Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Water St. Cafe Menu

$$$Diner, Breakfast, Restaurant
467 S Exchange St, Geneva, NY 14456
Order Online

  • Allergy Notification

    • I Have A Food Allergy

      Please add your allergy to the special Instructions
      $0.00

  • Water St. Breakfast Favorites

    • Garbage Plate

      Scrambled Eggs, Hash, Homefries & Toast Topped with Sausage Gravy (50 Cent Container Charge Included in price with All To-Gos)
      $12.30

    • Statesman Platter

      2 Eggs, 2 Slices of French Toast, 2 Strips of Bacon & Homefries. (50 Cent Container Charge Included in price with All To-Gos)
      $10.65

    • Heron Platter

      1 Egg, 1 piece of French Toast, 1 Strip of Bacon, 1/2 order of Homefries
      $7.90

    • Corn Beef Hash, Eggs &Toast

      Corn Beef Hash, 2 Eggs & Toast
      $9.85

    • Frittata

      Eggs mixed with Homefries, Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Carrots, Green Beans, Cauliflower, Pepperoni, Ham, Italian & Breakfast Sausage, with Toast
      $12.05

    • 1/2 Frittata

      Half Order of: Eggs mixed with Homefries, Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Carrots, Green Beans, Cauliflower, Pepperoni, Ham, Italian & Breakfast Sausage, with Toast
      $9.55

    • Sausage Biscuits & Gravy

      Fresh Baked Biscuits, covered in Homemade Sausage Gravy,
      $8.45

    • 1/2 Order Sausage Biscuits & Gravy

      1 Fresh Baked Biscuit, Covered in Sausage Gravy
      $6.80

    • Kitchen Sink Oatmeal

      Oatmeal made from scratch, with Blueberries, Strawberries, Bananas, Walnuts, and Raisins. Its every topping we have!
      $10.95

    • Steak & Eggs

      Steak, 2 Eggs, Home fries & Toast. (50 Cent Container Fee Included in pricing for all To-Gos)
      $17.55

  • Early Bird Specials

    • #1

      2 Eggs, Homefries, & Toast
      $6.55

    • #2

      2 Eggs, Homefries, (Ham, Bacon or Sausage) & Toast
      $10.05

    • #3

      Homestyle: Scrambled Eggs mixed with Homefries & Toast
      $9.10

    • #4

      2 Eggs, Choice of Ham, Bacon or Sausage Patties/Links & Toast
      $9.25

    • 1 Egg & Toast

      1 egg, choice of preparation: scrambled, sunny side up, over easy/medium/hard, poached, or egg whites. Toast options include wheat, white, biscuits, rye, Italian, English muffin, raisin, sourdough.
      $3.50

    • 2 Egg & Toast

      Two eggs, choice of style. Served with toast or biscuit options: wheat, white, rye, Italian, English muffin, fresh raisin, or sourdough.
      $4.00

  • Weekly Breakfast Specials

    • Pumpkin Pancakes

      Fresh made Pumpkin Pancakes, served with Homemade Maple Butter.
      $6.50

    • French Toast Breakfast Sandwich

      Two pieces of French Toast, Egg, Cheese and choice of Meat: Bacon or Sausage. Served with Homefries.
      $12.50

    • Loaded Breakfast Fries

      Battered Fries, Topped with 2 eggs, Bacon and Cheddar Cheese. Add more Meats or Veggies in the Modifications. If you want double Bacon, just choose Bacon under "Basic Meat Choices"
      $13.70

    • The Big Garry

      In Memory of Garry H. 3 Over Easy Eggs, 2 Sausage Patties, Homefries, and 3 piece of Italian Toast. No Substitutions.
      $13.65

    • French Toast Roll Ups

      3 Sausage links, wrapped in 3 pieces of French Toast, with Homefries on the side.
      $12.85

    • Buffalo Chicken Omelette

      Omelette stuffed with Shredded Buffalo Chicken and Blue Cheese crumbles. With Homefries & Toast
      $12.05

    • Country Benedict

      Open faced Biscuit Sandwich, 2 Eggs, 2 Sausage Patties, and American Cheese, with Homefries, All Smothered in Sausage Gravy.
      $13.25

  • Breakfast Sandwiches

    • Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich

      1 Egg Included
      $2.75

  • Specialty Omelettes

    • Cheese Omelette

      (American, Cheddar, Swiss or Provolone)
      $7.90

    • Meat Lovers

      Ham, Bacon, Sausage & Cheese
      $13.70

    • Northern

      Spinach, Roasted Red Peppers & Feta Cheese
      $12.00

    • Western

      Peppers, Onions, Ham & Cheese
      $11.75

    • Southwestern

      Hot Peppers, Sausage, Avocado & Cheddar Cheese
      $12.65

    • Denver

      Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Ham & Cheese
      $12.05

    • Veggie

      Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Spinach, Cheese
      $12.05

    • Sloppy Omelette

      Scrambled Eggs, mixed with 1 meat choice and Cheese Choice. comes with toast.
      $10.95

    • Water Street Omelette

      Roasted Red Peppers & Provolone Cheese
      $10.40

    • Farmers

      Sausage, Cheese, Homefries, Topped with Sausage Gravy
      $12.85

    • Hash Lovers

      Corn Beef Hash & Cheese
      $11.75

    • Angus Philly Steak Omelette

      Angus Philly Steak, Peppers, Onions and Provolone Cheese. Comes with Toast.
      $13.70

  • Omelette Bar Creations

    • 2 Egg Omelette

      Comes with Toasts Add a side of Homefries for $1.50 Make with Egg Whites for $1.00
      $4.90

    • 3 Egg Omelette

      Comes with Toasts Add a side of Homefries for $3.25 Make with Egg Whites for $2.27
      $5.45

  • Breakfast Burritos

    • Angus Philly Steak Burrito

      Angus Philly Steak, Peppers, Onions, and Provolone Cheese.
      $13.70

    • Denver Burrito

      Scrambled eggs, Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Ham & Cheese.
      $11.78

    • Northern Burrito

      Scrambled Eggs, Spinach, Roasted Red, Peppers & Feta Cheese.
      $11.78

    • Meat Lover's Burrito

      BIGGER & BETTER, Scrambled Eggs, Sausage, Ham, Bacon & Cheese.
      $17.60

    • Hash Lovers Burrito

      Scrambled Eggs, Corn Beef Hash, and Cheese.
      $11.50

    • South Western Burrito

      Scrambled Eggs, Hot Peppers, Sausage, Avocado & Cheddar Cheese.
      $11.78

    • Farmer's Burrito

      Scrambled Eggs, Cheese, Sausage, and Homefries all stuffed into a Burrito, and Smothered in Sausage Gravy
      $12.60

    • Veggie Lover Burrito

      Scrambled Eggs, Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Spinach & Cheese.
      $11.50

    • Western Burrito

      Scrambled eggs, Peppers, Onions and Ham
      $11.50

    • Build Your Own Burrito

      Build Your Own Breakfast Burrito.
      $5.50

  • Pancakes

    • Single Pancake

      Single pancake with customizable butter placement and syrup options including regular, extra, or real maple syrup in varying quantities.
      $4.75

    • Short Stack Of Pancakes

      Short stack of pancakes, option for butter placement, choice of syrup ranging from none to extra real maple.
      $6.75

    • Full Stack Of Pancakes

      Full stack of pancakes with optional butter placement. Choose from no syrup to extra real maple syrup (2 or 3 oz options).
      $10.25

  • French Toast

    • Single French Toast

      Single French Toast served with optional butter (no butter, on top, or side) and syrup choices ranging from none, regular, extra regular, to real maple (2 oz or extra 3 oz).
      $2.75

    • Short Stack French Toast

      Short Stack (2) French Toast
      $5.73

    • Full Stack French Toast

      Full Stack (3) French Toast
      $6.25

  • Specialty French Toast

    • Specialty FT Full Stack

      3 Slices
      $9.58

    • Specialty FT Single

      1 Slice
      $4.35

    • Specialty FT Short Stack

      2 Slices
      $7.93

  • Specialty Pancakes

    • Single Specialty Pancake

      $6.45

    • Full Stack Specialty Pancakes

      Full Stack (3) Specialty Pancakes
      $12.50

    • Short Stack Specialty Pancakes

      Short Stack (2) Specialty Pancakes
      $8.80

  • A La Carte Breakfast

    • Homefries

      Side plate of Homefries
      $3.00

    • Oatmeal Cup

      Cup of fresh made Oatmeal, to order.
      $3.50

    • Oatmeal Bowl

      Bowl of fresh made Oatmeal, to order.
      $3.75

    • Avocado Add To Toast

      Avocado spread on choice of toast: wheat, white, biscuits, rye, Italian, English muffin, raisin, sourdough.
      $3.80

    • Muffins

      Water St. Baked in House Muffins
      $4.08

    • Melon

      Sliced Cantaloupe
      $2.75

    • Whole Banana

      A single, ripe banana, offering a naturally sweet and portable snack option.
      $1.25

    • Side Of Avocado

      Side of sliced Avocado
      $3.30

    • White/Wheat Toast

      Side of Toast, Buttered
      $1.30

    • English Muffin

      English Muffin, buttered
      $3.25

    • Rye Toast

      Buttered
      $3.25

    • Italian Toast

      Buttered
      $3.25

    • Raisin Toast

      Fresh Home Baked Raisin Bread made in House Buttered
      $3.80

    • Bagel

      Toasted Bagel with butter
      $3.25

    • Cream Cheese

      Can be added to any menu item
      $1.00

    • Sour Cream

      Can be added to any menu item
      $1.00

    • Salsa

      Can be added to any menu item
      $1.00

    • Add An Egg

      Egg cooked to preference: scrambled, sunny side up, over easy/medium/hard, poached, or just whites.
      $1.65

  • Breakfast Meat Choices

    • Bacon

      Crispy thick-cut, smoked to perfection.
      $5.75

    • Ham Steak

      A thick slice of ham steak, often accompanied by eggs and toast, reflecting a traditional breakfast choice.
      $5.75

    • Sausage Links

      Succulent linked sausages, perfectly seasoned for a classic breakfast delight.
      $5.75

    • Sausage Patties

      Savory grilled meat patties, a must-try for meat lovers seeking a delicious breakfast twist.
      $5.75

    • Fresh Pork Sausage

      Made Fresh in house, with Water St. Seasoning recipe.
      $6.25

    • Fresh Turkey Sausage

      Ground turkey sausage, typically includes a blend of seasonings, seared to perfection.
      $6.25

    • Turkey Bacon

      Crispy Turkey Bacon Strips - Perfectly Sizzled for a Smoky Flavor
      $6.25

    • Corn Beef Hash

      Side of our Corn Beef Hash
      $6.25

    • Sausage Gravy

      A creamy gravy typically including ground sausage, seasoned and simmered to a thick consistency.
      $4.35

  • Signature Burgers

    • Classic Burger

      with Fries
      $8.20

    • J's Favorite Burger

      6oz Burger Patty, DOUBLE Bacon, DOUBLE American Cheese, zesty pickles, Made Js Way with Mayo & Ketchup, Lettuce & Onion. (NO TOMATOS)
      $16.45

    • Swiss Staple Burger

      6oz Patty with Swiss Cheese, Peppers, Onions, and Mushrooms.
      $13.40

    • Rodeo Burger

      Bacon, Onion Rings, American Cheese, BBQ Sauce, Comes with Fries
      $12.60

    • Cajun Burger

      Cajun Seasoned Beef, Bacon & Crumbly Blue Cheese. Comes with Fries
      $12.60

    • Whiskey Burger

      Bacon, Onion, American Cheese & Whiskey Sauce, Comes with Fries
      $12.60

    • Southwest Burger

      Avocado, Cheddar, Hot Peppers & Siracha Mayo. Comes with Fries
      $12.60

    • Breakfast Burger

      Over Easy Egg, Bacon, American Cheese. Comes with Fries.
      $12.88

    • Mozzie Burger

      1 (6oz Patty), American Cheese, Topped with 2 Mozzie Styx & Red Sauce and Parmesan Cheese. Served with Fries.
      $14.00

    • Rueben Burger

      Swiss, Sauerkraut, Corn Beef & Thousand Island Dressing. Comes with Fries.
      $12.60

    • Quickie Cheese Burger

      Cheeseburger & Fries with Gravy All Over
      $12.60

    • California Burger

      Avocado, Tomato, Provolone, Ranch Dressing, made with a Meatless Burger Patty. Comes with Fries.
      $13.70

    • Patty Melt

      Grilled Rye Bread, 6oz Burger, Swiss Cheese & Grilled Onions. With Fries
      $12.60

    • Breakfast Quickie Burger

      Bacon Cheese Burger, with a Over Easy Egg, and Sausage Gravy On Top. Comes with Fries
      $15.08

    • Flying Rodeo Burger

      6oz Beef Patty, Cheese, Bacon, Fried Onion Ring, topped with BBQ Chicken Tenders.
      $14.80

    • Flying Buffalo Burger

      Buffalo Wing Sauce Dipped Chicken Tender on top of a Burger, with Blue Cheese Crumbles and a side of Blue Cheese or Ranch dressing. Served with Fries.
      $14.80

  • Sandwiches

    • Western Egg

      Scrambled Egg, Ham, Peppers & Onions, American Cheese on Toasted White Bread
      $7.50

    • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

      Chicken Tenders dipped in Buffalo Sauce, with American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion on a Grilled Kaiser Roll **Try a Flavor Flip, with BBQ Sauce**
      $13.05

    • Cafe Chicken

      Roasted Red Peppers, Provolone, with Grilled Chicken on a Grilled Kaiser Roll
      $11.23

    • Chicken Bacon Ranch

      Bacon, Swiss & Ranch, with Grilled Chicken on a Grilled Kaiser Roll
      $12.05

    • Rueben

      Turkey OR Corn Beef, Sauerkraut, Swiss, Thousand Island on Grilled Rye
      $12.05

    • CLASSIC CLUB

      Lettuce, Tomato, Bacon, Mayo, Cheese, with your Choice of Meat. Served with Fries
      $13.05

    • HOT TURKEY

      Hot Turkey, Fries or Mash & Gravy Over All
      $11.50

    • Grilled Veggie

      *Vegetarian* Spinach, Roasted Red Peppers, Mushrooms, Swiss on Grilled Italian Toast
      $10.40

    • Garden Wrap

      Mixed Greens, Spinach, Roasted Red Peppers, Avocado and Feta Cheese. With Fresh Squeezed Lemon Juice.
      $10.95

    • BLT

      Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo on Italian Toast
      $11.50

    • Zesty Crispy Bacon Chix Sandwich

      Crispy Chicken Tenders, Bacon, American Cheese, Onion Rings and Zesty Sauce. Served with a Side of Fries
      $13.05

    • Garlic Cajun Chicken Sandwich

      Cajun Chicken, Bacon, Avocado, cheddar cheese, with garlic aioli on a grilled Kaiser roll, lettuce, Tomato, & Onion
      $12.00

    • Water St Philly Cheese Steak

      Angus Philly Steak, Peppers, Onions & Provolone Cheese. comes with French Fries.
      $15.50

  • Sandwich Maker

    • Create Your Own Sandwich Maker

      Includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo or Mustard. Chips & Pickles
      $9.00

  • Trash Plates & Lunch Specials

    • Water St. Trash Plate

      You have asked for real meat and a trash plate so we came through for you . Twin four ounce cheese burgers or two dogs on top of fries and Mac salad doused in 8 ounces of delicious meat sauce and finished with ketchup mustard and chopped onions . Our sauce is a medium heat for everyone but as always can step it up for the heat lovers ! 14$ available daily from now on
      $14.50

    • Fish Fry

      Battered Fried Fish, on a sub roll served with French Fries, Apple Sauce, and Tartar Sauce.
      $12.60

  • Grilled Cheeses & Melts

    • Grilled Cheese

      American Cheese grilled between white bread.
      $4.65

    • Grilled Cheese & Tomato

      American Cheese & Tomato grilled between white bread.
      $7.10

    • Grilled Cheese Plus

      American Cheese, PLUS Bacon OR Ham, grilled between white bread.
      $7.65

    • Make Your Own Melt

      Choose Your Bread, Cheese & Filling ALL Melts Include Bacon, Tomato on Grilled Bread with Chips & Pickles
      $10.95

  • Signature Salads

    • Buffalo Chicken Salad

      Chicken Fingers tossed in Buffalo Sauce, Crumbly Blue Cheese, over Mixed Greens
      $13.40

    • Chicken Avocado

      Grilled Chicken, Avocado, Candied Walnuts, Feta Cheese, Over mixed Greens & Choice of Dressing
      $13.40

    • Chef Salad

      Ham, Turkey, American Cheese, Hard Boiled Egg, over mixed Greens
      $13.40

    • Cowboy Salad

      Grilled Steak, Cheddar Cheese, Sunflower Seeds, over Mixed Greens
      $18.10

    • Side Salad

      Lettuce, Tomato, Onion & Pepperoni, over Mixed Greens
      $6.00

    • Cajun Cowgirl Salad

      Cajun Seasoned Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Hard boiled Egg, Over Mixed Greens with Choice Dressing
      $13.40

    • T's Favorite Salad

      Grilled Chicken, Zesty Pickles, Chipotle Tortilla Strips, Sunflower Seeds, Hard Boiled Eggs, Cheddar Cheese. with dressing.
      $14.80

