Two Tony's Pizza

Best kept secret in Linden! Pizza is great and cheaper than other places that don't even have good pizza...love this place and the authentic Sicilian vibe

We used to LOVE Two Tonys and get it ALL the time. I don’t know if they changed over management or chefs or something but the last three times have been complete disappointments, and we have decided as of tonight to not order from the ever again sadly. The first of our disappointments was our favorite pie - Cowboy we opened the box and it was inedible because it looked like they dumped an entire gallon of blue cheese and buffalo sauce on it the pizza was literally swimming, we are sauce lovers but it was extreme. We thought maybe it was an accident like it over spilled or the cap flew off so we decided we were going to try again the following week. AGAIN, DROWNING inedible and the pizza dough was half burnt half doughy. Tonight we ordered the Great White pie with extra cheese and pepperoni well done. The pie gets here and it’s a plain regular pie with pepperoni, we specifically ordered a white pie because I am currently very very pregnant and don’t like tomato sauce right now. I couldn’t have dinner because they completely gave us the wrong one. I don’t understand how they went from being the absolute best spot ever to the worst. I’m so sad.

Ordered a pie through Slice. Pie came cold and was delivered on a bike in 30 degree weather. Imagine what the pizza looked like. Was told I could pick it up bc there were no delivery driver. I couldn’t bc I was at work and anyway I pay for slice app prices. Winded up spending a half hour on phone w SLICE and not one ounce of remorse from the pizzeria. Not ordering here anymore.

The pizza was very underwhelming; tasted like it was a kid’s menu pizza at a subpar restaurant. Definitely expected more flavor and finesse.

The guy who makes the best pizza there is the older gentleman with the bald head. If he's not there don't bother. Went here on 5/6/23 and I'm so disappointed. Picked my slice up and the cheese and topping came straight off. 2/10/24 there is a new guy making the pizza and I wasn't disappointed...Keep up the good work

It was horrible I’m sorry but I can’t eat the food