12 Count Wings
  $20.00
- Ranch
  $0.75
- Blue Cheese
  $0.75
Wine
WINE BY THE GLASS IS FOR DINE-IN ONLY. Please only order wine by the glass via online ordering while on-site, using the QSR Code. Thank you
- Chardonnay
  $6.00
- Sauv Blanc
  $6.00
- Jacob's Cab Sav
  $6.00
- Rosé
  $6.50
- Red Tree Pinot Noir
  $6.00
- Archer Roose Cans
  $8.00
Extras
- Ranch
  $0.75
- House
  $0.75
- Blue Cheese
  $0.75
- Honey Mustard
  $0.75
- Ceasar
  $0.75
- Bag of Chips
  $1.00
- One Meatball
  $1.50
- Sauce
  $0.25
- Honey
  $0.50
- Drink Upcharge
  $0.20
- 18" Dough Ball
  $7.50
- 26" Dough Ball
  $10.00
- Red Hat
  $25.00
- Black Hat
  $22.00
- Coaster
  $10.00
- Shirts
  $20.00
Pastries
With our partner Clock Tower Bakery, located in downtown Overland Park, we offer a variety of made-from-scratch desserts, baked fresh and delivered multiple times each week. Offerings are subject to change often.
- Cookie
  $1.51