Mexitaly Brick oven Brewhouse

Take out was fantastic pickup was quick and efficient

The fish tacos are amazing here. I have also tried some of the other dishes and so far everything has been great. The mead is also pretty good.

Ordered side platters and sauces and never received them. The food is good, but make sure you check your bag before you walk away cause they tend not to give you what you paid for.

We love the pizzas, the poco burritos, nachos, tacos, and the pasta. Today I tried the new Greens and Beans and it was everything I wanted it to be. Perfect on a chilly, dreary Sunday afternoon. The staff is always great as well.

Good food, beers made in house. Decent lunch, even with the kids. 9/3 went again for lunch. Unholy toledo is that spanakopita pizza legit. 11/24 - same.

Staff was friendly, welcoming and helpful. We went for dinner on a Thursday night, wasn't too bad. Ordered cheese fries for appetizer, cheese sauce was "unique" but had good flavor, fries were hot and crispy. Girlfriend got Chipotle chicken tacos and I got southwest steak burrito. She really liked her tacos. I liked the burrito, it was HUGE and PACKED FULL.The only thing was everything wasn't really mixed too well(one end all hot other end all cold from guacamole and sour cream. Still tasted good, Willing to go back and try something else next time. Girlfriend got strawberry margarita for drink and it was best she ever had

Always love the food and drinks!

My fiancé and I passed this restaurant a few times and determined we would try it. We finally tried it on a cloudy, rainy, chilly day which lead to depression. To assuage the general sadness of the day, I decided that I wanted pasta, and my fiancé wanted Mexican. To deal with the conundrum, I suggested we could both have our way by going to MexItaly. We were both very happily surprised by it. It is a surprising gem in the food desert of York. The restaurant has a welcoming big city decor, the staff is friendly and timely, and the food is fantastic. I would strongly recommend their Mexican spicy fries as an appetizer. The taco bowl and beef Bolognese were something we both will come back for. The highest compliment I can pay is that it was as though we were transported to the food capital of America, Columbus, Ohio, without ever leaving the food desert of PA.