Pepi's Pizza

Husband picked up 2 par baked pizzas. Very tasty as they always have been! REMINDER: if cooking right on rack, brush off corn meal or you'll have one Smokey house. I learned my lesson. Very tasty pizza!!!

They must have changed the recipe, this is the worst pizza I had in a long time. Pepi's used to be the best. The whole pizza tastes odd. So disappointing

Very bad experience with the owner ricky, tried to call and resolve the concern and he literally blamed us that it was my dogs hair. He even went as far as to mention that he is a very powerful person that i better tread lightly. I have a recorded phone call with ricky making a threat!!!! People stay away from this place dont get on rickys bad side.stay away from this place he doesnt care about his patrons!!!!!!

Got take out for lunch here today. Excellent service. The guy who helped us was very nice and attentive, he came outside to let me know the pizza was ready since we had been parked outside a couple of minutes, and he made sure I left with plates and napkins. Atmosphere was quaint and unpretentious in the best way. They should be busier! But perhaps it was the time of day. Wish I had remembered to tip, will have to tip double next time. We will definitely be back. If you haven't checked it out yet, you should! Great location the off of greenfield in downtown west allis. Pizza was DELICIOUS. We had the large thin crust with pepperoni, green olive, and onion and it was only $20 even. Don't know if that was some kind of special, but that was an amazing price, especially considering it was a high quality pizza made with clearly fresh ingredients.

Been a customer for 55 years! There’s no pizza like Pepies If you like thin crust and good sausage you will love ❤️ it

I've had the pizza 3 times now, 1st 2 were great, last time not so much. We ordered right after they opened, and were told it would be 50 minutes. I got there 5 minutes early. When I got it home, it looked great, but wasn't very hot. It was apparently done much sooner than 50 minutes, but just sat there. They just need to get their timing right, and all will be good.

Fun family time at Pepi’s! Amazing thin crust! We felt so welcomed with our large group. We even played the piano. Thank you!

Love this place! I eat there and have delivery. Taste is the same as it was years ago on S. 16th Street. Owners/service/delivery guy all amazing people.

I belive it's very unprofessional of a business to have posted hours of operation & then not be open. If you're not going to br open post your adjusted hours. You never know when people have driven in from another community to patronize your business. I will not be going back in hopes that I haven't wasted my time again.