  • Soups

    • Bowl Of Soup

      Comes with Saltine Crackers, 16 oz To-Go Cup
      $5.00

    • Cup Of Soup

      Comes with Saltine Crackers 12 oz To-Go Cup
      $4.50

  • Sides, Sauces, & Gravy

    • Fries

      Golden and crispy, seasoned to perfection.
      $4.08

    • Onion Rings

      Crispy golden-fried onion rings, perfectly seasoned for a savory crunch.
      $5.00

    • Mozzie Styx

      Deep-fried mozzarella cheese sticks, typically served with a side of marinara sauce for dipping.
      $5.75

    • Chicken Fingers

      3 Tenders
      $7.80

    • Mac Salad

      Tender macaroni mixed with diced carrots, celery, and a creamy dressing.
      $3.10

    • Apple Sauce

      Pureed apples, often cooked with cinnamon and sweeteners, creating a smooth, sweet sauce.
      $3.10

    • Cottage Cheese

      Soft, white cheese made from the curds of soured milk, typically served as a side.
      $3.10

    • Sauce Sides

      Love Condiments As Much as We Do?
      $0.95

    • Brown Gravy

      Side cup of Brown Gravy
      $2.30

  • Beverages

    • Coffee

      16oz To-Go Cup
      $2.75

    • Cold Brew

      Smooth, and revitalizing cold brew coffee, perfect for a refreshing energy boost.
      $4.50

    • Hot Tea

      16 oz To-Go Cup
      $2.75

    • French Vanilla Cappuccino

      12oz To-Go Cup
      $3.30

    • Hot Chocolate

      12oz To-Go Cup
      $3.30

    • Juices

      12oz To-Go Cup
      $4.40

    • Milk

      12oz To-Go Cup
      $2.75

    • Chocolate Milk

      12oz To-Go Cup
      $3.60

    • Sodas

      16oz To-Go Cup
      $3.25

    • Raspberry Ice Tea

      Brisk Raspberry Ice Tea
      $3.65

  • Sweets & Treats

    • Peanut Butter Cookies

      House Fresh Baked Peanutbutter Cookies with Peanutbutter Chips
      $2.50

    • Chocolate Chip Cookie

      House Fresh Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies
      $2.50

    • Cinnamon Roll

      Fresh Baked, and grilled Cinnamon Roll topped, with sugar glaze.
      $4.00

  • Gluten Free

    • Make My Meal Gluten Free

      Must be selected for each meal, you desire to be made with our Gluten Free Protocol. This is for individuals who have an allergy such as Celiac Disease, which requires separate cooking surfaces and utensils.
      $4.00

    • Gluten Free White Toast

      Gluten Free White toast, add to any meal for $2.50
      $3.60

    • GLUTEN FREE Pancakes

      Gluten Free
      $6.50

    • GLUTEN FREE French Toast

      Gluten Free
      $4.35

    • GLUTEN FREE Muffin

      $4.90

  • Kids Menu

    • Kids Oatmeal

      Fresh made Oatmeal, and a side of Apple Sauce.
      $3.50

    • Kids Burger

      Choose a Burger or a Hot Dog. Served with Chips
      $5.50

    • Kid Hot Dog

      Kid Hot Dog, with Chips
      $3.00

    • Kids French Toast

      2 pieces of French Toast
      $4.25

    • Kids Chicken Fingers

      2 Chicken Fingers & Chips
      $5.20

    • Mickey Pancake

      House Pancake, made in a Mickey Mouse Shape!
      $4.25

    • Kids PB & J

      Classic Peanut butter & Jelly. Served with Chips
      $2.90

    • Kids Scrambled Eggs & Toast

      2 Eggs Scrambled & Toast
      $4.25

    • Kids Grilled Cheese

      Grilled Cheese on White Bread, served with Chips.
      $4.50

  • Street Sign T-Shirts

    • Purple Street Sign T-Shirts

      Coffee-themed apparel featuring purple street sign design. Available in sizes: small to 2x.
      $25.00

    • Black Street Sign T-Shirts

      Black street sign-themed t-shirts available in sizes small through 2x.
      $25.00

  • Street Sign Hoodies

    • Purple Street Sign Hoodies

      Purple hoodies featuring street sign designs. Available in sizes from small to 2x.
      $35.00

    • Black Street Sign Hoodies

      Black Street Sign Hoodies - Available in S, M, L, XL, 2X sizes. Comfort for every body.
      $35.00

  • T-Shirts “It’s Worth the Wait”

    • Blue “It’s Worth The Wait” T-Shirt

      Blue "It's Worth the Wait" T-shirt available in sizes: small, medium, large, XL, 2X.
      $25.00

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms