Geraldi's

People came in, ordered after us, was served before us and finished 20 minutes before our food came.

The best pizza in town, with many other delicious offerings. The pasta sauce is less phenomenal. The parking lot might be the very worst in Fayetteville and it will scrape your car's undercarriage. Parking: Parking is abysmal. The food is well worth the hassle and obstacles. Kid-friendliness: This place accommodates families pretty well, but it can become so packed at night that rambunctious children may compromise the dining experience of others.

This is where I take my people: friends from out of state, family on special occasions, and when I need a fix hahah. The meatballs, the GARLIC BREAD, the pizzas, the spicy Italian sausage, the lasagna, and last but not least, the SPICY CHICKEN ALFREDO. I am always SO HAPPY I went! Fast, friendly service, and it’s SO APPRECIATED in this community. Thank you Geraldi’s!

Very good, traditional pizza. Everyone is always friendly, and the meals are ready quickly. Flavours are good and ingredients are fresh.

Me and a group of friends came up for a football game last fall. We went looking all around town for Italian restaurants that we could actually get in to as it was homecoming weekend. Stumbled upon this place and decided why not. Let me say: don't let the appearance fool you. It ain't the fanciest looking or most attractive place, but the food was fantastic. The massive mozzarella sticks were to die for, the garlic bread made me want to stay in town for another week, and the main course was excellent as well. Definitely a 5* experience and hope to come back soon

Nice little pizza place. Quite a variety of other italian dishes as well. Nice atmosphere and friendly staff.

Our go to Italian food for lunch. Parking can be tight so ride together. Huge salads and delicious lasagna. Parking: Tight and sloped

Update: the spicy chicken Alfredo has been inconsistent & ordered the meatballs for the first time- do not recommend as they were undercooked and flavorless. The marinara sauce wasn’t good either. Great pizza and customer service though! 3.5/5 The pizza and pasta dishes are absolutely delicious! I’ve placed both catering and personal orders in the past and have received consistently amazing food each time! Highly recommend!