FYI, the new location is wheelchair accessible. And yeah, still the best pizza in town,
Great professional service,
Great pizza. Sicilian is my favorite.
Wish they had delivery! Best pizza in ithaca
Passion, skill, high quality ingredients. My favorite slice is the cheese Sicilian. The crust is perfection. Tender and crispy in all the right places.
This is by far the best pizza in Ithaca. It’s the closest to NYC pizza in the area. I’ve been more than 100 times and have never been disappointed. Love their new location! It is a big pricey, but worth the price!
Came to visit went by the reviews. I bought a large extra pepperoni looked delicious until my son grabbed the first piece and the pizza was so super floppy that the entire layer of sauce pepperoni and cheese slide off the slice. There was no undercarriage holding up the slice. Plus the pizza was very. Very saucy... So I got a very floppy saucy pie... The sauce was very overpowering. The sauce is very bland.. I tasted it from the cup of sauce they give you for the knots.. I'm glad I put garlic powder red pepper and parmesan cheese on the pizza bc it def needed more flavor... Oh and the guy told me 15 minutes and waited 30 mins that's no big deal.. my deal is with the saucy floppy pie where you pick up a slice and everything falls off.. it was alright pizza plus how can An Italian pizza shop not have coca cola everybody knows especially italians know Italian pizza needs coke to go with it....