Winking Lizard Reynoldsburg Menu

4.3

(1,250+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Sandwiches Lizard Wings Condiments Reptizers Salads & Soups Pizza Burger Board Lizard Wraps Chicken Chest Haddock & Nashville Hot Lizard Grill Sides Spare Parts Delectable Desserts Kids Menu Wing Sauce Bottles

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Traditional Wings
  Popular. House specialty! We use only the freshest jumbo wings, never frozen! Served with celery and bleu cheese or ranch dressing.
  $9.90
- Boneless Wing
  Popular. Boneless chicken breast breaded and deep fried to crisp and juicy perfection. Served with celery and blue cheese or ranch dressing. Try them tossed in your favorite lizard sauce.
  $8.80
- Chopped Lizard Salad
  Popular. Mixed greens topped with cheddar cheese, bacon, egg, and tomatoes.
  $11.55
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap
  Spicy. Tender slices of chicken breast basted in our hot sauce and rolled up in a soft tortilla with lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese and a side of blue cheese for dipping.
  $14.85
- Mac & Cheese Wedges
  Vegetarian. Sixteen breaded wedges filled with macaroni and cheese and fried until golden brown. Served with ranch dipping sauce.
  $11.00
- Mini Burger Basket
  Popular. Four slider burgers served on rolls with American cheese and pickle chips.
  $15.40
- Soft Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
  A basket of authentic Bavarian pretzel sticks, served with cheese cause and spicy brown mustard.
  $11.55
- Steak Fries
  Popular, vegetarian. Steak fries.
  $3.85
- Pfred's Preferred Pfries
  Fries baked with lots of cheddar and mozzarella cheese and topped with bacon.
  $8.80
- Fried Cheese Wedges
  Vegetarian. Italian breaded wedges of provolone cheese fried crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Served with marinara dipping sauce.
  $11.00
Sandwiches
Served with your choice of steak fries, mac and cheese, baked beans, coleslaw, apple sauce, rice pilaf or steamed broccoli. Substitute onion rings or pfred's preferred fries (baked with lots of cheddar and mozzarella cheese topped with bacon) for additional charges. Pickle spear available upon request.
- Grilled Cheese
  American and mozzarella cheese melted between grilled sourdough bread.
  $7.15
- Tomato Bacon Grilled Cheese
  Tomato, Applewood bacon, American and mozzarella cheese melted between grilled sourdough bread.
  $9.35
Lizard Wings
- Traditional Wings
  Popular. House specialty! We use only the freshest jumbo wings, never frozen! Served with celery and bleu cheese or ranch dressing.
  $9.90
- Boneless Wing
  Popular. Boneless chicken breast breaded and deep fried to crisp and juicy perfection. Served with celery and blue cheese or ranch dressing. Try them tossed in your favorite lizard sauce.
  $8.80
Condiments
Please specify if you need any condiments with your order. They will not automatically get put in your bag, though we would be happy to provide them for you. These are the condiments we offer as a courtesy to all of our guests. Other condiments may show up as a free or charge option, specifically for the menu item you order.
- Condiments
  Condiments available upon request, including ketchup, mustard, mayonnaise, and special house sauces to complement your burger.
Reptizers
- Spinach & Artichoke Dip
  A creamy blend of chopped spinach, tender artichoke hearts, and Parmesan cheese. Topped with diced tomatoes and served with warm tortilla chips and salsa.
  $12.65
- Pfred's Preferred Pfries
  Fries baked with lots of cheddar and mozzarella cheese and topped with bacon.
  $8.80
- Fried Cheese Wedges
  Vegetarian. Italian breaded wedges of provolone cheese fried crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Served with marinara dipping sauce.
  $11.00
- Mac & Cheese Wedges
  Vegetarian. Sixteen breaded wedges filled with macaroni and cheese and fried until golden brown. Served with ranch dipping sauce.
  $11.00
- Loaded Lizard Nachos & Cheese
  Nachos covered with cheddar, mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, onions, black olives, green peppers, and jalapeños. You can make it with plain chips with cheddar cheese sauce and a side of salsa or with chicken for additional charges.
  $9.35
- Lizard Lips
  Chicken tenders deep fried golden brown. Served with BBQ, honey mustard or ranch. Available tossed in any of our wing sauces.
  $11.55
- Garlic Cheese Bread
  Vegetarian. Garlic cheese bread.
  $4.95
- Beer Battered Onion Rings (Full Pound)
  Vegetarian. One pound of beer battered onion rings served in a basket with ranch dressing.
  $11.55
- Lizard Freckles
  A basket of breaded and fried pickles chips served with a side of ranch. Not currently available in Columbus, but will be soon.
  $9.90
- Soft Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
  A basket of authentic Bavarian pretzel sticks, served with cheese cause and spicy brown mustard.
  $11.55
- BBQ Lizard Bones-1/2 slab
  **Not available in Columbus or Galleria** Hickory Smoked St. Louis style ribs charbroiled and basted in our award winning BBQ sauce.
  $14.30
- BBQ Lizard Bones-Bucket
  **Not available in Columbus or Galleria** Hickory Smoked St. Louis style ribs charbroiled and basted in our award winning BBQ sauce. Approximately 18 bones
  $33.55
- Quesadilla
  Grilled flour tortilla shell filled with melted cheddar cheese , tomato, onion, and green pepper. Served with a side of sour cream and salsa.
  $9.90
Salads & Soups
- House Salad
  Popular. A bed of mixed greens with shredded cheddar cheese, and seasoned croutons. Garnished with a slice of cucumber, diced tomatoes.
  $8.25
- Caesar Salad-Small
  Fresh romaine lettuce tossed with our Caesar dressing and topped with Parmesan cheese and croutons
  $7.15
- Chicken Caesar Salad
  Fresh romaine lettuce tossed with our Caesar dressing and topped with Parmesan cheese and croutons and a grilled chicken breast. Dinner-sized portion!
  $13.75
- Chopped Lizard Salad
  Popular. Mixed greens topped with cheddar cheese, bacon, egg, and tomatoes.
  $11.55
- Mesa Chop Chicken Salad
  A Santa Fe seasoned chicken breast on a bed of mixed greens topped with black bean and fire roasted corn salsa, mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, and crispy tortilla strips. Served with a Southwestern ranch dressing.
  $15.40
- Mesa Chop Salad (No Meat)
  A bed of greens topped with black bean and fire roasted corn salsa, mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, and crispy tortilla strips. Served with a Southwestern ranch dressing.
  $11.55
- Buffalo Chicken Salad
  Spicy. Crispy chicken tenders tossed in our hot sauce, cheddar cheese, diced tomatoes, and celery. Served on top of fresh mixed greens. Served with blue cheese dressing.
  $15.40
- Spinach Salad
  A blend of spinach, chopped egg, bacon, sliced mushrooms, diced tomatoes, and banana pepper rings. Served with choice of dressing.
  $11.55
- Cajun Chicken Spinach Salad
  Spicy. Charbroiled chicken breast seasoned with our own cajun spices, on a bed of spinach and mozzarella cheese, garnished with chopped egg, bacon, tomatoes, and mushrooms. Served with choice of dressing.
  $15.40
Pizza
- Roasted Garlic Chicken Pizza Small 9" (6 cut)
  ***New*** Garlic oil, herbs, chicken breast, spinach, mozzarella and provolone cheeses.
  $15.40
- Roasted Garlic Chicken Pizza Large 12" (8 cut)
  ***New*** Garlic oil, herbs, chicken breast, spinach, mozzarella and provolone cheeses.
  $17.60
- White Bread Pizza Small 9" (6 cut)
  Garlic oil, herbs, mozzarella, and provolone cheeses.
  $11.55
- White Bread Pizza Large 12" (8 cut)
  Garlic oil, herbs, mozzarella, and provolone cheeses.
  $13.20
- Make Your Own Small 9" (6 cut)
  We make and toss our own fresh dough, top it with an old family recipe sauce, add freshly grated mozzarella and provolone cheese and let your do the rest! Mangia Bene! Take a look at our tantalizing toppings and add your favorite!
  $11.55
- Make Your Own Large 12" (8 cut)
  We make and toss our own fresh dough, top it with an old family recipe sauce, add freshly grated mozzarella and provolone cheese and let your do the rest! Mangia Bene! Take a look at our tantalizing toppings and add your favorite!
  $13.20
- Deluxe Pizza Small 9" (6 cut)
  Pepperoni, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, sausage, pizza sauce, mozzarella and provolone cheeses.
  $16.50
- Deluxe Pizza Large 12" (8 cut)
  Pepperoni, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, sausage, pizza sauce, mozzarella and provolone cheeses.
