Top Shelf Cookies Menu

4.8

(125+ Reviews)

$Bakery

Customer Favorites Wicked Fresh Cookies Stacks (bag of 6)

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Hazel's Chocolate Chip
  We didn't reinvent the wheel but we did perfect it an impeccable blend of buttery sweetness and dark chocolate richness with a crispy exterior and soft inner yumminess. make no mistake this is no back-of-the-bag recipe. it's the very best of a beloved classic and that's why we named it for hazel - the greatest grandma that ever was ingredient: flour brown sugar chocolate chips butter sugar eggs vanilla baking soda salt. contains: wheat milk eggs and soy.
  $11.00
- Black & Gold
  The cookie that started it all inspired by boston's 2011 champions. luxurious black cocoa is used to make this chewy dark chocolate cookie studded with peanut butter chips. if you're a superstitious hockey fan in boston this is the cookie for you
  $11.00
- PB Toffee Treasures
  The winner of the 2013 boston cookie throwdown these treasure-laden tastes never met a sweet tooth they couldn't charm. golden brown cookies studded with crunchy toffee bits and miniature peanut butter cups these sweet treats feature a deep caramel flavor balanced with just a hint of salt. ingredients: flour brown sugar butter sugar eggs peanut butter cups toffee vanilla baking soda salt. contains: wheat milk eggs soy.
  $11.00
- Boston Lager Chocolate Chip
  Boston is an innovative city it was about time someone put boston's original cookie with some of samuel adams' original brew: boston lager this is a spin on our chocolate chip cookie but you know with a beer in it
  $11.00
- Raisin Healthy
  Here at top shelf cookies we're all about sugar butter and chocolate and we have no pretense that any of those qualify as health foods. but if you're trying to eat better these are....almost. rolled oats eggs plump raisins
  $11.00
- Green Monster Mint
  A dark chewy chocolate cookie is strewn with vibrant green mint chips that remind us of fenway park ingredients: flour brown sugar butter mint chocolate chips sugar eggs cocoa baking soda baking powder salt. contains: wheat milk eggs and soy.
  $11.00
Wicked Fresh Cookies
Fresh baked cookies
- Hazel's Chocolate Chip
  Browned butter meets Belgian chocolate in a hand-scooped cookie that celebrates family baking tradition. Chewy, delicious perfection! Ingredients: Flour, Brown Sugar, Chocolate Chips, Butter, Sugar, Eggs, Vanilla, Baking Soda, Salt CONTAINS: WHEAT, MILK, EGGS, & SOY
  $2.75
- Black & Golds
  The cookie that started it all, inspired by Boston's 2011 champions. Luxurious black cocoa is used to make this chewy dark chocolate cookie studded with peanut butter chips. If you're a superstitious hockey fan in Boston, this is the cookie for you!
  $2.75
- Green Monster Mint
  A rich, fudgy chocolate cookie, dotted with vibrant, green specks of mint, brings us back to the liveliness of Fenway Park! Ingredients: Flour, Butter, Green Mint Chips, Dark Corn Syrup, Dark Brown Sugar, Sugar, Egg Whites, Black Cocoa, Dutch Process Cocoa, Vanilla, Baking Soda, Kosher Salt CONTAINS: WHEAT, MILK, EGGS, & SOY
  $2.75
- PB Toffee Treasures
  The winner of the 2013 Boston Cookie Throwdown, these treasure-laden tastes never met a sweet tooth they couldn't charm. Golden brown cookies studded with crunchy toffee bits and miniature peanut butter cups, these sweet treats feature a deep caramel flavor balanced with just a hint of salt. Ingredients: flour, brown sugar, butter, sugar, eggs peanut butter cups, toffee, vanilla, baking soda, salt. Contains: wheat, milk, eggs, soy.
  $2.75
- Raisin Healthy
  Here at top shelf cookies, we're all about sugar, butter, and chocolate, and we have no pretense that any of those qualify as health foods. But if you're trying to eat better, these are....almost. Rolled oats, eggs, plump raisins
  $2.75
- Boston Lager Chocolate Chip
  Boston is an innovative city, it was about time someone put Boston's original cookie with some of Samuel Adams original brew: Boston Lager! This is a spin on our chocolate chip cookie, but you know, with beer in it! Ingredients: Flour, Brown Sugar, Butter, Milk Chocolate Chips, Sugar, Eggs, Samuel Adams Boston Lager, Egg Yolks, Vanilla Extract, Baking Soda, Salt, Cinnamon CONTAINS: WHEAT, MILK, EGGS & SOY
  $2.75
- Short & Stout
  A rich chocolate treat infused with bold Guinness flavor! Each cookie is a chewy delight, featuring a blend of cocoa powders and creamy white chocolate chips. Perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth anytime! Ingredients: Flour, Brown Sugar, Butter, White Chocolate Chips, Sugar, Eggs, Cocoa, Guinness Draught, Vanilla, Baking Soda, Baking Powder, Salt CONTAINS: WHEAT, MILK, EGGS, SOY
  $2.75
- Salted Caramel
  Enjoy our chewy cookie made with browned butter, dark brown sugar, and caramel bits, topped with flaky sea salt. A perfect sweet and salty treat you won’t want to miss! Ingredients:Dark Brown Sugar, Flour, Butter, Caramel Bits, Eggs, Sugar, Egg Yolks, Vanilla, Salt, Baking Powder CONTAINS: WHEAT, MILK, EGGS, SOY
  $2.75
- Lucky Charm
  A rich chocolate treat infused with bold Guinness flavor! Each cookie is a chewy delight, featuring a blend of cocoa powders and creamy white chocolate chips. Perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth anytime! Ingredients:Flour, Sugar, Butter, Sprinkles, Eggs, Light Brown Sugar, Baking Powder, Vanilla, Baking Soda, Kosher Salt CONTAINS: WHEAT, MILK, EGG, & SOY
  $2.75
- Castle Island Chocolate
  Indulge in our Castle Island Chocolate cookie, featuring rich cocoa, bold South Boston Irish Whiskey, and crunchy sliced almonds. This chewy, chocolaty treat delivers unforgettable flavor in every bite! Ingredients:Flour, Light Brown Sugar, Butter, Almonds, Sugar, Egg, Dutch Process Cocoa, Black Cocoa, Grandten Distilling South Boston Irish Whiskey, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Kosher Salt CONTAINS: WHEAT, MILK, EGGS & TREE NUTS
  $2.75
Stacks (bag of 6)
Stacks
- Black & Gold
  The cookie that started it all inspired by boston's 2011 champions. luxurious black cocoa is used to make this chewy dark chocolate cookie studded with peanut butter chips. if you're a superstitious hockey fan in boston this is the cookie for you
  $11.00
- Hazel's Chocolate Chip
  We didn't reinvent the wheel but we did perfect it an impeccable blend of buttery sweetness and dark chocolate richness with a crispy exterior and soft inner yumminess. make no mistake this is no back-of-the-bag recipe. it's the very best of a beloved classic and that's why we named it for hazel - the greatest grandma that ever was ingredient: flour brown sugar chocolate chips butter sugar eggs vanilla baking soda salt. contains: wheat milk eggs and soy.
  $11.00
- PB Toffee Treasures
  The winner of the 2013 boston cookie throwdown these treasure-laden tastes never met a sweet tooth they couldn't charm. golden brown cookies studded with crunchy toffee bits and miniature peanut butter cups these sweet treats feature a deep caramel flavor balanced with just a hint of salt. ingredients: flour brown sugar butter sugar eggs peanut butter cups toffee vanilla baking soda salt. contains: wheat milk eggs soy.
  $11.00
- Boston Lager Chocolate Chip
  Boston is an innovative city it was about time someone put boston's original cookie with some of samuel adams' original brew: boston lager this is a spin on our chocolate chip cookie but you know with a beer in it
  $11.00
- Green Monster Mint
  A dark chewy chocolate cookie is strewn with vibrant green mint chips that remind us of fenway park ingredients: flour brown sugar butter mint chocolate chips sugar eggs cocoa baking soda baking powder salt. contains: wheat milk eggs and soy.
  $11.00
- Raisin Healthy
  Here at top shelf cookies we're all about sugar butter and chocolate and we have no pretense that any of those qualify as health foods. but if you're trying to eat better these are....almost. rolled oats eggs plump raisins
  $11.00