Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream Counter at Foxtail Coffee

I looked online for the flavors of the month. I came here for brownie batter and on Friday at 8pm they are sold out of it.

Ice cream was very good. The waffle cone ok. It was a little over priced.

I've tried hard to enjoy their flavors through the years. Just can't force it anymore. The BEST employees though, very friendly and happy to serve you.

The service was great, but for the price, the ice cream was pretty standard - no richness or boldness to separate from other brands with similar flavors. The atmosphere was nice, but hard to get a seat as many people were there hanging out on laptops for indeterminate periods of time due to the coffee shop. Make sure you get a drink at home because the cost for a standard bottle of water (in hot FL) is $3.50. We rode our bikes to the shop from the West Orange trail and were pretty thirsty, but will plan better next time. The total for two small (single scoop) sugar cones, no toppings and two bottles of water was $18.00.

Visiting Plant Street from out of state and decided we wanted a cold treat after dinner. Stopped into this darling ice cream shop with such high hopes, only to be treated so rudely!! We arrived around 9:35-9:40. They close at 10. The young lady working the counter made it quite clear to us that she was annoyed that we and the other customers were there. She commented sarcastically that she just loved people that came in so close to closing time. We reminded her that it was summertime and a Saturday night. She had the petty nerve to argue that it wasn’t still summer. What?!? Ok it’s Florida and it’s hot so there’s that! My daughter ordered a milkshake but was told the milkshake machine had already been washed so no on the shake. I ordered a ice cream in a waffle cone and didn’t get much ice cream. In fact, that was the driest ice cream cone I had ever gotten! It had so little ice cream in the cone!! I basically threw away $13!!! We left stunned!! Plant Street is a beautiful area with cute shops and delicious restaurants. So much fun to walk around. All of the other businesses were so friendly and really seemed grateful that we were there! Sorry this stop was so disappointing because as I said the shop was absolutely darling!!

Best ice cream ever

their banana pudding ice cream is out of this world!!