  $19.80
- Vegetarian Pizza Small 9" (6 cut)
  Onions, mushrooms, green peppers, tomatoes, pizza sauce, mozzarella and provolone cheeses.
  $15.40
- Vegetarian Pizza Large 12" (8 cut)
  Onions, mushrooms, green peppers, tomatoes, pizza sauce, mozzarella and provolone cheeses.
  $17.60
Burger Board
Fresh (never frozen) half pound of ground beef, charbroiled to perfection and served on a deluxe roll with your choice of steak fries, mixed vegetables, mac and cheese or steamed broccoli. Substitute onion rings or pfred's preferred fries (baked with lots of cheddar and mozzarella cheese topped with bacon) for additional charges.
- Patty Melt
  Charbroiled ground beef patty with American cheese and grilled onions. Served on grilled rye bread.
  $14.85
- Bacon Cheeseburger
  American cheese topped with strips of applewood bacon.
  $15.40
- Hamburger
  Fresh ground beef, charbroiled to perfection.
  $13.75
- Cheeseburger
  Fresh ground beef, charbroiled to perfection, topped with your choice of cheese.
  $14.30
- Blue Shroom Burger
  Spicy. Flame broiled and seasoned with Cajun spices and topped with melted blue cheese, grilled mushrooms and strips of applewood bacon.
  $15.95
- Bayou Burger
  Spicy. Seasoned with our Cajun spices topped with melted mozzarella cheese and grilled mushrooms.
  $14.85
- Big Ed Burger
  A premium one pound double bacon cheeseburger.
  $20.90
- Wild Western Burger
  Based in our award winning BBQ sauce, topped with American cheese, applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato and a pile of fried onion straws.
  $15.40
- Hanson Burger
  Swiss cheese topped with grilled onions and sautéed mushrooms.
  $14.85
- Black Bean Vegetable Burger
  Spicy, vegetarian. A spicy blend of black beans, peppers, and Southwestern spices, served on a multi-grain hamburger roll with corn salsa, cheddar cheese, lettuce and a pile of crisp onion straws.
  $13.20
- Bo-Man's Bacon Cheeseburger
  Cajun burger served on fresh garlic bread with lettuce, tomato, American cheese, and applewood bacon.
  $15.95
- Mini Burger Basket
  Popular. Four slider burgers served on rolls with American cheese and pickle chips.
  $15.40
Lizard Wraps
Served with your choice of steak fries, mixed vegetables, mac and cheese or steamed broccoli. Substitute onion rings or pfred's preferred fries (baked with lots of cheddar and mozzarella cheese topped with bacon) for additional charges.
- Cajun Chicken Wrap
  Spicy. Cajun charbroiled chicken breast, lettuce, onion, green pepper, tomato, and cheddar cheese all rolled up in a warm flour tortilla shell with Southwestern ranch.
  $14.85
- Southwestern Veggie Wrap
  Vegetarian. Black Bean vegetable burger, lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese and corn salsa all rolled up in a flour tortilla shell. Served with southwestern ranch.
  $13.20
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap
  Spicy. Tender slices of chicken breast basted in our hot sauce and rolled up in a soft tortilla with lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese and a side of blue cheese for dipping.
  $14.85
Chicken Chest
Served with your choice of steak fries, mixed vegetables, mac and cheese or steamed broccoli. Substitute onion rings or pfred's preferred fries (baked with lots of cheddar and mozzarella cheese topped with bacon) for additional charges.
- Bo-Man's Chicken Philly
  Chicken breast broiled and topped with mozzarella cheese, grilled onions, and mushrooms. Served on garlic bread.
  $15.40
- Bo-Man's Chicken Parmesan
  Fresh chicken breast, lightly breaded with Italian bread crumbs, smothered in marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese. Served on garlic bread.
  $15.40
- Bo-Man's Honey Club
  Breaded chicken breast tossed in our own honey mustard sauce then topped with mozzarella cheese, applewood bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Served on garlic bread.
  $15.40
- BBQ Chicken Club
  A grilled chicken breast basted in our award winning BBQ sauce, topped with cheddar cheese, applewood bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Served on a deluxe roll.
  $14.30
- Buffalo Chicken
  Spicy. A grilled chicken breast basted in our hot sauce and served with lettuce, tomato and a side of creamy blue cheese. Served on a deluxe roll.
