Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Menu

2349 W 29th St, Greeley, CO 80631
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • CRAFT YOUR OWN PIZZA

      Choose your crust & toppings.
      CRAFT YOUR OWN PIZZA
    • CRAFT YOUR OWN CALZONE

      A blend of mozzarella, ricotta. Choose your favorite fresh toppings.
      $12.09+
      CRAFT YOUR OWN CALZONE
    • CHICAGO 7™

      Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, red onions, black olives, green peppers, sliced mushrooms.
      CHICAGO 7™
    • FOUNTAIN DRINKS

      $3.99+
      FOUNTAIN DRINKS
    • KIDS BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA

      Build your own kid-sized version of our Chicago style pizza. Pick any 2 toppings below.
      $6.09
      KIDS BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA
    • LEMONADES

      Your choice of Classic, Strawberry, or Pomegranate.
      $3.99+
      LEMONADES
    • SICILIAN PEPPERONI ROLLS™

      Signature dough, pepperoni, fresh green onions & cheese.Served with signature red sauce.
      $14.59
      SICILIAN PEPPERONI ROLLS™
    • DOUBLE DECKERONI™

      2x the pepperoni with shaved parmesan, a dash of hot sauce and parsley garnish.
      DOUBLE DECKERONI™
    • CHICAGO 7™ CALZONE

      Pepperoni, Italian sausage, red onions, black olives, green peppers, sliced mushrooms, mozzarella, ricotta.
      $16.39
      CHICAGO 7™ CALZONE
    • SIDE GARDEN SALAD

      Fresh greens, carrots, cucumbers, croutons & tomatoes. Choice of dressing.
      $6.09
      SIDE GARDEN SALAD
    • ITALIAN NACHOS

      Pasta chips, mozzarella, pepper jack, pepperoni, pepperoncini, Italian sausage and our signature red sauce.
      $17.59
      ITALIAN NACHOS
    • MEAT ME™

      Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, Andouille sausage, pepperoni, green olive and fresh basil garnish.
      MEAT ME™
  • UNREAL PIZZA DEALS

    • PIZZA PARTY TO-GO

      Your choice of a Salad Platter and three Large Specialty Pizzas. Served with two Big Cookies. Serves 8-10. Calories are per piece/slice.
      $151.29
      PIZZA PARTY TO-GO
    • PARTY PACK FOR 4

      Your choice of a Taproom Starter, a Large Pizza and a 6 Inch Big Cookie. Calories are per slice/piece.
      $36.29
      PARTY PACK FOR 4
    • PARTY PACK FOR 6

      Your choice of a Taproom Starter, 2 Large Pizzas and a 9 Inch Big Cookie. Calories are per slice/piece.
      $72.59
      PARTY PACK FOR 6
  • STARTERS

    • SICILIAN PEPPERONI ROLLS™

      Signature dough, pepperoni, fresh green onions & cheese.Served with signature red sauce.
      $14.59
      SICILIAN PEPPERONI ROLLS™
    • ITALIAN NACHOS

      Pasta chips, mozzarella, pepper jack, pepperoni, pepperoncini, Italian sausage and our signature red sauce.
      $17.59
      ITALIAN NACHOS
    • BAVARIAN PRETZEL STICKS

      Four Bavarian pretzel sticks served with mustard beer cheese sauce made with Guinness.
      $12.69
      BAVARIAN PRETZEL STICKS
    • TWISTED TENDERS

      Chicken tenders marinated in buttermilk for 24 hours andbreaded in our Twisted seasoned flour blend. Includes choice of two sauces.
      $14.59
      TWISTED TENDERS
    • NASHVILLE HOT-ZARELLA *LIMITED TIME*

      Fried mozzarella sticks tossed in Nashville Hot sauce and served with ranch
      $12.69
      NASHVILLE HOT-ZARELLA *LIMITED TIME*
    • BUFFALO CHICKEN ROLLS

      Roasted chicken, Buffalo sauce, mozzarella cheese, celery &bleu cheese dressing baked inside our signature dough. Served with bleu cheese dressing.
      $14.59
      BUFFALO CHICKEN ROLLS
    • MOZZARELLA STICKS

      Breaded and fried, served with signature red sauce.
      $11.49
      MOZZARELLA STICKS
    • CHEESY DIPPIN' STRIPS

      OC Thick pizza crust, mozzarella, garlic butter, house seasoning, side signature red sauce
      $12.09
      CHEESY DIPPIN' STRIPS
    • SPINACH ARTICHOKE DIP

      Spinach, artichokes, mozzarella & parmesan cheeses, served with pasta chips.
      $13.99
      SPINACH ARTICHOKE DIP
    • FRIED PICKLES

