Mama Cimino's Pizza

The BEST in town! A+ Just had the most AWESOME pizza we have had in a long time

These are the most amazing stuffed shells I’ve ever had! I decided to order a late night dinner, and was reluctant about ordering so close to closing. When my dinner arrived, it was all so fresh and warm. I ordered the stuffed shells with a side salad, and a cannoli. The salad was so fresh, with large chunks of tomatoes and cucumbers in it. The balsamic dressing was a great compliment on the salad. But the stuffed shells were amazing! The sauce was flavorful, and the garlic bread was the best I’ve ever had. It was soft & chewy, not dry and crusty like all others. And lastly, their cannolis are stuffed with real cannoli cream. It’s difficult to find a cannoli not made with frosting, but with the actual cream! 5 stars all the way! Only one thing I’d comment on, is allowing drinks to be ordered for delivery.

Ordered for delivery to our hotel, fast service and excellent pizza and marinara sauce!

Coming from Chicago, this has to be the best pizza we've had- and we've had good pizza! Must have!

Open late Options for getting your food I will be going back Friendly staff

Nice little pizza joint. Staff is friendly and helpful. Place isn’t fancy. Prices were good. Got the Pepperoni Rolls and they were great. Got 14 inch Ciminos Crust(thin) with Sausage/Black Olives. Very Tasty and thought sausage was excellent. Will go back. Parking: Plenty of parking. Kid-friendliness: Have Kids menu, and kids size pizza.

Fantastic Dining Experience at Mama Cimino's Pizza with Exceptional Service from Carmen! I recently dined at Mama Cimino's Pizza in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, and it was truly a remarkable experience. From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted by the lovely server, Carmen, who made us feel right at home. Her exceptional customer service truly enhanced our dining experience. The cheese curds we ordered as an appetizer were out of this world - so fresh and delicious! As for the main courses, both the chicken parmesan and chicken carbonara were absolutely divine. The flavors were rich and authentic, and every bite was a delight to the taste buds. As a Chicago native, I have high standards when it comes to Italian cuisine, and Mama Cimino's Pizza exceeded all expectations. The food here rivals that of any 5-star restaurant, and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a top-notch dining experience. If you find yourself in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, do yourself a favor and pay a visit to Mama Cimino's Pizza. You won't be disappointed! Thank you, Carmen, and the entire team at Mama Cimino's, for a memorable evening of great food and exceptional service. Five stars all the way!