Frankie & Johnnie's Steakhouse Rye

We were visiting NYC and we wanted to go somewhere special for my birthday. My friend that is from there said we had to experience a real New York Steak House. It was the best steak we ever had! The waiter was great too.

My husband and I just came back from our anniversary dinner at Frankie & Johnnie’s. We absolutely loved the NY strip with steak fries. We have been looking for a good steak spot in Westchester and finally found it! The service was excellent! Ambiance was great. Everyone was super kind and made us feel so welcome. Waitress was super nice and recommended the Ferrero Rocher gelato for dessert, so glad we went with her suggestion! We will be back to get the porterhouse for two next time! Thanks for making our night so special!

We were well dressed & polite and the waiter was consistently rude. The 12 ounce steak was clearly undersized. (we didn’t mention it). The mashed potatoes were watery. The butter for the bread appeared to be frozen margarine. No one asked us how our food was or if we needed anything. The table was cleared, and 20 minutes later, a different waiter came over with menus as though we had not ordered. We explained that we had eaten and would like to consider after dinner refreshments. This new waiter took over and was also rude. $331 for a lackluster meal. (We noticed they never put the $80. steak in the to-go bag & again, did not mention it). Considering how few patrons they had, they should consider being more polite and gouging customers less.

A lot of nice experiences! Food is generally top notch but there has been some let down occasionally. No matter what, the service is perfect and issues were always promptly fixed. They have a nice wine list as well that isn't overly priced.

From the perspective of an 8 year old, the steak was over salted (the adults thought it was very good).But the rest was very good. Although the Brussels sprouts had too much seasoning (again no issues from the perspective of the adults). Sincerely 8 year old food critic

Food is great, however last time we visited the service wasn’t great.