Joey's Pizza (Middletown)

If you like crispy pizza like I do, you'll love it. Lots of pies to choose from.

It's called a pizza restaurant when we walked in we asked if we should just be seated. I guess there was a language barrier. We sat down others, walked in and straight up to the counter. It turns out that you need to order at the counter it's counter service only and you have to bus your own tables when they do bring things to your table, they don't take anything away even stacks of empty dishes. Most of the food was okay. The dinner came out with garlic bread which I was not expecting. It looked like it had a lot of minced garlic on it but while there wasn't any flavor? And there's some sort of orange butter substitute. They made the chicken francese fresh but it needed to be cooked with some lemon. We had lemon from other dishes but I was able to squeeze onto the dish and make it exceptible. It came with rice which was delicious on its own. Steamed clams were sandy but the shrimp cocktail was amazing but the cocktail sauce lacked any horseradish.

Good pizza! Ordered a deep dish, which was good and very filling. Came back for a slice of cake the next day, which tasted good but was a little on the dry side; may have just been in the refrigerator too long. The staff were friendly, and there was a wide variety of pizza slices and other prepared foods available. Overall, happy with the experience.

Since Joey's has reopened, we get a Buffalo Chicken Pizza once a week from here. We ordered one today and as usual it was delicious....we will never order buffalo chicken any where else . Thank you.....soooooo good!!!

Best Pizza in Town. The sauce, the crust is delicious. Delivery is on point. I edited my stars because Google changed my rating this restaurant deserves 5 stars in my book.

I been coming here for years always good food and they have lot different choices I had pizza last time I was here

We order from here at work all the time. They are now my go to delivery spot.