Insomnia Cookies

My cookies were fresh and warm, the employee was super friendly as soon as I walked

Great...mmmm smells sooo delicious!

the best.

I gave a confusing address when making my order. Dylan was the kind man's name who made multiple trips to my apartment complex to make sure all was correct. Far too often we, as people, take for granted how hard some people work - and I realized last night how much effort this man and the store he works at much put in time after time after time. I'll order from here many more times. Thank you!!!

Always an amazing experience going into this place. Other cookie stores in the town pale in comparison to their customer service and cookie quality.

Paige is such a kind manager there. Service was great as well!

These are the best Cookies in Manhattan!! Paige does an amazing job at customer service. The store and bathrooms are impeccable. Catering orders are timely and correct. Thank you Paige!!

This place is awesome! I’m a Cookie Magic regular and have never had any issues with this location honoring coupons, and the customer service is always amazing! I’ve personally dealt with Paige on many occasions and have always had a great customer experience.