High Street Bagels Sayville Menu

217 N Main St, Sayville, NY 11782
  • Quick Picks

    • Chopped Cheese Hero

      Chopped Cheese NY style on a garlic hero served with lettuce tomato and onions comes with mayo dressing
      $13.99
    • 4 PC Chicken Tenders

      Freshly fried and battered Chicken tenders.
      $7.59
    • 4 PC Chicken Tenders With French Fries

      Chicken tenders Served with crsipy French Fries.
      $10.50
    • Fruit Cup

      Fresh mixed fruit served in a cup- a perfect burst of natural flavors
      $5.49
    • Vanilla Yogurt Parfait

      Greek vanilla yogurt with Fesh bluberries and Crisp granola.
      $6.49
    • 1/2 Lb Rice Pudding

      Rice cooked with milk and sugar, typically topped with cinnamon and whipped cream.
      $3.00
  • Muffins ,Bakery and cookies

    • Muffin

      Bursting with blueberries, this muffin offers a moist and tender crumb with a golden-brown top.
      $3.65
    • Danish

      Choose from cheese, stawberry or bluberry
      $3.50
    • Apple Turnover Or Strawberry Turnover

      Puff pastery baked with apple or stawberry filling.\nPlease choose
      $3.50
    • Mini Black And White Cookie Box

      A box of mini cake-like cookies, each half coated with vanilla and chocolate icing, inspired by a New York classic.
      $6.50
    • Rainbow Cookie Box

      A delightful assortment of cookies, typically featuring layers of almond-flavored sponge cake, apricot jam, and a chocolate coating, inspired by traditional Italian rainbow cookies.
      $6.50
    • Mini Linzer Tart Cookie Box

      A selection of mini Linzer tart cookies, typically featuring a buttery almond dough filled with raspberry jam.
      $6.50
    • Fancy Cookies 16oz

      A selection of homemade cookies, typically includes chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, and sugar cookies.
      $11.99
    • Chocolate Chip Cookies 12oz

      Hand-made chocolate chip cookies, containing dairy, eggs, soy, and wheat.
      $11.99
    • Chocolate Buns Box

      Soft, fluffy buns made with rich chocolate, typically presented in a convenient box.
      $11.99
    • Rugalech 12oz Box

      Choose from chocolate or cinnamon
      $11.99
  • Cream cheese and salads sold by pound

    • 1/2 Plain Cream Cheese

      1/2 lb of plain cream cheese, typically includes a smooth and spreadable texture. Prepared for versatile use.
      $6.50
    • 1 Lb Plain Cream Cheese

      One pound of our house-made plain cream cheese, prepared for spreading or use in various dishes.
      $12.99
    • 1/2 Lb Flavored Cream Cheese

      Half-pound of cream cheese in your choice of flavors: vanilla walnut raisin, scallion, vegetable, olive, strawberry, cinnamon raisin, or jalapeño.
      $7.75
    • 1 Lb Flavored Cream Cheese

      1 lb cream cheese, available in vanilla walnut raisin, scallion, vegetable, olive, strawberry, cinnamon raisin, jalapeño.
      $15.50
    • 1/2 Lb Butter

      1/2 lb of butter, typically used as a spread for various breads and bagels.
      $6.50
    • 1/2 Lb Tuna Salad

      Tuna salad, typically includes a blend of tuna, mayonnaise, celery, and red onion, seasoned to taste.
      $7.75
    • 1/2 Lb Chicken Salad

      can choose from chicken apple cranberry and regular chicken salad
      $7.75
    • 1/2 Lb Egg Salad

      Egg salad, typically includes chopped boiled eggs mixed with mayonnaise and a blend of seasonings.
      $6.99
    • 1/2 Egg White Spinach Salad

      Egg whites and fresh spinach combined, typically dressed lightly to complement the salad's natural flavors.
      $7.49
    • 1/2 Lb Coleslaw

      Shredded cabbage and carrots, typically mixed with a creamy dressing.
      $5.50
    • 1/2 Lb Macaroni Salad

      Elbow macaroni combined with diced celery, onion, and a creamy mayonnaise dressing.
      $5.50
    • 1/2 Lb Potato Salad

      Potato salad typically includes boiled potatoes, mayonnaise, and often features ingredients like onions, eggs, and celery, seasoned to taste.
      $5.50
  • Beverages

    • Small Hot Coffee

      Hot coffee, freshly brewed with a smooth finish, typically served black. Milk or sugar available upon request.
      $2.19
    • Medium Hot Coffee

      Freshly brewed drip coffee, typically includes options for cream and sugar upon request.
      $3.00
    • Large Coffee

      A generous serving of our rich, aromatic brewed coffee.
      $3.25
    • Snapple 16 Oz

      flavors lemon, peach, rashberry tea
      $2.79
    • 20 Oz Soda

      coke, diet coke, pepsi, diet pepsi, ginger ale
      $2.79
    • Tropicana 12 Oz Juice

      some pulp, no pulp
      $3.25
    • Iced Coffee Small

      Iced coffee, served cold, often includes a blend of brewed coffee and ice, with options for milk or sweeteners upon request.
      $2.99
    • Medium Ice Coffee

      Brewed coffee served over ice, typically includes options for milk and sugar upon request.
      $3.50
    • Large Ice Coffee

      Cold brewed coffee served over ice, typically includes options for cream and/or sugar upon request.
      $4.39
    • Poland Spring Water Small

      A small bottle of Poland Spring water, sourced from natural springs for a refreshing and pure hydration experience.
      $1.65
    • Poland Spring Water 1 Liter

      A 1-liter bottle of Poland Spring, offering natural spring water sourced from Poland Spring sources.
      $3.59
    • Monster Energy Drink

      Monster energy beverage with a boost to keep you energized throughout the day.
      $3.79
    • Redbull Energy Drink 8oz

      An 8-ounce can of Red Bull Energy Drink, designed to increase alertness and improve concentration with its unique blend of ingredients.
      $3.79
    • Gatorade

      fruit punch,lemon lime, orange
      $2.99
  • Fresh Squezed Orange Juice

    • Small Size

      Freshly squeezed orange juice, typically made to order, offering a refreshing and natural taste.
      $4.99
    • Medium

      Freshly squeezed orange juice, made from ripe oranges for a natural and refreshing taste.
      $5.99
    • Large

      Freshly squeezed orange juice, prepared upon order for peak freshness.
      $6.99
  • Bagels

    • One Bagel

      Choose the type of bagel
      $1.65
    • Bagel With Butter

      Choice of bagel spread with butter. Options include plain, whole wheat, everything, cinnamon raisin, and more. From sesame to multigrain and sunflower.
      $2.95
    • Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese

      Bagel spread with plain cream cheese, choice of bagel includes plain, various seed-topped, whole wheat, flavored, and more.
      $3.25
    • Bagel With Flavored Cream Cheese

      Select from a variety of bagels including plain, whole wheat, seed-topped, and more. Paired with cream cheeses like vanilla walnut raisin, scallion, or jalapeño.
      $4.29
    • Dozen Bagels

      Selection of 12 bagels, options include plain, various seeds, whole wheat, egg varieties, cinnamon raisin, cheddar, onion, rainbow, and more. Customize your dozen from over 20 choices.
      $19.00
  • Egg Sandwiches

    • Eggs

      Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have a certain medical conditions.
      $4.50
    • Eggs & Cheese

      Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have a certain medical conditions.
      $4.99
    • Eggs & Meat

      Bacon, ham, turkey or sausage. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have a certain medical conditions.
      $6.39
    • Eggs, Cheese & Meat

      Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have a certain medical conditions.
      $6.79
  • Breakfast Heroes

    • Batman

      2 eggs, bacon, ham & sausage. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have a certain medical conditions.
      $8.99
    • Robin

      3 eggs, bacon, sausage & cheese. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have a certain medical conditions.
      $8.99
    • The Hungry Man

      3 eggs, bacon, sausage, ham & cheese. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have a certain medical conditions.
      $9.99
  • Breakfast Burritos

    • Classic Burrito

      Eggs, onions, ham & American cheese. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have a certain medical conditions.
      $8.79
    • Spicy Burrito

      Eggs, home fries, bacon, Swiss, jalapeno peppers. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have a certain medical conditions.
      $8.79
    • Veggie Burrito

      Eggs, mushrooms, grilled onions & peppers. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have a certain medical conditions.
      $8.79
    • Healthy Burrito

      Eggs whites, spinach, Swiss cheese & onions. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have a certain medical conditions.
      $8.79
    • #5- No Cheese Burrito

      Eggs, peppers, ham, bacon & onions. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have a certain medical conditions.
      $8.79
  • Omelets

    • American

      Onions, bacon & American cheese.
      $7.99
    • Calorie Counter

      Egg whites, oven gold turkey & Swiss.
      $7.99
    • Wester

      Wester-Ham, peppers, onions & American.
      $7.99
    • Greek

      Egg whites, spinach, feta & onions.
      $7.99
    • Mexican Veggie

      Bacon, Swiss, tomato, jalapeno peppers.
      $7.99
  • Signature Sandwiches

    • The Commuter

      Maple honey turkey, bacon, melted Vermont cheddar cheese & honey mustard on a hero.
      $11.99
    • The Beast

      Hot roost beef, melted mozzarella on a roll.
      $11.99
    • The Station

      Roast beef, jalapeno pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions & horseradish sauce on a hero.
      $11.99
    • Sayville Mom's

      Maple honey turkey, bacon, molted Swiss cheese & honey mustard on a roll.
      $11.49
    • All Aboard

      Hot roast beef, melted provolone & Russian dressing on a hero.
      $11.99
    • Vegetarian

      Roasted eggplant, tomato, mozzarella, & jalapeno on a roll.
      $9.99
    • The Runaway

      Roast beef, bacon, mated cheddar, BBQ sauce on a hero.
      $11.99
    • Gone Fishing

      Bologna & American with mayo or mustard on roll.
      $9.99
    • The Boone

      Breaded chicken cutlet, American cheese, bacon with Russian dressing on a roll.
      $11.99
    • South Shore

      Oven gold turkey, pepperoni, American, lettuce, tomato, served on a bagel.
      $11.99
    • The Works

      Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone, lettuce & tomato on a hero.
      $11.99
    • Cherry Avenue Elementary

      Deluxe ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce & mayo on o roll.
      $11.99
    • The Rail

      Grilled pastrami, melted Swiss cheese, coleslaw & Russian dressing on a roll.
      $11.99
    • Lincoln Avenue Elementary

      Oven gold turkey, coleslaw, Russian dressing on a roll.
      $11.99
    • The Traveler

      Maple honey turkey, bacon, mozzarella, coleslaw & Russian dressing on a roll.
      $11.99
    • Sunrise Drive Elementary

      Oven gold turkey, lettuce, tomato, mayo, oil a vinegar on a roll.
      $11.99
  • Signature Burgers

    • Classic Hamburger ½ Pounder

      Half-pound beef patty on a bun, typically includes lettuce, tomato, onions, and mayonnaise.
      $7.99
    • Deluxe

      Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, fries, or rings.
      $9.75
    • Classic Cheese Burger ½ Pounder

      Half-pound beef patty with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onions, typically served on a bun.
      $8.99
    • Mushroom Swiss Burger ½ Pounder

      Sauteed mushroom, melted Swiss.
      $9.99
    • Bacon Blue Cheese Burger ½ Pounder

      Bacon, blue cheese.
      $10.99
    • Deutschandler ½ Pounder

      Bacon, pickles, mustard, muenster cheese.
      $10.99
  • Classic Sandwiches

    • Classic Reuben

      Corned beef, Swiss, 1000 island, grilled marbled rye.
      $11.99
    • The Carnegie

      Hot pastrami, mustard, marbled rye.
      $11.99
    • American Hero

      Roast beef, ham, turkey, cheese, lettuce, tomato, hero.
      $11.99
    • Italian Hero

      Ham, genoa salami, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & vinegar.
      $11.99
    • Philly Cheese Steak

      Shaved beef grilled with onions & peppers, smothered with cheese on hero.
      $11.99
    • Pub Chicken Sandwich

      Fried chicken, lettuce, tomato, bacon, cheddar, honey mustard, BBQ sauce, pretzel bun.
      $11.99
    • BBQ Chicken Sandwich

      Grilled chicken, bacon, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, yellow BBQ sauce, brioche roll.
      $11.99
    • Chicken Quesadilla

      Grilled chicken, peppers, onion, jack & cheddar cheese, grilled tortilla.
      $11.99
    • Southern Italian Wrap

      Ham, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onions, oil, vinegar, mustard.
      $11.99
    • Classic BLT

      Crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato toast.
      $7.99
    • Signature Chicken Cutlet Hero

      Chicken cutlets, BBQ sauce, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, hero.
      $11.99
    • Classic Gyro

      Beef / lamb broiled, tzatziki sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, pita.
      $11.99
    • Chicken Souvlaki

      Grilled chicken marinated tzatziki sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, pita.
      $11.99
    • Turkey Club

      Oven gold turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, triple stacked on toast.
      $11.99
    • Classic Grilled Cheese

      Grilled cheese, choice of coleslaw, macaroni, or potato salad on the side.
      $4.99
  • Boars Head Cold Cut Sandwiches

    • Oven Gold Turkey

      Oven gold turkey typically includes sliced turkey, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise, often complemented by a selection of cheese.
      $8.49
    • Deluxe Ham

      Deluxe ham, typically served on bread, accompanied by select, complementary condiments to enhance the flavor.
      $8.49
    • Roast Beef

      Roast beef typically served with lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on bread. Provolone cheese is a common addition.
      $8.99
    • Bologna

      Bologna sandwich typically includes sliced bologna and mayonnaise, served on white bread.
      $7.99
    • Genoa Salami

      Genoa salami paired with lettuce, tomato, and onion, typically served on bread.
      $7.99
    • Pastrami

      Pastrami typically served on rye bread, often accompanied by mustard and sometimes includes pickles.
      $8.99
    • American Cheese

      Grilled American cheese melted between slices of bread.
      $6.49
    • Swiss Cheese, Provolone Cheese, Muenster Cheese

      Layers of Swiss, provolone, and Muenster cheese melted between grilled bread.
      $6.49
    • Cheddar Cheese

      Grilled cheddar cheese sandwich, typically includes bread.
      $6.99
  • Salad Sandwiches

    • Tuna Salad

      Made on a bagel, roll, wrap or sliced bread and served with side salad.
      $8.25
    • Chicken Salad

      Made on a bagel, roll, wrap or sliced bread and served with side salad.
      $8.99
    • Fresh Egg Salad

      Creamy egg salad with fresh greens, served on a sesame-seed bagel.
      $7.25
    • Chicken Apple Cranberry Salad

      Diced chicken mixed with apple slices, dried cranberries, and a light dressing, typically served between slices of bread.
      $8.99
    • Vegetable Tuna Salad

      Tuna salad combined with a medley of fresh vegetables, typically dressed in mayonnaise, served as a refreshing salad sandwich option.
      $8.25
    • Egg White Spinach Salad

      Egg whites and spinach, lightly dressed with mayonnaise and a hint of lemon juice, typically served on a bed of greens.
      $7.25
  • Fresh Salads

    • House Salad

      Fresh romaine lettuce, cucumbers, green peppers, tomatoes & carrots.
      $8.99
    • Greek Salad

      Fresh romaine lettuce, feta cheese, black olives, Bermuda onion, red & green peppers, tomatoes & cucumber.
      $11.99
    • Chef Salad

      Turkey, ham, provolone, mixed greens, hard boiled eggs, tomatoes.
      $12.99
    • Signature Salad With Grilled Chicken

      Grilled chicken, fresh romaine, parmesan, croutons.
      $13.99
  • Paninis And Wraps

    • Chicken Cordon Bleu

      Grilled chicken, ham, Swiss.
      $10.25
    • Buffalo Chicken

      Buffalo chicken, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, ranch.
      $10.25
  • Sides

    • Bacon

      Crispy thick-cut, smoked to perfection.
      $3.99
    • Sausage

      Savory, perfectly seasoned sausage links, a classic breakfast favorite.
      $3.99
    • Ham

      Thinly sliced ham, typically served as a complement to a variety of dishes.
      $3.99
    • Fries

      Golden, crispy fries seasoned lightly, offering a satisfying crunch with every bite.
      $4.99
    • Waffle Fries

      Crispy golden fries with a unique waffle-cut shape, served hot and delicious.
      $4.99
    • Grilled Chicken

      Juicy, perfectly grilled chicken with a hint of herbs and spices.
      $6.99
    • Chicken Cutlet

      Breaded chicken cutlet, typically accompanied by lettuce, tomatoes, and mayo, served on a long roll.
      $6.99
    • Pickle

      Crisp pickled cucumbers, often accompanied by a blend of spices for a tangy finish.
      $1.25
    • Cheese Fries

      Golden fries topped with melted cheese, perfect for snacking or sharing.
      $6.99
    • Home Fries

      Crispy diced potatoes mixed with sautéed green bell peppers and onions.
      $4.50
  • Vegetarian/ Vegan Suggestions

    • The Greek Inspiration

      Red roasted peppers, cucumber, pepperoni, kalamata olives, radish, tomatoes, red onions, feta cheese with tzatziki sauce (optional).
      $11.95
    • The Cardoon Bomber

      Red roasted peppers, spinach, fresh mozzarella cheese, salt, pepper & basil pesto spread.
      $11.95
    • The Hummus Hummer

      Hummus, cucumber, tomato, red onion, Swiss cheese & cheddar cheese.
      $11.95
    • The Vegan Frenchie

      Sauteed mushrooms, caramelized onions, sauteed spinach with tofu spread.
      $11.95
    • The Sweet Sensational

      Avocado, apple slices, spinach, honey mustard, salt & pepper.
      $11.95
  • Fruit Smoothies

    • Strawberry Smoothie

      A refreshing blend of ripe strawberries, and creamy yogurt
      $5.99
    • Pineapple Paradise Smoothie

      A refreshing blend of ripe pineapples with hints of tropical fruits, typically mixed with a base of coconut milk or yogurt.
      $5.99
    • 4 Berry Smoothie

      Strawberry, blueberry, raspberry, and blackberry blended with a hint of honey.
      $5.99
    • Strawberry Banana Smoothie

      Perfect for a healthy boost!
      $5.99
    • Butternut Squash Mango Smoothie

      Butternut squash and mango blended together, typically includes a hint of honey for sweetness.
      $5.99
    • Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice

      Freshly squeezed orange juice available in small (12 oz.), medium (16 oz.), or large (24 oz.).
      $4.99

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

SAYVILLE BAIT & TACKLE
SAYVILLE BAIT & TACKLE
4.5
(171 Reviews)
Restaurant
Friendly's
Friendly's
4.3
(534 Reviews)
American, Diner, Family
TOA Asian Fusion (Sayville)
TOA Asian Fusion (Sayville)
4.5
(341 Reviews)
Asian fusion, Chinese, Japanese
Ramen Ramen
Ramen Ramen
4.2
(92 Reviews)
Ramen, Asian, Hawaiian
Sal's Pizzeria and Catering
Sal's Pizzeria and Catering
4.5
(342 Reviews)
Pizza, European, Italian
Local Burger - Sayville - Restaurant and Bar
Local Burger - Sayville - Restaurant and Bar
4.2
(39 Reviews)
Restaurant, Bar, Chicken wings
Umberto's of Sayville
Umberto's of Sayville
4.5
(398 Reviews)
Pizza, Italian, Restaurant
Cenote Mexican
Cenote Mexican
4.4
(145 Reviews)
Mexican, Bar, Cocktail bar
Joelle - Barroom + Cafe
Joelle - Barroom + Cafe
4.5
(445 Reviews)
Eclectic, Bar, Restaurant
Sayville Athletic Club
Sayville Athletic Club
4.5
(85 Reviews)
Sports bar

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms