Tully's Good Times Amherst Menu

4.4

(2,275+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Starters & Snacks The Best Chicken Tenders on Earth Salad Entrées Huge Deli Sandwiches Tully's Favorites Sandwich Platters Burgers Pastas Healthy Choices Dinner Specials Desserts Beverages Sides/Add

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Tully's Tender Dinner
  Fresh hand battered chicken tenders with fries. Served with Tully's honey mustard and coleslaw.
  $20.79
- 10 Tenders
  Served with tully’s honey mustard sauce.
  $26.29
- Asian Tender Dinner
  Tully's tenders dipped in house sweet 'n spicy Asian sauce and sprinkled with fresh scallions. Served with fries, Tully's ranch and coleslaw.
  $21.59
- Tully's Tenders Appetizer
  Hand battered chicken tenders served with fries and Tully's honey mustard.
  $18.19
- Buffalo Tender Dinner
  Tully's tenderse dipped in house buffalo sauce. Served with fries, bleu cheese and coleslaw.
  $21.59
- Cajun Chicken Pasta
  Fresh chicken, mushrooms and ziti tossed in a spicy alfredo sauce.
  $23.79
- Chicken Wing Dip (GS)
  Our homemade spicy dip topped with melted jack- Our homemade spicy dip topped with melted Jack-cheddar cheese and sour cream. Served with tortilla chips.
  $15.79
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
  Homemade with chocolate crumb crust, creamy peanut butter, topped with semi-sweet chocolate and whipped cream.
  $10.89
- Side Fries
  $4.99
- Mozzarella Sticks
  Lightly battered and served with our own marinara sauce.
  $14.39
- Add Ranch
  $1.99
- Chicken & Broccoli Alfredo
  Tender chicken and broccoli tossed with fettuccine alfredo.
  $22.49
Starters & Snacks
- Chicken Wing Dip (GS)
  Our homemade spicy dip topped with melted jack- Our homemade spicy dip topped with melted Jack-cheddar cheese and sour cream. Served with tortilla chips.
  $15.79
- Chicken Quesadilla
  A flour tortilla packed with grilled chicken, cheese, tomatoes, jalapeños, black olives and scallions. Served with sour cream and pico de gallo.
  $18.79
- Louisianna Crab Dip
  A blend of real and imitation crab meat, homemade and creamy with a little zing! Served with tortilla chips.
  $14.99
- Mozzarella Sticks
  Lightly battered and served with our own marinara sauce.
  $14.39
- Veggie Quesadilla
  A flour tortilla packed with cheese, tomatoes, jalapeños, black olives and scallions. Served with sour cream and pico de gallo.
  $14.99
- Tex-Mex Egg Rolls
  Filled with spicy chicken, corn, black beans, peppers, onions and melted cheese. Served with spicy Cajun sauce and salsa.
  $16.29
- Chicken N Cheese
  Tully's tenders and mozzarella sticks with Tully's honey mustard and marinara sauce.
  $15.29
The Best Chicken Tenders on Earth
Our chicken tenders are fresh, non-marinated, never frozen and all-natural.
- Asian Tender Dinner
  Tully's tenders dipped in house sweet 'n spicy Asian sauce and sprinkled with fresh scallions. Served with fries, Tully's ranch and coleslaw.
  $21.59
- 10 Tenders
  Served with tully’s honey mustard sauce.
  $26.29
- Tully's Tender Dinner
  Fresh hand battered chicken tenders with fries. Served with Tully's honey mustard and coleslaw.
  $20.79
- Tully's Tenders Appetizer
  Hand battered chicken tenders served with fries and Tully's honey mustard.
  $18.19
- Buffalo Tender Dinner
  Tully's tenderse dipped in house buffalo sauce. Served with fries, bleu cheese and coleslaw.
  $21.59
- Buffalo Tenders Appetizer
  Tully's tenders dipped in buffalo wing sauce. Served with fries and creamy bleu cheese.
  $18.69
- Asian Tenders Appetizer
  Tully's tenders tossed in a sweet 'n spicy Asian sauce and sprinkled with fresh scallions. Served with fries.
  $18.69
Salad Entrées
Served with garlic bread and choice of dressing: Tully's ranch (gs), Tully's honey mustard (gs), thousand island (gs), red wine vinaigrette (gs), fat-free Italian (gs), creamy bleu cheese (gs), or dijon balsamic vinaigrette (gs). Add crumbled bleu cheese for an additional charge.
- Balsamic Chicken Salad
  Romaine tossed with Balsamic vinaigrette dressing and tomato bruschetta. Topped with roasted peppers, olives, Romano cheese, grilled chicken and scallions.
  $21.29
- Tavern Steak Salad
  Mixed greens tossed with red wine vinaigrette, cucumbers, diced tomatoes, scallions, potatoes and topped with grilled USDA Choice Flat iron steak and crumbly Bleu Cheese.
  $22.49
- BBQ Chicken Salad (GS)
  Romaine and iceberg lettuce tossed with homemade Tully's ranch, black beans, corn, jack-cheddar cheese. Topped with scallions, cilantro, diced tomatoes, tortilla chips and BBQ, grilled chicken.
  $18.79
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
  Crisp romaine tossed with Caesar dressing and homemade croutons, topped with grilled chicken.
  $18.69
- Tully's Tender Salad
  Salad greens, fresh vegetables, black olives, jack cheddar cheese topped with Tully's tenders. Sub buffalo tenders for an additional charge.
  $18.89
Huge Deli Sandwiches
Served with a pickle spear. Add fries, loaded potato salad or fat free pasta salad and add a side salad for an additional charge.
- The Ultimate Grilled Cheese
  Cheddar, yellow American and white American cheese on country white bread.
  $17.49
- Tuna Melt
  Grilled with melted Cheddar cheese and sliced tomatoes on Rye.
  $18.79
- The Tully
  Shaved turkey and ham lightly grilled and topped with melted white American cheese and bacon with lettuce and tomato on butter toasted deli bread.
  $18.79
- New York Grilled Reuben
  Corned beef, thousand island dressing, sauerkraut and melted swiss on rye.
  $19.99
- The Ultimate BLT
  Crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on country white bread.
  $18.49
Tully's Favorites
- Mile High Meatloaf (Mashed potatoes available at 4pm, except Sunday, all day)
  Homemade meatloaf (contains mushrooms) served on top of country mashed potatoes and topped with fresh gravy. Served with coleslaw.Mashed potatoes available at 4pm (except Sunday, all day)
  $19.99
- California Fish Taco
  A crisp tortilla packed with hand breaded haddock, melted cheese, black beans, pico de gallo, scallions, black olives, jalapeños and our spicy homemade dressing. Served with rice and beans.
  $20.09
- Santa Fe Chicken Dinner
  Two fresh 6oz chicken breast grilled then topped with teriyaki sauce, American cheese, mushrooms, and bacon. Served with coleslaw and choice of side.
  $22.49
- Fish Fry Haddock Dinner
  Lightly breaded haddock with choice of potato, coleslaw and tartar sauce.
  $21.29
- Seafood Combo
  Hand breaded shrimp and lightly breaded haddock, served with choice of potato and coleslaw.
  $22.49
Sandwich Platters
Served with a pickle spear and choice of fries, boiled potatoes, rice or broccoli. Add a side salad for an additional charge.
- Ranch Chicken
  Chicken breast hand battered and lightly fried. Topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, bacon and Tully's ranch dressing.
  $18.29
- Buffalo Chicken
  Hand battered chicken breast dipped in buffalo sauce, topped with bleu cheese.
  $17.49
- Cajun Cheddar Chicken Sandwich
  Grilled chicken breast seasoned with Cajun spices and topped with cheddar cheese. Served on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato and Cajun mayo.
  $18.19
- Bacon Chicken Teriyaki Sandwich
  An old favorite! Grilled chicken breast topped with teriyaki sauce, American cheese, mushrooms and bacon.
  $18.79
- Blackened Mahi Sandwich
  Grilled to perfection with diced pickles, lettuce and Cajun mayo.
  $19.99
- Cheese Steak
  Sliced sirloin topped with onions, peppers, mushrooms and melted American cheese.
  $18.39
- Fish Fry Haddock Sandwich
  Lightly hand breaded haddock, served with lettuce and a side of tartar sauce.
  $17.89
Burgers
Fresh ground, never frozen steak burgers. Burgers are prepared medium, medium-well, or well done. Served with a pickle spear and fries. Add a side salad for an additional charge.
- Mountain Melt Burger
  Our huge burger packed between our ultimate grilled cheese with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
  $19.99
- Smokehouse Burger
  Bacon, cheddar cheese, BBQ sauce, sauteed red onion and Cajun mayo.
  $17.89
- Bacon Cheese Burger
  Five strips of bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
  $18.79
- Fiery Jalapeno Cheddar Burger (Not Available at our Fairmount location)
  Seasoned with our fiery habañero roasted garlic seasoning and jalapeños right in the burger. Topped with cheddar cheese and Cajun mayo.**Not Available at our Fairmount Location**
  $17.99
- American Classic Burger
  Our fresh steak burger topped with American cheese and freshly sliced white onion with diced pickles, ketchup and mustard. A must try!
  $18.19
- Basic Burger
  Lettuce and tomato.
  $17.49
- Cheeseburger
  Lettuce, tomato and choice of American, cheddar, swiss or pepper-jack.
  $18.29
- Knife & Fork Cheesy Philly Burger
  Topped with diced onions, peppers, American cheese and our homemade mac 'n cheese sauce poured all over the bun.
  $19.99
- Turkey Burger
  1/2 lb. juicy ground seasoned turkey grilled with lettuce and tomato.
  $17.49
- Mushroom Swiss Burger
  Sautéed mushrooms and melted swiss cheese.
  $17.29
Pastas
Served with warm garlic bread and a side salad.
- Baked Ziti
  A generous portion of ziti tossed in our own marinara sauce with Romano and mozzarella cheese, then baked.
  $19.69
- Cajun Chicken Pasta
  Fresh chicken, mushrooms and ziti tossed in a spicy alfredo sauce.
  $23.79
- Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese
  Tender chicken sautéed in buffalo sauce then tossed with ziti pasta and our homemade cheese sauce. Topped with butter crumb topping and melted jack‐cheddar cheese.
  $23.79
- Chicken Parmigiana
  Chicken breast breaded Italian style, topped with our own marinara sauce, Romano and mozzarella with a side of fettuccine.
  $20.69
- Chicken & Broccoli Alfredo
  Tender chicken and broccoli tossed with fettuccine alfredo.
  $22.49
- Cheesy Chicken Broccoli Bake
  Homemade cheddar cheese sauce tossed with tender chicken, ziti and broccoli. Topped with our buttery crumb topping.
  $21.19
Healthy Choices
Most of our healthy choice options are under 600 calories.
- Shrimp Creole
  A taste of New Orleans! Plump shrimp and our own Creole seasoning sautéed with garlic butter, fresh chopped celery, green peppers, onions, diced tomatoes and a little hot sauce for some kick! Served with seasoned rice.
  $19.39
- Orange Tenders Rice Bowl
  Tully's Tenders® tossed with broccoli, shredded carrots and our homemade orange citrus sauce. Served over seasoned rice and sprinkled with scallions.
  $18.79
- Chicken Fresca
  Chicken tenders sautéed in our light tomato white wine sauce with mushrooms, tomato bruschetta, roasted red peppers, Romano cheese, scallions and fresh lemon. Served over seasoned rice.
  $21.29
- Healthy Choice Life Bowl
  Rice accompanied by southwest seasoned chicken, black beans, corn, pico de gallo, guacamole, cilantro and fresh lime. (under 600 calories).
  $17.49
- Blackened Shrimp Rice Bowl
  Blackened gulf shrimp, grilled with onions, corn, black beans and roasted red peppers. Served over rice with pico de gallo and fresh cilantro.
  $17.49
Dinner Specials
- Baked Stuffed Shells
  Pasta shells stuffed with ricotta, herbs, and mozzarella cheese. Topped with our own marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese then baked until golden brown. Served with a side salad and garlic bread.
  $19.99
- Steak Fajita Bowl
  Seasoned Black Angus Flat Iron steak served with grilled onions, mushrooms and peppers, pico de gallo, guacamole and cowboy caviar. Served over seasoned riced and sprinkled with fresh cilantro and cheddar-jack cheese.
  $23.79
- Grilled Pork Chops
  Two center-cut loin pork chops seasoned with salt and pepper then grilled. Served with applesauce, coleslaw and country mashed potatoes.
  $21.29
- Orange Citrus Salmon
  8oz Norwegian salmon grilled with our homemade orange citrus sauce. Served with seasoned rice and fresh vegetables.
  $24.99
- Steak and Tender Combo
  6oz USDA choice Black Angus Flat Iron steak and Tully’sTenders® served together with Tully’s Honey Mustard. Served with country mashed potatoes and coleslaw.
  $24.99
- Steak and Shells Combo
  6oz USDA Choice Black Angus Flat Iron steak served with our classic stuffed shells and garlic bread.
  $24.99
- Petite Flat Iron Steak
  6oz USDA choice Black Angus flat iron steak served with country mashed potatoes and fresh vegetables.
  $20.99
Desserts
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
  Homemade with chocolate crumb crust, creamy peanut butter, topped with semi-sweet chocolate and whipped cream.
  $10.89
- Chocolate Chip Cookie
  Warm chocolate chip cookie.
  $2.49
Beverages
Looking for a refreshing drink to pair with your meal? Select a drink below from our wide variety of Pepsi products
- Diet Pepsi - 2L Bottle
  A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories.
  $4.99
- Starry - 20oz Bottle
  A light and refreshing, caffeine-free, lemon-lime soda made with real sugar
  $2.99
- Pepsi - 2L Bottle
  The bold, refreshing, robust cola
  $4.99
- Pepsi - 20oz Bottle
  The bold, refreshing, robust cola
  $2.99
- Starry - 2L Bottle
  A light and refreshing, caffeine-free, lemon-lime soda made with real sugar
  $4.99
- Gatorade Cool Blue - 20oz Bottle
  Cool, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
  $3.99
- Aquafina - 20oz Bottle
  Pure water for a perfect taste
  $2.99
- Diet Pepsi - 20oz Bottle
  A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories.
  $2.99
Sides/Add
- Add Ranch
  $1.99
- Side Boiled Potatoes
  $4.49
- Add Bleu Cheese
  $1.99
- Side Coleslaw
  $3.99
- Add Honey Mustard
  $1.99
- Side Asian Sauce
  $1.99
- Side Mashed Potatoes (after 4:30 pm)
  $4.99
- Side Alfredo Sauce
  $3.99
- Side of Gravy
  $1.49
- Side Garlic Parm Sauce
  $1.99
- Add Tartar Sauce
  $1.49
- Side Mild Wing Sauce
  $1.99
- Add Caesar
  $1.79
- Add Italian Dressing
  $1.79
- Add Sour Cream
  $1.09
- Add Salsa
  $1.09
- Add Black Olives
  $1.09
- Add Grilled Onions
  $1.29
- Add Lettuce
  $1.09
- Add Tomato
  $1.09
- Side Salad
  $3.29
- Cutlery Kit with napkin
- Add 1000 Island
  $1.79
- Add Celery
  $0.99
- Add Hot Fudge
  $1.49
- Add Roll
  $1.49
- Side Applesauce
  $3.99
- Side Guacamole
  $3.79
- Side Hot Wing Sauce
  $1.99
- Side Medium Wing Sauce
  $1.99
- Add Nacho Cheese
  $1.49
- Add Mushrooms
  $1.29
- Add BBQ
  $1.79
- Add Garlic Bread
  $1.29
- Side Fries
  $4.99
- Side Rice
  $4.49
- Side Buffalo Wing Sauce
  $1.99
- Add Marinara
  $1.79