      Beer battered and tossed in a zesty southern spice blend. Served with ranch or sweet Thai chili dipping sauce..
      $11.49
      FRIED PICKLES
  • WINGS

    Served with celery sticks. Choice of ranch or bleu cheese.
    • KEG OF WINGS

      When a tall order of wings just isn’t enough, the Keg of Wings features twice the wings, twice the sauce.
      $33.29+
      KEG OF WINGS
    • BONELESS CHICKEN WINGS TALL

      Breaded all-white meat boneless chicken wings hand tossed in one of our signature sauces or dry rubs.
      $16.39
      BONELESS CHICKEN WINGS TALL
    • BONELESS CHICKEN WINGS SHORT

      Breaded all-white meat boneless chicken wings hand tossed in one of our signature sauces or dry rubs.
      $11.49
      BONELESS CHICKEN WINGS SHORT
    • BONE-IN CHICKEN WINGS TALL

      Traditional bone-in, twice cooked chicken wings hand tossed in one of our signature sauces or dry rubs.
      $20.59
      BONE-IN CHICKEN WINGS TALL
    • BONE-IN CHICKEN WINGS SHORT

      Traditional bone-in, twice cooked chicken wings hand tossed in one of our signature sauces or dry rubs.
      $13.29
      BONE-IN CHICKEN WINGS SHORT
  • PIZZA

    Choose your crust: Tavern Thin, Hand Tossed Ale Crust, OC Thick Pan or Cauliflower Crust. Calories are per slice.
    • CRAFT YOUR OWN PIZZA

      Choose your crust & toppings.
      CRAFT YOUR OWN PIZZA
    • CHICAGO 7™

      Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, red onions, black olives, green peppers, sliced mushrooms.
      CHICAGO 7™
    • DOUBLE DECKERONI™

      2x the pepperoni with shaved parmesan, a dash of hot sauce and parsley garnish.
      DOUBLE DECKERONI™
    • MEAT ME™

      Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, Andouille sausage, pepperoni, green olive and fresh basil garnish.
      MEAT ME™
    • CHICKEN BACON RANCH PIZZA

      Our flaky crust, Ranch sauce, roasted chicken, crispy bacon, and melty mozzarella garnished with fresh green onions and a drizzle of Ranch dressing
      CHICKEN BACON RANCH PIZZA
    • THE CLASSIC

      Pepperoni, sliced mushrooms, Italian sausage & roasted garlic.
      THE CLASSIC
    • NASHVILLE HOT CRISPY CHICKEN PIZZA *LIMITED TIME*

      White sauce, mozzarella, Nashville Hot chicken, pickles and green onions drizzled with ranch and hot honey sauce.
      NASHVILLE HOT CRISPY CHICKEN PIZZA *LIMITED TIME*
    • THAI PIE

      Sweet Thai chili sauce, mozzarella, pepper jack, cheddar, roasted chicken, mushrooms, red peppers, broccoli, sesame seeds, green onions & teriyaki sauce.
      THAI PIE
    • VEGGIE 7

      Red onions, green bell peppers, sliced mushrooms, black olives, artichoke hearts and red peppers.
      VEGGIE 7
    • FARMER'S DAUGHTER PIZZA

      Mozzarella, blistered tomatoes, pesto sauce, fresh arugula & a balsamic drizzle.
      FARMER'S DAUGHTER PIZZA
    • TOP IT OFF

      Select a sauce, served on the side for drizzle or dunks!
      TOP IT OFF
  • CALZONES

    • CHICAGO FIRE CALZONE

      Pepperoni, sweet Italian sausage, red peppers, red onions, pepperoncini, mozzarella, ricotta. Topped with a fresh jalapeño baked into the crust. Served with house-made ranch.
      $16.99
      CHICAGO FIRE CALZONE
    • CRAFT YOUR OWN CALZONE

      A blend of mozzarella, ricotta. Choose your favorite fresh toppings.
      $12.09+
      CRAFT YOUR OWN CALZONE
    • CHICAGO 7™ CALZONE

      Pepperoni, Italian sausage, red onions, black olives, green peppers, sliced mushrooms, mozzarella, ricotta.
      $16.39
      CHICAGO 7™ CALZONE
  • ENTRÉES

    • SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS

      Italian sausage & ground beef meatballs over spaghetti, signature red sauce, fresh basil & parmesan cheese.
      $17.59
      SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS
    • TWISTED TENDERS MEAL

      Six buttermilk marinated crispy-fried tenders, fries, and choice of two sauces: Buffalo, Ranch, Blue Cheese, BBQ,Nashville Hot, Honey Mustard, Twisted Sauce
      $19.39
      TWISTED TENDERS MEAL
    • CHICKEN & BACON MAC

      Cavatappi, golden beer cheese sauce, Applewood chicken, peppered bacon.
      $17.59
      CHICKEN & BACON MAC
    • SPAGHETTI PIE WITH CHICKEN

      Spaghetti tossed in Alfredo sauce with parmesan, mozzarella, and Romano, cheeses. Baked, then topped with additional Italian cheeses and your choice of marinaraor Alfredo sauce. With applewood smoked chicken breast.
      $21.19
      SPAGHETTI PIE WITH CHICKEN
    • SPAGHETTI PIE WITH MEATBALLS

      Spaghetti tossed in Alfredo sauce with parmesan, mozzarella, and Romano, cheeses. Baked, then topped with additional Italian cheeses and your choice of marinaraor Alfredo sauce. With two Meatballs.
      $21.19
      SPAGHETTI PIE WITH MEATBALLS
    • MUSIC CITY HOT MAC *LIMITED TIME*

      Cavatappi pasta, gold beer cheese sauce, chicken and bacon topped with Nashville Hot sauce & bread crumb topping.
      $18.19
      MUSIC CITY HOT MAC *LIMITED TIME*
    • SPAGHETTI PIE

      Spaghetti tossed in Alfredo sauce with parmesan, mozzarella, and Romano, cheeses. Baked, then topped with additional Italian cheeses and your choice of marinaraor Alfredo sauce.
      $17.59
      SPAGHETTI PIE
    • CHICKEN PESTO ALFREDO

      Penne Alfredo with applewood chicken, broccoli, diced tomatoes, pesto & shaved parmesan
      $19.39
      CHICKEN PESTO ALFREDO
    • CHICKEN PARMESAN

      Basil and parmesan crusted chicken breast, mozzarella, penne, fresh basil & signature red sauce
      $19.39
      CHICKEN PARMESAN
  • HANDHELDS

    Choice of fries, coleslaw or fresh veggies with dip.Sub veggie patty for any burger.
    • CLASSIC CHEESEBURGER*

      Burger with melted American cheese on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato, pickles & roasted garlic aioli
      $15.19
      CLASSIC CHEESEBURGER*
    • BBQ BACON CHEESEBURGER*

      Burger with signature BBQ sauce, melted American cheese & peppered bacon
      $16.99
      BBQ BACON CHEESEBURGER*
    • CHICKEN CAESAR WRAP

      Romaine, applewood grilled chicken, Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese, flour tortilla
      $15.79
      CHICKEN CAESAR WRAP
    • CHICKEN CAPRESE SANDWICH

      Grilled chicken, pesto, mozzarella, tomato, arugula, and balsamic drizzle
      $18.79
      CHICKEN CAPRESE SANDWICH
    • HOT CHICKEN WRAP *LIMITED TIME*

      Crispy Nashville Hot chicken tenders, pickles, lettuce and ranch wrapped in a tortilla, served with fries or tots.
      $16.99
      HOT CHICKEN WRAP *LIMITED TIME*
    • CHICKEN SALAD WRAP

      Applewood grilled chicken salad, bacon, lettuce, tomato, flour tortilla
      $16.99
      CHICKEN SALAD WRAP
    • NASHVILLE HOT CRISPY CHICKEN SANDWICH

      Nashville Hot Crispy chicken breast, lettuce, dill picklesand ranch
      $18.79
      NASHVILLE HOT CRISPY CHICKEN SANDWICH
    • CRAFTED BEER BURGER*

      Burger grilled with a light lager & mustard beer cheese sauce made with Guinness, crispy onion strings
      $16.99
      CRAFTED BEER BURGER*
    • CRISPY CHICKEN SANDWICH

      Crispy chicken breast, lettuce, dill pickles and ranch
      $17.59
      CRISPY CHICKEN SANDWICH
  • SALADS

    • SIDE GARDEN SALAD

      Fresh greens, carrots, cucumbers, croutons & tomatoes. Choice of dressing.
      $6.09
      SIDE GARDEN SALAD
    • SIDE CAESAR SALAD

      Romaine, shaved parmesan, basil croutons & signature Caesar dressing.
      $6.09
      SIDE CAESAR SALAD
    • BLACKENED CHICKEN CAESAR

      Cajun-seasoned grilled chicken breast on a crisp bed of romaine, Parmesan, and croutons. Enjoy with Caesar dressing.
      $15.79
      BLACKENED CHICKEN CAESAR
    • CUP OF BROCCOLI CHEESE SOUP *LIMITED TIME*

      Blend of cheeses, with cream and broccoli.
      $7.29
      CUP OF BROCCOLI CHEESE SOUP *LIMITED TIME*
    • OLD CHICAGO CHOPPED SALAD

      Applewood chicken, peppered bacon, bleu cheese, and fresh green onions, topped with tomato. Enjoy with creamy herb dressing.
      $16.99
      OLD CHICAGO CHOPPED SALAD
    • ROASTED CHICKEN & APPLE WALNUT SALAD

      Fresh greens, bleu cheese crumbles, apple slices, toasted walnuts, sun-dried cranberries and applewood-spiced chicken. Enjoy with creamy herb dressing.
      $16.99
      ROASTED CHICKEN & APPLE WALNUT SALAD
  • KIDS MEALS

    1,400 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice for children, but calorie needs may vary.
    • KIDS BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA

      Build your own kid-sized version of our Chicago style pizza. Pick any 2 toppings below.
      $6.09
      KIDS BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA
    • SPAGHETTI & 1 MEATBALL

      $8.69
      SPAGHETTI & 1 MEATBALL
    • PENNE ALFREDO

      Served with your choice of one side.
      $7.29
      PENNE ALFREDO
    • SPAGHETTI

      Served with your choice of one side.
      $7.29
      SPAGHETTI
    • KIDS CHAMPION CHEESE PIZZA

      A kid-sized version of our famous Chicago-style pizza.
      $7.29
      KIDS CHAMPION CHEESE PIZZA
    • CHICKEN TENDERS

      Served with your choice of one side.
      $7.29
      CHICKEN TENDERS
    • MAC N' CHEESE

      Served with your choice of one side.
      $7.29
      MAC N' CHEESE
    • MIGHTY CHEESEBURGER

      Served with your choice of one side.
      $7.29
      MIGHTY CHEESEBURGER
  • DESSERT

    • TRIPLE CHOCOLATE BROWNIE

      Scratch made brownie topped with fudge sauce and ice cream with a caramel and chocolate drizzle
      $9.69
      TRIPLE CHOCOLATE BROWNIE
    • SCRATCH MADE COOKIZZA

      All-butter cookie dough with giant morsels of chocolate freshly baked in our deep-dish pizza pan. Calories are per slice.
      $7.29+
      SCRATCH MADE COOKIZZA
    • DOUGHNUT BITES

      House made doughnut balls, lightly fried and sprinkled with cinnamon sugar with fudge and caramel dipping sauce
      $7.89
      DOUGHNUT BITES
  • SIDES

    • FRIES

      $4.89
      FRIES
    • ADDITIONAL SAUCES

      $0.69+
      ADDITIONAL SAUCES
    • SIDE OF VEGGIES & DIP

      $4.89
      SIDE OF VEGGIES & DIP
    • TOTS

      $4.89
      TOTS
    • BROCCOLI WITH GARLIC BUTTER

      $6.09
      BROCCOLI WITH GARLIC BUTTER
  • DRINKS

    • ICED TEAS

      $3.99+
      ICED TEAS
    • RED BULL

      Red Bull, Red Bull Sugar Free or Red Bull Watermelon
      $6.09+
      RED BULL
    • FOUNTAIN DRINKS

      $3.99+
      FOUNTAIN DRINKS
    • LEMONADES

      Your choice of Classic, Strawberry, or Pomegranate.
      $3.99+
      LEMONADES
  • UTENSILS

    • Fork

    • Spoon

    • Black Pepper Packet

    • Mustard Packet

    • Ketchup Packet

    • Mayo Packet

    • Napkin

    • Straw

    • Knife

    • Salt Packet

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Twisted Tenders
Twisted Tenders
1.3
(11 Reviews)
Chicken, American, Chicken shop
Red Lobster
Red Lobster
4.0
(1,579 Reviews)
Seafood, American, Crab house
Almansitas
Almansitas
4.0
(949 Reviews)
Mexican
3 Margaritas Greeley
3 Margaritas Greeley
3.9
(1,096 Reviews)
Mexican
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
4.2
(2,275 Reviews)
Italian, Family, Gluten-free
Texas Roadhouse
Texas Roadhouse
4.4
(4,292 Reviews)
Steak house, American, Restaurant
Del Taco
Del Taco
3.8
(1,375 Reviews)
American, Breakfast, Hamburger
Chuck E. Cheese
Chuck E. Cheese
4.0
(641 Reviews)
Pizza
Georgia Boys BBQ - Greeley
Georgia Boys BBQ - Greeley
4.3
(786 Reviews)
Restaurant, Barbecue
Lucky Panda
Lucky Panda
3.9
(286 Reviews)
Chinese, Asian, Restaurant

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms