Upper Crust Pizza & Pasta Menu

4.3
(750+ Reviews)
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Original Meat Combo

      Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and bell peppers.
      $15.95
      Original Meat Combo
    • Pepperoni

      Pepperoni pizza with a choice of crusts including thick square for small to party sizes, thin and gluten-free personal sizes.
      $13.00
      Pepperoni
    • Cheese Pizza

      Cheese pizza with options from small to party size square thick crust, and personal to extra large round thin crust, including gluten-free.
      $10.75
      Cheese Pizza
    • Buffalo Wings

      Served with house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing. Please note: Our buffalo wings are served with buffalo sauce. We can not make them with no sauce or sauce on the side.
      $13.95
      Buffalo Wings
    • Sicilian Cannoli

      A crisp pasty shell piped full of sweet creamy filling, topped with chocolate chips, and dusted with powdered sugar.
      $4.95
      Sicilian Cannoli
    • 9" Personal Thin Crust Round

      6 slices
      $10.75
      9" Personal Thin Crust Round
    • Imported Spaghetti

      Served with your choice of sauce and house-made garlic bread.
      $16.95
      Imported Spaghetti
    • Coke

      2 Liter or 12 oz can.
      $2.95
      Coke
    • Garden Salad

      Mixed green lettuce with shredded carrots, green onions and croutons.
      $8.50
      Garden Salad
    • Pesto

      Pesto pizza: sizes in thick crust square from small to party, thin crust round up to extra large, and gluten-free option. our pesto sauce does not include any pine nuts
      $13.00
      Pesto
  • Combination Pizza

    • Original Meat Combo

      Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and bell peppers.
      $15.95
      Original Meat Combo
    • Meat Lover's

      Sausage, pepperoni, ham, and turkey bacon.
      $15.95
      Meat Lover's
    • Sicily's Mt. Etna

      Pepperoni, chopped pepperoncini, jalapeños and garlic.
      $15.95
      Sicily's Mt. Etna
    • Ranch BBQ Chicken

      House-made ranch sauce, BBQ chicken, red onions and turkey bacon.
      $17.50
      Ranch BBQ Chicken
    • Vegetarian Combo

      Mushrooms, onions, bell peppers, black olives and chopped tomatoes.
      $17.50
      Vegetarian Combo
    • Vegetarian Gourmet

      Artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, roasted garlic and mushrooms.
      $17.50
      Vegetarian Gourmet
    • Mediterranean

      Feta cheese, red onions, black olives and chopped tomatoes.
      $17.50
      Mediterranean
    • The Impossible Pizza

      Plant-based Impossible Meat, mushrooms and onions.
      $17.50
      The Impossible Pizza
    • Hawaiian

      Ham and pineapple.
      $15.25
      Hawaiian
    • Italian Sweet and Spicy

      Pepperoni, pineapple and jalapeños.
      $15.25
      Italian Sweet and Spicy
    • Sicilian Special

      Mushrooms, black olives and sausage.
      $15.25
      Sicilian Special
    • The Bee Sting

      Pepperoni, jalapeños and Mike's Hot Honey
      $15.25
      The Bee Sting
    • Pesto Bruschetta

      Pesto and house-made bruschetta mix on an olive oil base.
      $15.25
      Pesto Bruschetta
    • Pizza Bianca

      Artichoke hearts and garlic on an olive oil base.
      $15.25
      Pizza Bianca
    • Margherita

      Chopped tomatoes and fresh basil on an olive oil base.
      $15.25
      Margherita
    • Pepperoni

      Pepperoni pizza with a choice of crusts including thick square for small to party sizes, thin and gluten-free personal sizes.
      $13.00
      Pepperoni
    • Pesto

      Pesto pizza: sizes in thick crust square from small to party, thin crust round up to extra large, and gluten-free option. our pesto sauce does not include any pine nuts
      $13.00
      Pesto
    • Cheese Pizza

      Cheese pizza with options from small to party size square thick crust, and personal to extra large round thin crust, including gluten-free.
      $10.75
      Cheese Pizza
  • Create Your Own Pizza

    • Small Thick Crust Square

      4 slices
      $11.95
      Small Thick Crust Square
    • Medium Thick Crust Square

      6 slices
      $17.95
      Medium Thick Crust Square
    • Large Thick Crust Square

      8 slices
      $23.95
      Large Thick Crust Square
    • Family Thick Crust Square

      12 slices
      $32.95
      Family Thick Crust Square
    • Party Thick Crust Square

      24 slices
      $60.95
      Party Thick Crust Square
    • 9" Personal Thin Crust Round

      6 slices
      $10.75
      9" Personal Thin Crust Round
    • 14" Large Thin Crust Round

      8 slices
      $23.95
      14" Large Thin Crust Round
    • 16" Extra Large Thin Crust Round

      12 slices
      $29.95
      16" Extra Large Thin Crust Round
    • 10" Personal Gluten-Free Thin Crust Round

      6 slices
      $12.25
      10" Personal Gluten-Free Thin Crust Round
  • Appetizers

    • Bruschetta

      Toasted crostini served with a blend of chopped tomatoes, garlic, fresh basil, olive oil and balsamic vinegar.
      $7.95
      Bruschetta
    • Buffalo Wings

      Served with house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing. Please note: Our buffalo wings are served with buffalo sauce. We can not make them with no sauce or sauce on the side.
      $13.95
      Buffalo Wings
    • Sicilian Muffaletta Appetizer

      Pizza dough coated in sesame seeds, seasoned with olive oil and Italian spices. Layered with cheese and toasted in our brick oven until golden brown. Sliced and served with house-made ranch dressing.
      $6.95
      Sicilian Muffaletta Appetizer
    • House-Made Meatball Appetizer

      2 large hand-rolled meatballs. Served with house-made meat marinara.
      $7.50
      House-Made Meatball Appetizer
    • New York Style Italian Sausage Appetizer

      Sliced and served with house-made meat marinara.
      $7.50
      New York Style Italian Sausage Appetizer
    • Garlic Bread (3 Slices)

      Made fresh daily.
      $5.50
      Garlic Bread (3 Slices)
    • Garlic Bread (6 Slices)

      Made fresh daily.
      $7.95
      Garlic Bread (6 Slices)
  • Soup and Salads

    • Garden Salad

      Mixed green lettuce with shredded carrots, green onions and croutons.
      $8.50
      Garden Salad
    • Caesar Salad

      Crisp romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, and croutons with caesar dressing.
      $8.50
      Caesar Salad
    • Harvest Salad

      Mixed green lettuce, crumbled blue cheese, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, croutons and balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
      $9.95
      Harvest Salad
    • Greek Salad

      Crisp romaine lettuce, sliced tomatoes, Kalamata olives, red onions, cucumbers, and Feta cheese with Italian dressing.
      $9.95
      Greek Salad
    • California Chicken Salad

      Mixed green lettuce, grilled chicken breast, chopped tomatoes, red onions, bacon, avocado and croutons.
      $14.95
      California Chicken Salad
    • Soup of the Day

      Soup of the day. Served with house-made garlic bread.
      $5.95
      Soup of the Day
    • Family Garden Salad

      Family Serving (serves 5-7) . Mixed green lettuce with shredded carrots, green onions and croutons.
      $32.95
      Family Garden Salad
    • Family Caesar Salad

      Crisp romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, and croutons with caesar dressing.
      $32.95
      Family Caesar Salad
    • Family Harvest Salad

      Family Serving (serves 5-7) Mixed green lettuce, crumbled blue cheese, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, croutons and balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
      $38.95
      Family Harvest Salad
    • Family Greek Salad

      Crisp romaine lettuce, sliced tomatoes, Kalamata olives, red onions, cucumbers, and Feta cheese with Italian dressing.
      $38.95
      Family Greek Salad
  • Pasta

    • House-Made Spaghetti

      Served with your choice of sauce and house-made garlic bread.
      $16.95
      House-Made Spaghetti
    • Imported Spaghetti

      Served with your choice of sauce and house-made garlic bread.
      $16.95
      Imported Spaghetti
    • Rotini

      Served with your choice of sauce and house-made garlic bread.
      $16.95
      Rotini
    • Cheese Ravioli

      Served with your choice of sauce and house-made garlic bread.
      $16.95
      Cheese Ravioli
    • Three-Cheese Tortellini

      Served with your choice of sauce and house-made garlic bread.
      $16.95
      Three-Cheese Tortellini
    • Gluten-Free Penne

      Served with your choice of sauce.
      $16.95
      Gluten-Free Penne
    • Meat Lasagna

      Served with your choice of sauce and house-made garlic bread.
      $16.95
      Meat Lasagna
  • Sandwiches

    • House-Made Meatball

      Hand-rolled meatballs with meat marinara and cheese. Served with your choice of a side garden salad or cup of soup.
      $14.95
      House-Made Meatball
    • Italian Sausage

      Sliced sausage links with meat marinara and cheese. Served with your choice of a side garden salad or cup of soup.
      $14.95
      Italian Sausage
    • Turkey Breast

      Oven-roasted sliced turkey, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, mustard and mayonnaise. Served with your choice of a side garden salad or cup of soup.
      $14.95
      Turkey Breast
    • Turkey Pesto

      Sliced turkey breast, pesto, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise. Served with your choice of a side garden salad or cup of soup.
      $14.95
      Turkey Pesto
    • Italian Submarine

      Italian salami, sliced ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and Italian dressing. Served with your choice of a side garden salad or cup of soup.
      $14.95
      Italian Submarine
    • Ham

      Thin slices of smoked deli ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, mustard and mayonnaise. Served with your choice of a side garden salad or cup of soup.
      $14.95
      Ham
    • Vegetarian

      Mushrooms, artichoke hearts, black olives, red onions, garlic, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, mustard and mayonnaise. Served with your choice of a side garden salad or cup of soup.
      $14.95
      Vegetarian
  • Muffaletta

    • Sicilian Muffaletta Slice

      A slice of the Sicilian Muffaletta.
      $6.50
      Sicilian Muffaletta Slice
    • 16" Whole Ham Muffaletta

      With Italian spices, cheese, and thinly sliced ham.
      $42.95
      16" Whole Ham Muffaletta
    • 16" Whole Veggie Muffaletta

      With Italian spices, cheese, carrots and pesto.
      $42.95
      16" Whole Veggie Muffaletta
  • Desserts

    • Sicilian Cannoli

      A crisp pasty shell piped full of sweet creamy filling, topped with chocolate chips, and dusted with powdered sugar.
      $4.95
      Sicilian Cannoli
    • Chocolate Chip Cookie

      Pacific Cookie Company chocolate chip cookie.
      $3.95
      Chocolate Chip Cookie
    • Cookie Sundae

      Warm Pacific Cookie Company chocolate chip cookie topped with a scoop of Marianne's vanilla ice cream and drizzled with chocolate sauce.
      $8.50
      Cookie Sundae
    • Nutella Pizza

      Thin crust dessert pizza, topped with warm Nutella and powered sugar.
      $8.95
      Nutella Pizza
    • Vanilla Ice Cream

      A scoop of Marianne's vanilla ice cream.
      $5.50
      Vanilla Ice Cream
    • Molten Lava Cake

      Chocolate lava cake. Served with a scoop of Marianne's vanilla ice cream.
      $10.95
      Molten Lava Cake
  • Sides

    • Ranch Dressing

      Our famous house-made ranch dressing.
      $0.95
      Ranch Dressing
    • House-Made Meat Marinara

      House-made meat marinara, available in 2 oz, 6 oz, or 12 oz servings.
      $0.95
      House-Made Meat Marinara
    • Pizza Sauce

      House-made Pizza Sauce.
      $0.95
      Pizza Sauce
    • Anchovies

      Anchovies
      $0.95
      Anchovies
    • Blue Cheese Dressing

      House-made Blue Cheese Dressing Pizza Sauce.
      $0.95
      Blue Cheese Dressing
    • House-Made Vegetable Marinara

      House-made vegetable marinara available in 2 oz, 6 oz, or 12 oz.
      $0.95
      House-Made Vegetable Marinara
    • Jalapeños

      Sliced jalapeños, typically served as a spicy and tangy accompaniment, enhancing the flavors of the main dish.
      $0.95
      Jalapeños
  • Beverages

    • Sparkling Water

      Crystal Geyser sparkling water.
      $2.95
      Sparkling Water
    • Coke

      2 Liter or 12 oz can.
      $2.95
      Coke
    • Sprite

      2 liter or 12 oz can.
      $2.95
      Sprite
    • Diet Coke

      2 liter or 12 oz can.
      $2.95
      Diet Coke
    • Bottled Water

      Crystal Geyser bottled water.
      $2.95
      Bottled Water
  • Utensils and Condiments

    • Parmesan

      Freshly grated parmesan, often used to enhance the flavors of various dishes.
    • Peppers

      Served with a blend of hot peppers, holiday sausage, and mixed cheeses in our house sauce.
    • Forks

      Utensils typically include a set of forks designed for various Italian dining needs.
    • Knives

      Set of knives, typically used for dining. Please request if needed.
    • Napkins

      Napkins are provided upon request to accompany your meal.
    • Paper Plates

      Paper plates are provided upon request to accommodate your dining needs.
    • Plates/Napkins/Utensils

      Includes a set of plates, napkins, and utensils for convenience with your meal.
  • Apparel

    • Crew Neck T-Shirt Black

      Crew neck t-shirt in black. Sizes from small to XXX-large available.
      $22.95
      Crew Neck T-Shirt Black
    • Crew Neck Shirt Navy

      Navy crew neck shirt available in sizes from small to xxxx-large.
      $22.95
      Crew Neck Shirt Navy
    • Crew Neck Shirt Tie-Dye

      Italian crew neck shirt in tie-dye. Available sizes: small to xx-large.
      $22.95
      Crew Neck Shirt Tie-Dye
    • Women's V-Neck Shirt Black

      Women's black v-neck shirt. Available sizes: x-small to x-large.
      $23.95
    • Women's V-Neck Blush Frost

      Italian-inspired, available in extra small to x-large sizes.
      $23.95
      Women's V-Neck Blush Frost
    • Women's V-Neck Tie-Dye

      Italian-inspired, women's v-neck tie-dye apparel available in sizes: XS, S, M, XL.
      $23.95
      Women's V-Neck Tie-Dye
    • Polo Shirt Black

      Black polo shirt available in sizes ranging from small to xxx-large.
      $23.95
      Polo Shirt Black
    • Polo Shirt Navy

      Available sizes: medium to xxx-large.
      $23.95
      Polo Shirt Navy
    • Upper Crust Pizza Man Sticker

      Upper Crust Pizza Man Sticker
      $1.00
      Upper Crust Pizza Man Sticker
    • Upper Crust Sticker

      Upper Crust Sticker
      $1.00
      Upper Crust Sticker
    • Zip Up Sweatshirt Black

      Available sizes:small to xx-large.
      $44.95
      Zip Up Sweatshirt Black

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Mission West
Mission West
4.9
(46 Reviews)
Cocktail bar
Watering Hole
Watering Hole
4.1
(71 Reviews)
Bar
Tam's Restaurant
Tam's Restaurant
3.9
(216 Reviews)
Chinese
Domino's Pizza
Domino's Pizza
3.1
(369 Reviews)
Chicken wings, Pizza
Companion Bakeshop Westside Santa Cruz
Companion Bakeshop Westside Santa Cruz
4.6
(474 Reviews)
Bakery, Cafe, Espresso bar
Scrumptious Fish and Chips Food Truck
Scrumptious Fish and Chips Food Truck
4.5
(34 Reviews)
Restaurant
Humble Sea Brewing Co.
Humble Sea Brewing Co.
4.6
(613 Reviews)
Brewery, Bar, Beer garden
Chloe’s Kitchen
Chloe’s Kitchen
4.6
(191 Reviews)
Dumpling, Chinese noodle, Soup
The Apéro Club
The Apéro Club
4.9
(63 Reviews)
Wine bar
Santa Cruz Mountain Brewing
Santa Cruz Mountain Brewing
4.5
(356 Reviews)
Brewery, Pub

(831) 423-9010

2415 Mission St, Santa Cruz, CA 95060


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms