Gotham Bagels

I was very pleased with my sandwich. I had the corned beef and The staff was super helpful!

Ridiculously long wait and outrageous prices-not coming back

Best bagel sandwich I’ve had in a long time.

I love their Bialys and their bagels. The flavor of the bagels evokes memories of rhe NYC bagels....but he doesn't import the water. .and I LOVE that they deliver. They are my go to for family gatherings, and especially the Sunday Brunch. Whitefish salad, lox, Black and White Cookies...and even Dr. Brown sodas. Makes an East Coaster, transplanted to Wisconsin, a little less homesick

recently went on a DC movie binge, so I was like okay, I definitely gotta hit up Gotham Bagels now. Impeccable, clean, delicious, and fairly priced. Not only did it feel like some kind of New York portal experience, but it was tasty. I normally cant enjoy these types of foods cuz of my stomach, but this stores quality allowed me to.

Delicious!

Had our newborn son this week and decided to give this place a try while we were out here. My wife is from long Island and it is tradition for her to have breakfast bagels. Stopped in twice and we will MOST DEFINITELY be making special trips out here!!! So good!!!

Gotham is located between my house and my work, so I love to pop in here for a bagel on the way. The bagels are hearty, chewy, and with a nice crust like you would expect. I normally love everything bagels, but the sesame bagel has my heart after trying many combinations. The bagel sandwiches are so large that I often am able to eat one half for breakfast and one for lunch, making it a great value for the price and also simplifies my work day. The only reason I'm giving 4 instead of 5 (and I would give a 4.5 if Google allowed) is just that my order is frequently around 10 minutes later than the projected time. I solve this issue by ordering earlier than I need it, and I do understand that it is a very popular morning stop for many downtown madisonians.

Great bagel, but the service is lacking and so slow. Got a coffee and a bagel with a cream cheese toasted. Took almost 20 minutes to get.