Bagel Bakery Cafe

They have fresh bagels everyday and their crab bagel is awesome. I get one almost every week and I’ll be making a stop there Saturday morning for another one

What a wonderful cafe. Everything is yummy (bagels are the best) and the people are awesome! We will visit often. Jeff and Leighann

Bagels are unreal! Just fresh and amazing !!

Great service and soft fresh bagels... Yummy

The very best bagels you can get anywhere on the eastern shore.. I've lived in New York City, and you would be hard pressed to be able to differentiate the bagels there, versus the bagels here at Bagel Bakery. Everything is fresh and delicious, you will not be disappointed.. Definitely a MUST try when you are in the area!!

Yummy. Clean and friendly. Great muffins and sandwiches. Bagel pops sweet and fun.

I’m from NJ but am in Salisbury nearly every weekend so I know a good bagel when I get one. This place has them! I’ve been in search of a bagel that reminds me of the kind of bagels I had growing up which becoming harder and harder to do so in southern NJ as shops change ownership and recipes change or ingredients change due to cost. That being said, the Bagel Bakery cafe has the absolute best bagel I’ve had in about 30 years. Not even the bagel shops near me in NJ are this perfect in my opinion, well, not without having to drive an hour and a half north to the NYC end of the state anyway. Their bagels taste as good as they look. The bagel skin has the perfect amount of hardness to it that you know if you go with regular butter over a schmear, it’s going to keep the butter in. Oh and when butter melts into it, biting in to the bagel is next to heaven. There is the perfect amount of toppings too. They don’t skimp. I can’t wait to come back next weekend and get more. Next time, I’m getting a dozen and bringing them home. I’m thoroughly impressed. Also, the croissant and cinnamon roll I had from here over the weekend also deserve honorable mention because they too left me doing a happy food dance while I ate. Customer service was top notch. I’m so glad I found this place!