P & P New York Style Pizza (Mentor)

Unfortunately, P & P’s Pizza is not the same from what was by far the best NY Style Pizza in Lake County. We enjoyed the pizza for years under the prior owner/operator. The pizza was bland at best and there was virtually no sauce on the pizza. We will not be back.

Excellent new york style pie.

By far the best pizza I’ve ever had. It’s pricey, but to me it’s worth it.

Ordered a small pizza and breadsticks. 1:20 min later I get a delivery of cold food and not the greatest of cold food. Was told the delivery driver was given the wrong address. But I never received a call or was asked to verify my address so how did they know where to deliver?

Awesome Chicken Parmesan Sub. Will be trying the pizza soon

Nice place owners went out of there way to make sure everything was ok

Let me start off by saying that this is the best authentic New York style pizza I’ve had in Ohio. It seems like the workers there put a lot of heart into making these pizzas. Wouldn’t change a thing.

Don’t rate them off of DoorDash, first off. If you’re reading this, I’ve probably had a lot more pizza than you. And I mean that. Probably over 100 different pies. This place offers the best pickup-service New York style pizza in the county, hands down. They could use some rehab on the building and maybe more consistency. But that’s life.