CJ's Italian Restaurant

Hand tossed. Used to be great. Price up. Quality down. Ordered by phone. Picked up on time. Pizza was cold and tasteless just sitting on a cold counter for pick up. Very disappointed.

Deep dish pizza is always delicious! This was our first time trying the dessert (we planned to take them home, hence the containers), they were delicious! They didn't make it home, we ate them right there!

This place is a local favorite. Great deep dish if you like that.. my wife says the best. I love everything about it.

CJ's is a long-time island favorite. The salad greens are always fresh and crisp. The salad dressings are homemade. The interior, although small, has a unique quirkiness to it. Tonight's fare was Baked Spaghetti. An ample serving portion. If you have never been...go! If it's been a bit since you have been give them another try!

Incredible deep dish pizza!

Best deep dish pizza in the country!!

Despite the excellent reviews we were pleasantly surprised how delish our pizza was. Other places on the island have had good reviews but the food did not live up to the hype. Maybe our standards are too high? Anyway, we had the “Noah” pizza for a cause - hand tossed pepperoni/sausage to play it safe. It was awesome. Pizza is my favorite food, btw. My better half loved the meatballs, too. Jam packed at 5:30 and by 6:30 when we left people were leaving because the place was full with a wait. It’s tiny so go early or call-in your order. Excellent service, too. We will be back!

Fantastic food and service. We love coming in to eat and they have a great staff. The deep dish is the BOMB!

I ordered a pizza to go and when I got there at the specified pickup time (70 minutes after order) my order wasn’t even in process. The restaurant was slammed so I was told to wait with no information as to how long. The staff was dismissive and the pizza cook was belligerent and completely stressed out yelling about no pizza cutters and throwing boxes around. While I love the food, I doubt I’ll ever go back there after the treatment I received. I eventually got my pizza 40 minutes after I arrived to pick it up.