• NEW JERSEY FLAVORS

    • Creme Brulee

      $8.00
      Creme Brulee
    • Bananas Foster

      Our House-made Caramel with Vanilla Mousse and Banana Ice Cream sandwiched between two Cinnamon Cookies
      $8.00
      Bananas Foster
    • Cookies ’N Cream

      Our take on the Classic Ice Cream Sandwich, Vanilla Ice Cream with Chocolate & Vanilla Mousse on Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Cookies ’N Cream
    • Candy Bar

      Our House-made Custard with Banana Butter over a scoop of vanilla ice cream sandwiched with two graham cracker cookies
      $8.00
      Candy Bar
    • Molten Chocolate

      Our Signature all chocolate pie, Chocolate Ice Cream with a layer of Chocolate Mousse sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Molten Chocolate
    • Caramel Brownie

      Our Best Seller from the very start The Salted Caramel Brownie is Vanilla Ice Cream topped with our House-made caramel and fudge brownie bites sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies!
      $8.00
      Caramel Brownie
    • Coffee Toffee

      Our Classic Coffee Ice Cream Sandwich, topped with our House-made Caramel and Toffee Crumble on Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Coffee Toffee
    • Cookie Dough

      One of our most popular! Experience Cookie Dough and Ice Cream like you've never had it before. Two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies, layered with Creamy Chocolate Mousse with house-made cookie dough bites swirled on top of Vanilla Ice Cream.
      $8.00
      Cookie Dough
    • Triple Chocolate Brownie

      For the True Chocolate Lover: Chocolate Ice Cream, Chocolate Mousse, House-made Brownies, sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Triple Chocolate Brownie
    • S'mores

      Peace Pie's frozen take on the American Classic Chocolate Ice Cream with a layer of Chocolate Mousse and Mini Marshmallows sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies!
      $8.00
      S'mores
    • Triple Vanilla

      Creamy Vanilla Mousse over a scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream on our Original Butter Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Triple Vanilla
    • Caramel Apple

      Cinnamon Cookie, Apple Pie Filling, Caramel, Vanilla Ice Cream
      $8.00
      Caramel Apple
    • Peanut Butter Cup

      Peace Pie's Peanut Butter Cup is the perfect combination of Chocolate Ice Cream and our Deliciously Creamy Peanut Butter Mousse on two crispy Butter Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Peanut Butter Cup
    • Key Lime Pie

      Our Delicious Key Lime Pie Mousse with a Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream Served Between Our Crunchy Cinnamon Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Key Lime Pie
    • Chocolate Covered Strawberry

      Chocolate Cookie, Chocolate Chips, Chocolate Mousse, Strawberry Ice Cream
      $8.00
      Chocolate Covered Strawberry
    • Coconut Cream

      Shortbread Cookie, Coconut Custard, Vanilla Ice Cream
      $8.00
      Coconut Cream
    • Boston Cream Pie

      Shortbread Cookie, Custard, Chocolate Mousse, Vanilla Ice Cream
      $8.00
      Boston Cream Pie
    • The Elvis

      Our delicious house-made banana butter with creamy peanut butter mousse over chocolate ice cream sandwiched between two crunchy chocolate shortbread cookies
      $8.00
      The Elvis
    • Strawberry Shortcake

      A refreshing scoop of Strawberry Ice Cream topped with a layer of creamy Vanilla Mousse, sandwiched between two Butter Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Strawberry Shortcake
    • Pecan Pie

      The original Peace Pie is our Pecan Pie; made with the family's homemade Pecan Pie filling recipe, over Vanilla Ice Cream sandwiched between two of our delicious Butter Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Pecan Pie
    • Cinnamon Bun

      Cinnamon Swirl Ice Cream topped with a layer of our house-made Caramel and Vanilla Mousse sandwiched between two Cinnamon Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Cinnamon Bun
    • Rocky Road

      Rocky Road reinvented with our Delicious Chocolate Mousse, swirled with Almond Slivers and Mini Marshmallows over Chocolate Ice Cream Sandwiched Between Two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Rocky Road
    • Creamsicle

      Refreshing Orange Sherbet topped with our creamy Vanilla Mousse on Butter Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Creamsicle
    • Thin Mint

      Our house-made whipped mint mousse, over chocolate ice cream on two chocolate shortbread cookies
      $8.00
      Thin Mint
    • Party Pie

      Chocolate Ice Cream topped with a layer of Vanilla Mousse and Rainbow Sprinkles sandwiched between two Butter Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Party Pie
    • Blueberry Lemon Drop

      Butter shortbread cookie with lemon mousse and lemon candy on blueberry ice cream
      $8.00
      Blueberry Lemon Drop
    • PB Blondie

      Butter shortbread cookie with peanut butter mousse and brownies on vanilla ice cream.
      $8.00
      PB Blondie
    • Jersey Devil

      The one and only JERSEY DEVIL Peace Pie is all Red White & Blue with Blueberry Ice Cream topped with a layer of Cherry Pie Filling and Vanilla Mousse sandwiched between two Butter Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Jersey Devil
    • PB Pretzel

      Peanut Butter Ice cream with our signature house-made Caramel over a pretzel and sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      PB Pretzel
    • Cherry Pie

      Vanilla Ice cream topped with a layer of Cherry Pie and Vanilla Mousse on two Butter Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Cherry Pie
    • PB Cookie Dough

      Chocolate shortbread cookie with peanut butter chiffon and cookie dough on chocolate ice cream.
      $8.00
      PB Cookie Dough
    • Chocolate Raspberry

      Chocolate shortbread cookie with chocolate mousse on raspberry ice cream
      $8.00
      Chocolate Raspberry
    • Peaches N' Cream

      Peach Ice Cream topped with our signature Vanilla Mousse, sandwiched between two Graham Cracker Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Peaches N' Cream
    • Blueberry Cobbler

      Blueberry Ice Cream with a layer of our house-made Vanilla Mousse on two Graham Cracker Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Blueberry Cobbler
    • Chocolate Mint

      Chocolate shortbread cookie with chocolate mousse and mint chip ice cream.
      $8.00
      Chocolate Mint
    • Banana Cream

      Our House-made Custard with Banana Butter over a scoop of vanilla ice cream sandwiched with two graham cracker cookies
      $8.00
      Banana Cream
    • Banana Split

      Banana Ice Cream with Cherry Pie Filling and Chocolate Mousse on two Butter Shortbread Cookies
      $8.00
      Banana Split

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

La Doña Restaurante Mexicano
La Doña Restaurante Mexicano
3.9
(271 Reviews)
Mexican
Cape May Macarons
Cape May Macarons
5.0
(7 Reviews)
Bakery
Tisha's Fine Dining
Tisha's Fine Dining
4.5
(809 Reviews)
American, Italian, Seafood
Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls
Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls
4.5
(134 Reviews)
Seafood
Crepe May
Crepe May
4.2
(95 Reviews)
Restaurant
Magic Brain Cafe
Magic Brain Cafe
4.7
(283 Reviews)
Coffee shop, Espresso bar
The Star
The Star
4.5
(179 Reviews)
Cafe, Coffee shop
Uncle Charleys Ice Cream
Uncle Charleys Ice Cream
4.3
(233 Reviews)
Ice cream shop
Delaney's Irish Pub And Grill
Delaney's Irish Pub And Grill
4.1
(1,894 Reviews)
Irish pub, Bar & grill, Irish
Brown Room At Congress Hall
Brown Room At Congress Hall
4.3
(103 Reviews)
Bar, Cocktail bar, Lounge

(609) 435-5321

326 Carpenters Ln, Cape May, NJ 08204


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms