Nico's Pizzeria & Grill- Subs

It wasn’t worth the travel pizza was 1/10

Trash... 7/11 has better pizza tbh...

Every time i visit the New York area i try to find restaurants unfamiliar to me. Well this place was nostalgic to my partner so i was willing to try it. It was very outdated to say the least. I ordered an Italian cheeseburger, which I've never had. I specifically asked them not to put a lot of ketchup. I asked for light ketchup and heavy mayo. When i pulled the sandwich out of the bag you could see the ketchup through the paper before even opening it. i tried to wipe some off but it was massive. On top of that, the meat was over cooked. I was really disappointed because i was excited to try something new and i only got through half.

Update 8-8-2024 OMG They sold this place to a bunch of Arabs and the flavor and taste is not the same. I do not recommend this place anymore ever since the twins sold this establishment I don't know why they would do that, but I would never go there again or the same thing that I ordering for the past 9+ years and it tasted horrible. The flavor is gone. The people is gone. That establishment is over. Everything is over , my heart so much this place but like what time everything changes I Do not recommend now This Italian cheesesteak is so delicious. I am so happy with my food today and every time I visit this place this is Gem.. It always pleases my little tummy every time I go to this place love love love this place

I love Nicosia pizza and I will forever love it however the new 2 workers provided wrong pricing trying to swindle me and the pizza they have made is nasty it would never compare to the way the old owners made it ..it literally was the worst pizza ive ever tasted

I love these brothers. If I had money I would donate an A/C system to them. I'm thinking about calling q TV show to get them renovated. The pizza is good and I love the Gyros

I've been going for years, not what it used to be. The food is good, but they have added a lot to the menu. They were known for their Italian cheese burgers and such

I went in to buy two slices. The restaurant is nice and big. Plenty of seating. A wide variety of pizzas. The guy who assisted me was so nice. So pleasant. I think he may have even been Italian. The pizza was delicious, crunchy crust, not too hard. Just the right amount of cheese and sauce. I will be going back.