Craig's Cookies NOTL

Stumbled upon this small shop on one of the main streets in NOTL. We originally thought it was a local small business, but we have since seen many other locations in Toronto. Their concept of using a chocolate bar/treat to make cookies is unique. For the chocolate bar ones, a portion of the chocolate bar is a nice surprise in the centre of the cookie. The cookies are soft and delicious. But I’d say my preference would be to incorporate the chocolate bar and/or different flavours throughout the entire cookie rather than just in the centre, because the cookie base itself is pretty basic. And if I were to eat a Ferrero Rocher cookie for example, I’d love those chocolate hazelnut flavours throughout. The cookies were still a delicious treat though! Out of the ones we sampled, the brownie and kinder surprise ones were our favourite.

very nice friendly and welcoming service, long opening hours, big variety, everyone is different but if you love cookies you cannot go wrong here. classic is my favorit my son loves sour patch and nutella and ferrero and basicly anything 😁

Rude employee, overcharged us due to his fault and would not correct the problem.

Very good cookies but over priced for what they are 7 and change for two cookies is a little much.

Brownie cookie is the best cookie I’ve ever had

Delicious cookies! I tried a gluten free chocolate chip and it was amazing. Also dog friendly!! The store is so fun and inviting, and the employee was so friendly!

A huge variety of flavorful cookie options. Milk chocolate, dark chocolate, white chocolate, strawberry shortcake cookies and the list goes on. Soft thick cookies full of the stuff that makes sweet treats sweet.

Was super underwhelmed. I have seen a lot about Craig’s online, and it didn’t live up to the hype for me. Almost too many flavours to choose from, a lot of which were gimicky and didn’t even sound like they would be any good. We got 2 cookies - one was gross (didn’t finish it), and one was fine

You can't go wrong with the classic chocolate cookie!