Papa Joe's Menu

Three cannolis hand-filled with a decadent chocolate chip cream.

A warm, housemade brownie topped with vanilla bean ice cream and caramel drizzle.

Rich, creamy and locally made with a walnut and graham cracker crust. Top with housemade raspberry or strawberry topping for $1.00

Layers of rich chocolate cake and decadent fudge. A chocolate lover's dream!

Layers of light and fluffy iced lemon cake

Classic carrot cake with cream cheese frosting

Bright and delightful. Limoncello gelato is topped with raspberries and served in a champagne flute.

Ask your server what the cheesecake special is!

French Vanilla, Spumoni, or 'Rush Hour' Coffee

Filled with Italian sausage, ricotta, feta & parmesan cheese, placed on a pool of marinara sauce

Sauteed medallions of chicken in our marsala sauce with mushrooms

Hand-breaded, sauteed, & topped with marinara & melted cheese. Baked to order!Served with spagettini marinara

Crisp, hand-breaded eggplant, topped with marinara and melted Provolone. Served with spaghettini marinara.

A sizzling platter of our house-made meatballs, sweet Italian sausage, and penne marinara

Noodles layered with our Tuscan bechamel and meat sauces and laced with Reggiano Parmesan and Mozzarella cheeses

Traditional Parmesan cream sauce tossed with fettuccine noodles

Hand rolled with ricotta, spinach, & Parmesan Reggiano, topped with melted cheese & marinara sauce $16

10 oz. Abundantly Flavorful Stock Yards USDA Prime Steak

Stock Yards USDA Choice 8 oz.

12 oz.

Broiled

Served with French fries

Served with lettuce, tomato, and red onion

Our house-made meatballs with marinara sauce and melted cheese on a hoagie bun

With lettuce, tomato, red onion, and tartar sauce on a grilled bun

Fried ever so lightly, served with a delightful pepperonicini rosemary oil

Great for sharing, this heaping platter of zucchini is lightly fried and sprinkled with Reggiano parmesan cheese.

Select chicken, organic mesclun, celery, cranberries, blue cheese, candied walnuts, raspberry vinaigrette

3 scoops homemade chicken salad, egg salad, tuna salad served with fresh pita.

Romaine, select chicken, buffalo sauce, celery, carrot, crumbled blue cheese, housemade ranch.

Salami, capicola, natural baked ham, pepperoni, mortadella, and provolone on fresh Italian Hoagie bun.

Select chicken, organic lettuce, tomato, bacon on toasted bread with garlic mayo

Select breaded chicken, buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, tomato, on a toasted bun

Fresh breaded lake perch, organic lettuce, tomato, red onion, homemade tartar on a fresh local bun.

Your choice of homemade salad served on white or wheat.

House-Roasted turkey breast, lettuce, onion, tomato.

A sponge cake splashed with espresso, dark rum, & layered with sweet mascarpone & rich cocoa topping

Three cannolis hand-filled with a decadent chocolate chip cream.

Classic carrot cake with cream cheese frosting

A warm, housemade brownie topped with vanilla bean ice cream and caramel drizzle.

Rich, creamy and locally made with a walnut and graham cracker crust. Top with housemade raspberry or strawberry topping for $1.00

Layers of rich chocolate cake and decadent fudge. A chocolate lover's dream!

Layers of light and fluffy lemon cake, fresh lemon mascarpone and berries.

With marinara and pesto sauces

House Favorite!Filled with Italian sausage, ricotta, feta and parmesan cheese, placed on a pool of marinara sauce.

With a pepperoncini rosemary oil

10 oz. Abundantly Flavorful Stock Yards USDA Prime Steak

Slow roast to perfection

10 oz. Broiled

Fresh breast of chicken hand-breaded and sauteed, topped with marinara and melted provolone. Served with spaghettini marinara.

A sponge cake splashed with espresso, dark rum, & layered with sweet mascarpone & rich cocoa topping.

A warm, housemade brownie topped with vanilla bean ice cream and caramel drizzle.

Served with our marinara and pesto sauces, a new twist on an old favorite.

House Favorite!Filled with Italian sausage, ricotta, feta and parmesan cheese, placed on a pool of marinara sauce.

Fried ever so lightly, served with a delightful pepperoncini rosemary oil

Served with spiced pineapple sauce

Penne pasta tossed with grilled chicken & tomato bruschetta in a light cream with balsamic drizzle

Served with spaghettini marinara

Served with spaghettini marinara.

Drizzled with a honey lemon sauce.

Served with lemon beurre blanc

with whipped potatoes

A warm, housemade brownie topped with vanilla bean ice cream and caramel drizzle.

Warm brownie topped with vanilla ice cream, caramel sauce and a dash of sea salt

Spumoni | Vanilla | Coffee

Chicken Salad, tuna salad, baked ham, roast turkey, and roast beef served on French rolls with our house-made Papa's Pasta Salad.

Roasted red peppers, marinated artichoke hearts, pepperonicini, salami, capicola, tomato & mozzarella salad, & a blend of olives, served with crackers

Papa's Pasta Salad, Kidney Bean Salad, Tortellini Salad, Tomato & Mozzarella Salad. Broccoli Salad

Served with 5 local cheeses, crackers, broccoli, cauliflower, carrots, cucumbers, bell peppers, & celery, served with our house made ranch

Served with cocktail sauce

Served with toasted pita chips, serves 20-24

Served with toasted pita chips, serves 20-24

Serves 20-25

Mozzarella sticks & Fried cheese ravioli served with marinara dipping sauce, sauerkraut balls served with cocktail sauce, and honey dipped wings

Locally made Italian sausage tossed with peppers, onions, & tomatoes

Made in-house with your choice of barbecue or marinara sauce

Brushed with EVOO & Tuscan spices, serves 10 - 12

Choice of barbecue or buffalo style

Great for sharing, this heaping platter of zucchini is lightly fried and sprinkled with Reggiano parmesan cheese.

Fried ever so lightly, served with a delightful pepperoncini rosemary oil

Hand-breaded, sauteed, & topped with marinara & melted cheese. Baked to order!Served with spagettini marinara

Hand breaded, sauteed, & topped withmarinara & melted cheese. Baked to order!Served with spagettini marinara

Hand-pounded and breaded veal sauteed and topped with marinara and meltedprovolone. Served with spagettini marinara

Hand-rolled with fresh ricotta and Reggiano Parmesan, baked with Alfredo sauce and melted mozzarella, topped with fresh tomato bruschetta

Gluten free pasta is available if requested (+ $2)

Grilled chicken breast, topped with sauteed mushrooms, onions, & melted cheese. Served with whipped potatoes.

Grilled chicken breast, with Italian seasonings, served with risotto

Sauteed chicken & mushrooms in our richmarsala wine sauce

Grilled chicken breast, basted with honey Dijon mustard, topped with candied pecans

Incredibly tender and naturally juicy Stock Yards 12 oz | minimum of 6

Stock Yards USDA Choice 8 oz.

U.S.D.A Choice Center Cut New York Strip Steak - 12oz

1 Entree, 1 Side Entree Choices:Grilled Chicken BreastHoney Dijon Chicken Roast SIrloin Au JusOur Famous LasagnaSide Dish Choices:Roasted PotatoesItalian Green BeansPenne Marinara

3 Main Entrees 2 Side Dish

Chicken cutlets lightly breaded, topped with baby arugula, EVOO, lemon, & Parmesan

Grilled chicken breast, basted with honey Dijon mustard, topped with candied pecans

Grilled chicken breast, with Italian seasonings

Penne with seasonal vegetable with oil & garlic, & sprinkled with Parmesan

Noodles and eggplant layered with Tuscan bechamel & our house made sauce,Parmesan Reggiano & mozzarella cheese

Fresh baked cookies: Chocolate Truffle, Oatmeal Raisin, Snickerdoodle, and White Chocolate Macadamia Cookies

Gourmet lemon bars, handmade cannolis, freshly baked brownies, cookies, and oldfashioned rice krispie treats

Freshly baked brownies

A sponge cake splashed with espresso, dark rum, & layered with sweet marscarpone & rich cocoa topping

Rich & creamy, graham cracker & walnut crust, topped with your choice of raspberriesor strawberries

A warm, housemade brownie topped with vanilla bean ice cream and caramel drizzle.