Yo Pauly's New York Pizza Co Menu

4.6

(950+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Get-Cha Wings!Somethin' to Munch On Big City Salads Yo Pauly's Piz'zas NY Calzones & Stromboli Sandwiches San Gennaro's Feast Dinner Yo Pauly's Kids Menu Sweet Endings Something to Drink

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- 18" Cheese Louise
  Keeping it original with mozzarella & our signature pizza sauce.
  $22.80
- 14" Cheese Louise
  Keeping it original with mozzarella & our signature pizza sauce.
  $17.40
- Old School Garlic Knots
  Pizza dough tied in a knot and brushed with olive oil, fresh garlic, and spices. served with marinara sauce.
  $4.20
- Single Hit (12)
  12 chicken wings with a choice of flavors: buffalo medium, sweet & tangy BBQ, lemon butter & oregano, or sweet & spicy.
  $16.19
- 10" Cheese Louise
  Keeping it original with mozzarella & our signature pizza sauce.
  $11.99
- 18" Ziggy's Favorite ZA
  Pepperoni, sausage, sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil.
  $30.60
- 18" Da Midtown Meltdown
  Extra pepperoni & extra cheese.
  $29.99
- 14" Ziggy's Favorite ZA
  Pepperoni, sausage, sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil.
  $23.40
- Manhattan Meatballs
  Three delicious meatballs in marinara sauce.
  $7.19
- Mozzarella Sticks (6)
  Crispy breaded mozzarella sticks served with a side of tangy marinara sauce.
  $8.39
Get-Cha Wings!
- Single Hit (12)
  12 chicken wings with a choice of flavors: buffalo medium, sweet & tangy BBQ, lemon butter & oregano, or sweet & spicy.
  $16.19
Somethin' to Munch On
Feeds 2-3 comfortably.
- Old School Garlic Knots
  Pizza dough tied in a knot and brushed with olive oil, fresh garlic, and spices. served with marinara sauce.
  $4.20
- Totally Cheesy Knots
  Garlic knots smothered in mozzarella cheese.
  $5.99
- Manhattan Meatballs
  Three delicious meatballs in marinara sauce.
  $7.19
- Fried Rav's (6)
  $7.19
- Fried Rav's (12)
  $14.39
- French Fries (Basket)
  $5.40
- Mozzarella Sticks (6)
  Crispy breaded mozzarella sticks served with a side of tangy marinara sauce.
  $8.39
- Mozzarella Sticks (12)
  $15.59
Big City Salads
Add grilled chicken to any salad for an additional charge.
- Small Standard Antipasto
  Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, red onions, peppers, tomatoes, olives, cucumbers, and pepperoncinis on a bed of mixed lettuce with balsamic vinaigrette.
  $8.39
- Large Standard Antipasto
  Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, red onions, peppers, tomatoes, olives, cucumbers, and pepperoncinis on a bed of mixed lettuce with balsamic vinaigrette.
  $15.59
- Small Jimmy the Greek
  Mixed lettuce, feta cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, green peppers, kalamata olives & pepperoncinis.
  $8.39
- Large Jimmy the Greek
  Mixed lettuce, feta cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, green peppers, kalamata olives & pepperoncinis.
  $15.59
- Small Chop Salad
  Mixed lettuce, feta cheese, bacon, cucumbers, olives, tomatoes & served with our balsamic ranch dressing.
  $8.39
- Large Chop Salad
  Mixed lettuce, feta cheese, bacon, cucumbers, olives, tomatoes & served with our balsamic ranch dressing.
  $15.59
- Small Traditional House
  Mixed lettuce, tomato, cucumber, with black & green olives.
  $6.59
- Large Traditional House
  Mixed lettuce, tomato, cucumber, with black & green olives.
  $11.99
- Small Hail Caesar
  Romaine lettuce, croutons & grated parmesan cheese with Caesar dressing.
  $6.59
- Large Hail Caesar
  Romaine lettuce, croutons & grated parmesan cheese with Caesar dressing.
  $11.39
Yo Pauly's Piz'zas
Our signature, NY-style thin-crust pizzas.
- 10" Cheese Louise
  Keeping it original with mozzarella & our signature pizza sauce.
  $11.99
- 14" Cheese Louise
  Keeping it original with mozzarella & our signature pizza sauce.
  $17.40
- 18" Cheese Louise
  Keeping it original with mozzarella & our signature pizza sauce.
  $22.80
- 10" Da Midtown Meltdown
  Extra pepperoni & extra cheese.
  $16.20
- 14" Da Midtown Meltdown
  Extra pepperoni & extra cheese.
  $22.20
- 18" Da Midtown Meltdown
  Extra pepperoni & extra cheese.
  $29.99
- 10" Margarita Village
  Olive oil, garlic, a light touch of pizza sauce, tomatoes, fresh basil, & mozzarella.
  $14.39
- 14" Margarita Village
  Olive oil, garlic, a light touch of pizza sauce, tomatoes, fresh basil, & mozzarella.
  $21.59
- 18" Margarita Village
  Olive oil, garlic, a light touch of pizza sauce, tomatoes, fresh basil, & mozzarella.
  $28.79
- 10" It's All Greek To Me
  Garlic, feta & mozzarella cheese, sauce, fresh tomatoes, spinach, red onion, olive oil & topped with kalamata olives, OPA!
  $16.20
- 14" It's All Greek To Me
  Garlic, feta & mozzarella cheese, sauce, fresh tomatoes, spinach, red onion, olive oil & topped with kalamata olives, OPA!
  $23.40
- 18" It's All Greek To Me
  Garlic, feta & mozzarella cheese, sauce, fresh tomatoes, spinach, red onion, olive oil & topped with kalamata olives, OPA!
  $30.60
- 10" Hawaiian Vacation
  Smoked ham, pineapple, sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil.
  $16.20
- 14" Hawaiian Vacation
  Smoked ham, pineapple, sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil.
  $23.40
- 18" Hawaiian Vacation
  Smoked ham, pineapple, sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil.
  $30.60
- 10" The Godfather
  Garlic, ham, pepperoni, salami, mozzarella, sauce, pepperoncinis, olive oil & fresh basil.
  $16.20
- 14" The Godfather
  Garlic, ham, pepperoni, salami, mozzarella, sauce, pepperoncinis, olive oil & fresh basil.
  $23.40
- 18" The Godfather
  Garlic, ham, pepperoni, salami, mozzarella, sauce, pepperoncinis, olive oil & fresh basil.
  $31.19
- 10" 5 Boroughs BBQ Chicken
  Garlic & oil, BBQ sauce, mozzarella, red onions & of course, chicken.
  $16.99
- 14" 5 Boroughs BBQ Chicken
  Garlic & oil, BBQ sauce, mozzarella, red onions & of course, chicken.
  $23.40
- 18" 5 Boroughs BBQ Chicken
  Garlic & oil, BBQ sauce, mozzarella, red onions & of course, chicken.
  $31.80
- 10" Whitestone Bridge
  Our "white" pie with fresh garlic, ricotta cheese, mozzarella, fresh spinach, olive oil & tomatoes.
  $16.99
- 14" Whitestone Bridge
  Our "white" pie with fresh garlic, ricotta cheese, mozzarella, fresh spinach, olive oil & tomatoes.
  $23.40
- 18" Whitestone Bridge
  Our "white" pie with fresh garlic, ricotta cheese, mozzarella, fresh spinach, olive oil & tomatoes.
  $30.60
- 10" Madison Square Garden
  Tomatoes, green peppers, onion, sauce, mozzarella, black olives & mushrooms.
  $16.20
- 14" Madison Square Garden
  Tomatoes, green peppers, onion, sauce, mozzarella, black olives & mushrooms.
  $23.40
- 18" Madison Square Garden
  Tomatoes, green peppers, onion, sauce, mozzarella, black olives & mushrooms.
  $29.40
- 10" Ziggy's Favorite ZA
  Pepperoni, sausage, sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil.
  $16.20
- 14" Ziggy's Favorite ZA
  Pepperoni, sausage, sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil.
  $23.40
- 18" Ziggy's Favorite ZA
  Pepperoni, sausage, sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil.
  $30.60
- 10" Wiseguy's Choice
  Pick any 3 toppings & we'll build it for ya.
  $16.20
- 14" Wiseguy's Choice
  Pick any 3 toppings & we'll build it for ya.
  $23.40
- 18" Wiseguy's Choice
  Pick any 3 toppings & we'll build it for ya.
  $30.60
- 10" Melting Pot
  Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, sauce, mozzarella, ham & bacon.
  $16.79
- 14" Melting Pot
  Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, sauce, mozzarella, ham & bacon.
  $23.99
- 18" Melting Pot
  Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, sauce, mozzarella, ham & bacon.
  $32.39
- 10" The Big Apple
  Sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, green peppers, black olives, sauce, mozzarella, onions & mushrooms.
  $16.79
- 14" The Big Apple
  Sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, green peppers, black olives, sauce, mozzarella, onions & mushrooms.
  $23.99
- 18" The Big Apple
  Sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, green peppers, black olives, sauce, mozzarella, onions & mushrooms.
  $32.39
- 10" The New Yorker
  Olive oil, garlic, sauce, mozzarella, eggplant, tomatoes & fresh basil.
  $16.20
- 14" The New Yorker
  Olive oil, garlic, sauce, mozzarella, eggplant, tomatoes & fresh basil.
  $22.79
- 18" The New Yorker
  Olive oil, garlic, sauce, mozzarella, eggplant, tomatoes & fresh basil.
  $30.60
NY Calzones & Stromboli
All served with marinara sauce.
- Ham it Up Calzone
  Ricotta & mozzarella cheeses with lotsa thin sliced ham.
  $15.59
- Little Italy Calzone
  Ricotta & mozzarella cheeses with pepperoni & sausage.
  $15.59
- Tri State Calzone
  Ricotta & mozzarella cheeses with your choice of any 3 toppings.
  $15.59
- City Slickers Calzone
  Ricotta & mozzarella with eggplant, tomato, mushrooms & fresh basil.
  $15.59
- Daily News Stromboli
  Sausage, pepperoni & ham with mozzarella, rolled up like the daily newspaper.
  $15.59
Sandwiches
Big sandwiches from the Big Apple. *Da works include lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, and vinegar, salt & pepper. On a low-carb diet? Order it without the bread!
- The Mayor's Meatball Parmesan
  Meatballs, marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella.
  $13.19
- Chelsea Chicken Parmesan
  Breaded chicken cutlet, marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella.
  $14.39
- Goodfella's Eggplant Parmesan
  Breaded eggplant, marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella.
  $14.39
- Long Island BLT
  Bacon, lettuce & tomato with mayo, oil, vinegar & black pepper.
  $11.99
- The Italian Job
  Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni, provolone, cheese, spicy mustard & da works*. Da works includes lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, vinegar, salt & pepper.
  $13.19
- City Hall Chicken
  Crispy chicken cutlet, mayo & da works*. Da works includes lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, vinegar, salt & pepper.
  $14.39
San Gennaro's Feast Dinner
Just like being in Little Italy. "I'll make you a pasta you can't refuse."
- Sonny's Spaghetti
  A generous portion of meatballs with spaghetti & marinara sauce.
  $14.39
- Bensonhurst Baked Ziti
  Penne pasta, ricotta cheese, our signature marinara sauce, Parmesan & mozzarella cheese.
  $16.79
- Grandma's Chicken Parmesan
  Breaded chicken cutlet, our signature marinara sauce, Parmesan & mozzarella cheese. Served with penne pasta.
  $17.99
- Mama Leone's Eggplant
  Breaded eggplant, our signature marinara sauce, Parmesan & mozzarella cheese. Served with penne pasta.
  $17.99
- Ravioli Rav's Dinner
  $9.99
- Ravioli & Meatballs
  $15.59
Yo Pauly's Kids Menu
Served with a soft drink and three garlic knots.
- Arron's Pasta
  Penne pasta served with melted butter & a side of marinara sauce for dipping.
  $7.79
- Little Joey's Pizza
  One slice of cheese pizza cut into bite sized pieces.
  $6.59
- Eddie's Spaghetti & Meatball
  Kids' sized pasta with marinara and one meatball.
  $9.59
- Chicken Strips
  Breaded n' fried, served with a side of ranch dressing.
  $10.29
Sweet Endings
Worth saving room for. Serves 2-3 people.
- NY Cheesecake
  World famous NY cheesecake with cherry topping.
  $6.90
- Coney Island Cannolis
  Six mini cannoli shells filled with traditional Italian cream & chocolate chips.
  $10.79
- 1 Cannoli
  Crispy pastry shells filled with sweet ricotta cream, drizzled with chocolate sauce and dusted with powdered sugar.
  $2.40
Something to Drink
- Pepsi - Fountain
  The bold, refreshing, robust cola.
  $3.30
- Diet Pepsi - Fountain
  A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories.
  $3.30
- Starry - Fountain
  A caffeine-free soda that provides a crisp, clear burst of lemon lime flavor
  $3.30
- Mtn Dew - Fountain
  Mtn Dew exhilarates and quenches thirst with its one of a kind citrus taste.
  $3.30
- Brisk Iced Tea Unsweetened - Fountain
  Brisk has become the badge of creative hustlers everywhere. By bringing in-your-face flavors and vibrant colors to the juice drink and iced tea game we help you make your mark on the world.
  $3.30
- Brisk Iced Tea Raspberry - Fountain
  Brisk has become the badge of creative hustlers everywhere. By bringing in-your-face flavors and vibrant colors to the juice drink and iced tea game we help you make your mark on the world.
  $3.30
- Mug Root Beer - Fountain
  Appeal to the senses with a rich foam, unique aroma and the feeling of ice-cold refreshment
  $3.30
- Dr. Pepper - Fountain
  A signature blend of 23 flavors makes every sip of Dr. Pepper truly unique.
  $3.30

