Search
Scoops
- Small Ice CreamA small size scoop of your choice of one flavor of homemade ice cream!$5.95
- Regular Ice CreamA regular size scoop of your choice of one or two flavors of homemade ice cream$6.45
- Large Ice CreamA large size scoop of your choice of one or two flavors of homemade ice cream!$6.95
- FlightsNot sure what flavor to order? Flights are the perfect way to have it all! Flights come with your choice of 3 or 4 small scoops of different ice cream flavors, and are finished with waffle cone pieces!3 Scoop Flight$5.954 Scoop Flight$6.75
- To-Go ToppingsA single serving of your favorite candy or ice cream sauce toppings!Rainbow Sprinkles$0.50Chocolate Sprinkles$0.50Brownie Bits$0.75Cookie Dough Topping$0.75Gummy Bears$0.75Heath Bits$0.75Oreo Topping$0.75Mini Chocolate Chips$0.75Mini M&M's$0.75Reese's Pieces$0.75Walnuts$0.75Whipped Cream$0.75Caramel Sauce$0.75Hot Fudge Sauce$0.75Marshmallow Sauce$0.75Peanut Butter Sauce$0.75Sugar Cone$0.00Homemade Waffle Cone$1.001/2 Pint of Hot Fudge$5.001/2 Pint of Caramel Sauce$5.00
- Mini Ice CreamA mini size scoop of your choice of one flavor of homemade ice cream!$5.15
Sundaes, Frappes & Sandwiches
- 2 or 3 Scoop Ice Cream SundaeThe classic and beloved ice cream sundae, featuring 2 or 3 scoops of ice cream topped with your choice of sauce, whipped cream and a cherry!Two Scoop Sundae$6.75Three Scoop Sundae$7.75
- FrappeCreamy and delicious hand spun ice cream frappes made with milk and your choice of ice cream!For our customers with allergies, please be advised that our frappes are made on shared equipment and are not recommended to customers with severe allergies. *Frappes can be made with almond milk by request*$7.75
- S’mores SundaeChocolate ice cream topped with hot fudge, marshmallow sauce, graham cracker crumbles, whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles!PB S'mores sundae: replace hot fudge with peanut butter sauce. Caramel S'mores sundae: replace hot fudge for caramel sauce$8.50
- Grand Slam SundaeGreen Monster ice cream with hot fudge, crushed Oreos, mini chocolate chips, whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles.$8.50
- Caramel Chocolate Craze SundaeSalted caramel and chocolate caramel brownie ice cream topped with caramel sauce. hot fudge, brownie bits, whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles!This specialty sundae will be available during the month of April.$8.50
- Turtle SundaeSalted Caramel ice cream topped with caramel sauce, hot fudge, whipped cream and roasted pecans!This specialty sundae will be available during the month of April only.$8.50
- Peanut Butter Dream SundaeChocolate peanut butter ice cream topped with Hot Fudge & PB sauces, Reese’s Pieces, and whipped cream.$8.50
- Ice Cream Cookie SandwichOur out-of-this-world delicious cookie sandwiches feature one scoop of your favorite ice cream sandwiched between two homemade cookies made by local bakery Bliss Confection Co.!Small Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich$5.75Regular Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich$7.00Gluten Free Ginger Molasses Cookie Sandwich$7.50Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookie$7.50
Pints, Quarts, and Sundae Kits
- To-Go ToppingsA single serving of your favorite candy or ice cream sauce toppings!Rainbow Sprinkles$0.50Chocolate Sprinkles$0.50Brownie Bits$0.75Cookie Dough Topping$0.75Gummy Bears$0.75Heath Bits$0.75Oreo Topping$0.75Mini Chocolate Chips$0.75Mini M&M's$0.75Reese's Pieces$0.75Walnuts$0.75Whipped Cream$0.75Caramel Sauce$0.75Hot Fudge Sauce$0.75Marshmallow Sauce$0.75Peanut Butter Sauce$0.75Sugar Cone$0.00Homemade Waffle Cone$1.001/2 Pint of Hot Fudge$5.001/2 Pint of Caramel Sauce$5.00
- Brownie Sundae KitTreat yourself with a take-home brownie sundae kit! Our kits provide all the essentials to make a delicious treat. The kits pair perfectly with a birthday celebration, movie night, or any time you are looking to add some extra joy to your day. Inside your kit, you will find... Small Brownie Sundae Kit: Two Brownies or Blondies One Pint of Hand-Packed Ice Cream Two 4 oz. Jars of Hot Fudge and Caramel Sauce Large Sundae Kit: Four Brownies or Blondies One Quart of Hand-Packed Ice Cream Two 1/2 Pint Jars of Hot Fudge & Caramel Sauce$19.00
- Large Sundae KitAll of the essentials for a fun sundae party! Large Sundae Packages feature 2 quarts of ice cream, your choice of 2 candy toppings, sprinkles, a pint of hot fudge or caramel sauce and 8 sugar cones! Large Sundae Kits feed 6-8 people$40.00
- Small Sundae KitA party in a bag! Small sundae kits feature 2 pints of ice cream, your choice of 2 candy toppings, sprinkles, a 1/2 pint of hot fudge or caramel sauce and 4 sugar cones! Small Sundae Kits feed 4-6 people.$25.00
- Hand Packed Pints & QuartsTake home a hand packed 32 ounce quart 16 ounce pint or two of your favorite ice cream!Quart$12.25Pint$8.50
Ice Cream Pies
- Easter PiesMake this Easter egg-celent by celebrating with a West Side Creamery pie! We are offering two specialty pies for Easter (descriptions below) in addition to our classic pies. Please plan to pick up your pie in-store on the pickup date that you select!Chocolate Easter Bunny: Chocolate Caramel Brownie ice cream hand-packed into a fudge lined chocolate cookie crust that is topped with Easter Sprinkles and Cadbury mini eggs!Hoppy Easter: Chocolate Chip ice cream hand-packed into a fudge lined chocolate cookie crust that is topped with a chocolate drizzle, pastel m&ms and whipped cream dollops! This pie can be made Gluten Free upon request.Thursday, April 17th$30.00Friday, April 18th$30.00Saturday, April 19th$30.00Sunday, April 20th$30.00
- Custom Easter PieCelebrate Easter with a custom pie from West Side Creamery! Please plan to pick up your pie in-store on the pickup date that you select.Thursday, April 17th$30.00Friday, April 18th$30.00Saturday, April 19th$30.00Sunday, April 20th$30.00
Menu Photos
Menu Photos
Loading...
