Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

I didn’t even purchase anything from here, but the place nexts doors restroom was broken. They let us come in and use it and we’re just SO kind. I wish we had gotten food from here, too!!!

Both the key lime and Granny’s apple are my absolute favorites from here. Whenever I want a sweet treat and it’s pie, Buttermilk Sky Pie never disappoints me. The store associates are always eager to help and friendly. Y’all should check them out and try the Granny’s Apple pie Parking: Parking is free and plenty of spaces are available.

Ordered and paid for a peanut butter pie a week ahead. Get there to pick it up today and it is sheer chaos and they are out of peanut butter pie?

The taste was bad. Not only the taste was bad, the staff were quite disrespectful. I waited 10 minutes in front of the cash register while one teenage staff was working and the other doing nothing at the open kitchen area. They looked at me and just let me waited there. Shopping here was just an unpleasant experience for me.

This is a wonderful little pie shop. From the 4" sample box to the full size pies. Each more delicious than the last. We were lucky enough to be there for the new fall flavors. The Spiced Applebutter Pie was fantastic.