  $13.75
- Jerk Chicken Sandwich
  Spicy. A grilled chicken breast coated with jerk seasoning, basted in our Caribbean wing sauce and topped with lettuce, tomato, and red onion. Served on a deluxe roll.
  $14.30
- Cajun Chicken Sandwich
  Spicy. Cajun chicken breast, topped with melted mozzarella cheese. Served on a deluxe roll.
  $13.75
- Cheddar Club
  A grilled chicken breast topped with cheddar cheese, applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato and a side of mayo. Served on a deluxe roll.
  $14.30
- Just Plain Fowl
  Our grilled chicken breast served with lettuce, tomato and a side of mayo. Available BBQ or honey mustard style. Served on a deluxe roll.
  $13.75
- Maui Maui
  Our grilled chicken breast marinated in teriyaki and topped with grilled pineapple. Served on a deluxe roll.
  $14.30
- Bo-Man's Buffalo
  Spicy. Tender chicken breast lightly breaded and crispy fried, tossed in our hot sauce then topped with mozzarella cheese, lettuce and tomato. Served with a side of blue cheese. Served on garlic bread.
  $15.40
Haddock & Nashville Hot
- Beer Battered Haddock Sandwich
  Large filet of haddock, beer battered, fries and served on a hoagie roll with shredded lettuce and tomato. Served with steak fries and a side of tartar sauce.
  $14.30
- Beer Battered Haddock Dinner
  A large filet of haddock, beer battered, fried to a crisp golden brown. Served with steak fries, coleslaw, garlic cheese bread and a side of tartar sauce.
  $15.40
- Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
  Breaded chicken breast fried then tossed in our Nashville hot sauce. Served on a fresh brioche bun topped with pickle chips and a Tennessee smoky ranch. Served with a side of steak fries.
  $14.30
Lizard Grill
Served with cole slaw, garlic bread and your choice of steak fries, mixed vegetables, mac and cheese, or steamed broccoli. Substitute a house salad for cole slaw for additional charges and substitute onion rings or pfred's preferred fries (baked with lots of cheddar and mozzarella cheese topped with bacon) for steak fries for additional charges.
- Teriyaki Chicken Breast
  Twelve ounces of chicken breast charbroiled and basted in our teriyaki sauce, topped with a pineapple ring.
  $14.85
- BBQ Chicken
  Twelve ounces of boneless chicken breast in our award winning BBQ sauce.
  $14.85
- 12 oz. Strip Steak
  A juicy, tender strip steak seasoned and charbroiled to your temperature of choice.
  $20.90
- St Louis Dinner-Half Slab
  **Not available in Columbus or Galleria** Juicy and meaty St. Louis ribs seasoned with our special rub, slowly smoked then grilled and basted with our award winning BBQ Sauce.
  $18.70
- St Louis Rib Dinner-Full slab
  **Not available in Columbus or Galleria** Juicy and meaty St. Louis ribs seasoned with our special rub, slowly smoked then grilled and basted with our award winning BBQ sauce.
  $25.85
Sides
- Cole Slaw
  Vegetarian. Cole slaw.
  $2.75
- Applesauce
  Smooth, pureed apples with a hint of sweetness.
  $2.20
- Mac & Cheese
  Vegetarian. Mac and Cheese.
  $3.85
- Long Grain Rice
  Long grain rice
  $3.85
- Baked beans
  our famous house style baked beans with onions and bacon
  $3.85
- Steamed Broccoli
  Vegetarian. Steamed broccoli.
  $3.85
- Steak Fries
  Popular, vegetarian. Steak fries.
  $3.85
- Cup of Soup of the Day
  Made fresh from scratch daily and served piping hot.
  $3.85
- Bowl of Soup of the Day
  Made fresh from scratch daily and served piping hot.
  $5.50
- House Salad
  A bed of iceberg lettuce with shredded cheddar cheese and seasoned croutons. garnished with a slice of cucumber and diced tomato.
  $8.25
- Caesar Salad
  Fresh romaine tossed with our fresh made dressing and topped with shaved parmesan cheese and croutons.
  $7.70
Spare Parts
- Slice of Cheese
  Choice of American, Cheddar, Mozzarella, or Swiss cheese slice.
  $0.75
- Crumbled Bleu
  Crumbled bleu typically includes a generous topping of bleu cheese crumbles, often accompanied by ingredients that complement its rich and tangy flavor profile.
  $1.65
- Applewood Bacon
  Applewood smoked bacon, typically served crispy.
  $2.20
Delectable Desserts
- Cookies and Cream Pie
  Rich cream pie filled with chunks of chocolate cookies, topped with cookie crumbles and a whole chocolate cookie.
  $6.25
Kids Menu
- Kid Salad
  Mixed greens. Choose from 10 dressings, including options like 1000 Island, Caesar, Housemade Ranch, and Raspberry Vinaigrette (Fat Free).
  $6.60
- 2 Mini Burgers
  Two bite-sized burgers with choice of one side from options like fries, mac & cheese, and applesauce.
  $6.60
- 2 Mini Cheese Burgers
  Fresh ground beef charbroiled to perfection and topped with your choice of cheese. fresh (never frozen) half pound of ground beef charbroiled to perfection and served on a deluxe roll with your choice of steak fries mixed vegetables macaroni and cheese or steamed broccoli.
  $6.60
- 3 Lizard Lips
  3 lizard lips Choices of kids-friendly sides like fries, mac & cheese, applesauce, and more. One wing sauce option available from plain to extremely spicy (Fire in the Hole).
  $6.60
- 8 Fried Mac & Cheese
  Vegetarian. mac and cheese.
  $6.60
- 8 Mini Corn Dogs
  Mini corn dogs with a choice of kid-friendly sides including fries, mac & cheese, steamed broccoli, applesauce, or salad.
  $6.60
- 5 Traditional Wings
  Chicken wings served with a choice of kids' sides like fries, mac & cheese, soup, salad, and more. Wing sauce options range from mild to extremely hot, including BBQ, honey mustard, teriyaki, and more.
  $10.45
- 5 Boneless Wings
  Popular. boneless chicken breast breaded and deep fried to crisp and juicy perfection. served with celery and blue cheese or ranch dressing. try them tossed in your favorite lizard sauce.
  $8.25
- Nacho Chips with Cheese Sauce
  Crispy tortilla chips served with a side of creamy cheese sauce.
  $4.95
Wing Sauce Bottles
If you love our wing sauces, you can purchase a 12 oz. bottle! In order of heat! (Mildest to Hottest!)
- Winking Lizard BBQ Sauce
  A sweet hickory flavored tomato base sauce with a hint of heat
  $4.00
- Winking Lizard Honey Mustard
  Mustard and Honey mixed with garlic, brown sugar and a hint of hot sauce make up a butter sauce
  $5.50
- Winking Lizard Teriyaki
  A sweet soy sauce with garlic, ginger, pineapple & orange juice
  $5.50
- Winking Lizard Bourbon Barrel
  A sweet molasses sauce with notes of caramel and sriracha. Sticky but worth the mess.
  $6.00
- Winking Lizard Honey Garlic
  Classic taste of honey garlic sauce kicked up a notch with spicy cayenne pepper
  $6.00
- Winking Lizard Mild
  Classic buffalo-style wing sauce
  $5.50
- Winking Lizard Goldfinger
  A sweet & tangy sauce made from a blend of mustard, cayenne peppers & apple cider vinegar
  $6.00
- Winking Lizard Garlic
  A spicy hot sauce with a buttery garlic flavor
  $5.50
- Winking Lizard Spicy Sesame
  A blend of oriental hot chili sauce , honey, soy, sauce, rice vinegar, garlic, & toasted sesame seeds
  $6.00
- Winking Lizard Hot
  An aged cayenne pepper sauce with vinegar, salt & garlic
  $5.50
- Winking Lizard Caribbean
  Spicy hot sauce with cloves, cinnamon, nutmeg, thyme, garlic & honey
  $6.00
- Winking Lizard Cajun
  Hot Sauce with molasses, vinegar, sugar & Parmesan cheese
  $6.00
- Winking Lizard Spicy BBQ
  Our BBQ Sauce with Cajun Seasoning, cayenne pepper & African Bird Seed
  $5.50
- Winking Lizard Thai
  An oriental hot chili sauce mixed with honey & garlic
  $6.00
- Winking Lizard Spicy Garlic
  Garlic wing sauce with our 911 sauce
  $5.50
- Winking Lizard 911
  We take our hot sauce and mix it with the hottest spices we can find
  $5.50