Menu Photos

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Yo Pauly's New York Pizza Co Menu

Customer Favorites

18" Cheese Louise

14" Cheese Louise

Old School Garlic Knots

Single Hit (12)

10" Cheese Louise

18" Ziggy's Favorite ZA

18" Da Midtown Meltdown

14" Ziggy's Favorite ZA

Manhattan Meatballs

Mozzarella Sticks (6)

Get-Cha Wings!

Single Hit (12)

Somethin' to Munch On

Old School Garlic Knots

Totally Cheesy Knots

Manhattan Meatballs

Fried Rav's (6)

Fried Rav's (12)

French Fries (Basket)

Mozzarella Sticks (6)

Mozzarella Sticks (12)

Big City Salads

Small Standard Antipasto

Large Standard Antipasto

Small Jimmy the Greek

Large Jimmy the Greek

Small Chop Salad

Large Chop Salad

Small Traditional House

Large Traditional House

Small Hail Caesar

Large Hail Caesar

Yo Pauly's Piz'zas

10" Cheese Louise

14" Cheese Louise

18" Cheese Louise

10" Da Midtown Meltdown

14" Da Midtown Meltdown

18" Da Midtown Meltdown

10" Margarita Village

14" Margarita Village

18" Margarita Village

10" It's All Greek To Me

14" It's All Greek To Me

18" It's All Greek To Me

10" Hawaiian Vacation

14" Hawaiian Vacation

18" Hawaiian Vacation

10" The Godfather

14" The Godfather

18" The Godfather

10" 5 Boroughs BBQ Chicken

14" 5 Boroughs BBQ Chicken

18" 5 Boroughs BBQ Chicken

10" Whitestone Bridge

14" Whitestone Bridge

18" Whitestone Bridge

10" Madison Square Garden

14" Madison Square Garden

18" Madison Square Garden

10" Ziggy's Favorite ZA

14" Ziggy's Favorite ZA

18" Ziggy's Favorite ZA

10" Wiseguy's Choice

14" Wiseguy's Choice

18" Wiseguy's Choice

10" Melting Pot

14" Melting Pot

18" Melting Pot

10" The Big Apple

14" The Big Apple

18" The Big Apple

10" The New Yorker

14" The New Yorker

18" The New Yorker

NY Calzones & Stromboli

Ham it Up Calzone

Little Italy Calzone