Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery Menu

4.7
(475+ Reviews)
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Single Item Pizza (Large 14")

      Our sourdough crust topped with our house-made red sauce and hand-shredded mozzarella with your choice of topping(s).
      $22.00
    • Single Item Pizza (Small 12")

      Housemade red sauce and hand-shredded mozzarella with your choice of topping(s).
      $16.00
    • Cheesy Bread w/ Red Sauce

      Comes with a side(1) of red sauce
      $10.00
    • Brownies w/Chocolate Buttercream(1)

      Delicious chocolate chip brownies iced with a chocolate buttercream.
      $3.50
    • Calzone - Single Item

      1/2 lb of dough with an olive oil and garlic base, filled with up to 5 ingredients between 2 layers of hand-shredded mozzarella.
      $11.00
    • Blueberry Chocolate Chip Bars (2)

      Chocolate chip cookie dough topped with blueberries and a crumb topping baked to PERFECTION!
      $4.00
    • Stromboli - Single Item

      1/2 lb of dough filled our red sauce with up to 5 ingredients between 2 layers of hand-shredded mozzarella.
      $11.00
    • Cheese Pizza (Small 12")

      Sourdough crust, house made red sauce and mozzarella cheese.
      $14.95
    • Chocolate Chip Cookies(2)

      Yummy chocolate chip cookies baked from scratch.
      $3.50
    • Pauper’s Pie

      White sauce based, spinach, red onion, bacon and freshly minced garlic.
      $21.10
  • Build Your Own

    Build it how you want it! Baked in a wood-burning oven.
    • Cheese Pizza (Small 12")

      Sourdough crust, house made red sauce and mozzarella cheese.
      $14.95
    • Cheese Pizza (Large 14")

      $18.85
    • Single Item Pizza (Small 12")

      Housemade red sauce and hand-shredded mozzarella with your choice of topping(s).
      $16.00
    • Single Item Pizza (Large 14")

      Our sourdough crust topped with our house-made red sauce and hand-shredded mozzarella with your choice of topping(s).
      $22.00
    • Calzone - Single Item

      1/2 lb of dough with an olive oil and garlic base, filled with up to 5 ingredients between 2 layers of hand-shredded mozzarella.
      $11.00
    • Stromboli - Single Item

      1/2 lb of dough filled our red sauce with up to 5 ingredients between 2 layers of hand-shredded mozzarella.
      $11.00
    • Cheesy Bread w/ Red Sauce

      Comes with a side(1) of red sauce
      $10.00
  • Wood Fired Specialty Pizzas (12” Small)

    • 3-Cheeses BeGeezus

      Hand-shredded mozzarella, sharp Cheddar, and fresh mozzarella. A cheesy delight!
      $18.20
    • Autumn Swoon

      Italian sausage, banana peppers, red onions all topped with extra cheese and a sprinkle of red pepper flakes.
      $21.45
    • Pauper’s Pie

      White sauce based, spinach, red onion, bacon and freshly minced garlic.
      $21.10
    • Pigskin Pie

      A meat lovers dream! Pepperoni, Italian sausage and black forest ham. You can choose a veggie to top as well.
      $23.40
    • Potato Focaccia

      Olive oil and spice base with hand shredded mozzarella, thinly sliced potatoes, red onion and sharp cheddar cheese.
      $20.80
    • RefrigeRaider

      Tyler’s “build your own” supreme. Your choice of 2 meats and 3 veggies.
      $24.05
    • Sunny Side Up

      Butter and olive oil based. Hand shredded mozzarella, shredded potatoes, ham, sunny side up eggs all topped with bacon and cheddar cheese.
      $24.05
    • Veggie Focaccia

      Olive oil and spice based. Hand shredded mozzarella and your choice of 3 veggies.
      $20.15
    • Vegetarian

      Red sauce based. Hand shredded mozzarella and your choice of 3 veggies.
      $20.15
  • Wood Fired Specialty Pizzas (14" Large)

    • 3-Cheeses BeGeezus

      A cheesy delight! A blend of hand-shredded mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, and cheddar atop Tyler's red sauce.
      $22.10
    • Autumn Swoon

      Spicy Italian sausage, banana peppers, red onions and extra cheese sprinkled with red pepper flakes.
      $25.35
    • Pauper's Pie

      A white sauce base topped with leafy spinach, red onion, fresh garlic, and crispy bacon.
      $25.00
    • Pigskin Pie

      Meat lovers pie! Pepperoni, italian sausage, and black forest ham with your choice of 1 veggie.
      $27.30
    • Potato Focaccia

      An olive oil based pie sprinkled with basil, salt, and pepper. Mozzarella cheese, sliced potatoes, red onions, and sharp cheddar cheese.
      $24.70
    • RefrigeRaider

      Tyler's Supreme! Your choice of 2 meats and 3 veggies.
      $27.95
    • Sunny Side Up

      A butter based pie topped with hand shredded mozzarella, black forest ham, shredded potatoes, cheddar cheese, bacon, and sunny side eggs.
      $27.95
    • Veggie Focaccia

      Another olive oil based pie topped with basil, salt, pepper, mozzarella and your choice of 3 veggies.
      $24.05
    • Vegetarian

      Red sauce based pie with hand shredded mozzarella and your choice of 3 veggies.
      $24.05
  • Desserts

    Always made from scratch!
    • Brownies w/Chocolate Buttercream(1)

      Delicious chocolate chip brownies iced with a chocolate buttercream.
      $3.50
    • Blueberry Chocolate Chip Bars (2)

      Chocolate chip cookie dough topped with blueberries and a crumb topping baked to PERFECTION!
      $4.00
    • Chocolate Chip Cookies(2)

      Yummy chocolate chip cookies baked from scratch.
      $3.50

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Taco Bell
Taco Bell
3.6
(956 Reviews)
Burrito, Mexican, Taco
Hangry City Grille and Spirits
Hangry City Grille and Spirits
4.5
(677 Reviews)
Restaurant
Hibachi Express
Hibachi Express
4.1
(76 Reviews)
Japanese, Asian
Scramblers
Scramblers
4.4
(865 Reviews)
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch
GENJIGO
GENJIGO
3.7
(349 Reviews)
Asian, Japanese, Japanese steakhouse
Donatos Pizza
Donatos Pizza
4.1
(360 Reviews)
Pizza
Jersey Mike's Subs
Jersey Mike's Subs
4.2
(435 Reviews)
Sandwich shop, Deli
Rick's Freshmade Cafe and Catering
Rick's Freshmade Cafe and Catering
4.8
(122 Reviews)
Deli, Restaurant, Sandwich shop
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza
3.4
(187 Reviews)
Pizza
Pulp Juice and Smoothie Bar
Pulp Juice and Smoothie Bar
4.5
(186 Reviews)
Juice shop

(614) 322-9587

7516 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms