I want to like this place but they brought out the wrong dish for my friend and the Bistec a la Criolla that I ordered was nothing like the description. The meat was dry and a little tough, no sauce, just some sautéed onions in the side.
After having an unpleasant experience at another restaurant in the area we came to Judy’s and this was meant to be! The service was amazing, our server Fidel was friendly, knowledgeable about the menu and the drinks. Fidel gave us really good recommendations. We ordered one tamarind margarita and one lemon margarita with mezcal, they both were delicious and fresh! For the food, we ordered pupusas revueltas and pupusas with cheese and beans! Best pupusas I ever tried! I’m definitely coming back! The service at this place is really great! SECOND VISIT After a great experience at Judy’s last night, I wanted to come back to explore more the many and I’m glad I did! Fidel’s customer service was exceptional as the first time. This time I tried Bistec a la criolla, Judy’s combination and for dessert I had their 3 leches cake and their flan. Both were divide, I can recommend this place enough! THIRD VISIT AMAZING! The Lomo Saltado and Burrito was incredible delicious! The margaritas were tasty! Loving this restaurant! ❤️ the customer service is 100 points! 10 out of 10!
**EDIT** I came back a day after my review. Everything is excellent, and I’m here to say DO NOT SLEEP ON THE DESSERTS!!!!! The flan and tres leches are simply divine. Fidel provided exemplary service as always. I love Judy’s, I’ve been coming here for 4 years now. It’s been 2 years since I last came to eat at Judy Restaurant and it has gotten even better. Not only is the food excellent, the service is EXCELLENT. Our server, Fidel, did a phenomenal job taking care of us and honestly answering our questions regarding the menu. The drinks were strong and delicious, I strongly recommend a lime mezcal margarita. Pupusas were also amazing, thick with the perfect amount of dough, and don’t get me started on the curtido!!!! I didn’t get it this time, but my usual go-to is the bistec al caballo. The beans are to die for, and the eggs are always perfect. Parking is hell but it’s always awful anywhere worth your while. I’ve always had a great time here, and I always look forward to coming back. I always love the bachata classics playing in the background, makes me feel safe
I walked down 14th Street with my significant other & we stumbled on this amazing restuarant. From the amazing drinks, the savory carne asada & kind hosts; it’s a must have. We will definetely be back!