Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
Matzo Ball Soup
Our light and fluffy matzo balls in a rich chicken broth with carrots and onions.
$7.85+
Reuben
Our classic hot corned beef, sauerkraut & Swiss with homestyle Russian dressing on grilled Artisan rye. Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$19.10
Classic Deli Salad Sandwich
Served on a fresh baked Artisan Rye, Wheat, Challah, Wrap or Brioche Bun. Served with coleslaw & a dill pickle.
$14.40+
Chicken Noodle Soup
Loaded with chicken & vegetables - Only Bubbe makes it as good!
$6.90+
French Fries
Small or Basket
$5.55+
Build Your Own Burger
All burgers are served on a brioche bun. Includes choice of cheese & one sauce.
Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$16.00
Toojay's Cobb
Fresh lettuce blend diced chicken breast, ham, red onions, crumbled bacon, tomatoes, hard boiled eggs & cheddar.
$19.10
Cup of Soup & Half Hand Sliced or Salad Sandwich
Your Choice of Soup & Your Choice of Half Sandwich. Served with cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$16.90
Strawberry Citrus
Fresh lettuce blend tossed with raspberry vinaigrette, topped with mandarin oranges, fresh strawberries, red grapes, Gorgonzola & toasted almonds
$16.45
TooJay’s Famous Potato Knish
Filled with seasoned & whipped potatos
$7.50
St. Patrick's Day Specials
Limited Time Only - Available till 3/17!
New England Clam Chowder
A hearty chowder full of tender New England clams and chunks of potatoes.
$10.35+
Traditional Corned Beef & Cabbage Dinner
Three Courses
- Your choice of Clam Chowder, one of our other delicious cups of soup, side salad or Caesar salad.
- Traditional Corned Beef & cabbage, red potatoes, baby carrots and a side of horseradish cream.
- A slice of our made-from-scratch Irish Cream Cheesecake.
$29.90
Irish Grilled Cheese
Corned Beef and Cheddar cheese, grilled on Rye Bread with Green Onions and Our Very Own St. Pattys Sauce! Comes with French fries & coleslaw.
$17.25
Irish Cream Cheesecake
One of our most popular cakes. Available for a limited time.
$9.20+
Green & White Cookies (pound)
$12.65
Corned Beef
$11.50+
Starters
TooJay’s Famous Potato Knish
Filled with seasoned & whipped potatos
$7.50
Mini Potato Pancakes
A crunchy sampling of our signature scratch-made pancakes served with sour cream and applesauce.
$11.50
Chopped Liver
Our own famous recipe. Served with a slice of Artisan rye & fresh vegetables
$10.35
Loaded Latkes
Our crispy, scratch-made potato pancake bites topped with bacon, tomato, melted cheddar, sour cream & scallions. Big enough to share!
$17.85
Nova Latkes*
Crispy mini potato pancakes topped with sliced smoked salmon & sour cream. Finished with arugula, diced red onion & capers
$13.80
Roasted Wings
Oven Roasted to perfection. Served with Carrots, Celery and your choice of Ranch, Blue Cheese. Buffalo Sauce, Garlic Parmesan or Thai Chili Sauce served on the side.
$18.40+
Chicken Tender Basket
$12.65
Smoked Whitefish Dip
Smoked whitefish dip served with housemade bagel chips and vegetables. Don't forget the hot sauce.
$19.00
Scratch Soups
Matzo Ball Soup
Our light and fluffy matzo balls in a rich chicken broth with carrots and onions.
$7.85+
Chicken Noodle Soup
Loaded with chicken & vegetables - Only Bubbe makes it as good!
$6.90+
French Onion Soup
Topped with a thick layer of Provolone & Parmesan
$9.20+
Hand Tossed Salads
Your choice of dressing: Ranch, Blue Cheese, Caesar, Honey Mustard, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Russian, Lite Italian and Oil and Vinegar
Strawberry Citrus
Fresh lettuce blend tossed with raspberry vinaigrette, topped with mandarin oranges, fresh strawberries, red grapes, Gorgonzola & toasted almonds
$16.45
Toojay's Chopped
Turkey, ham, hard boiled egg, black olives red onions, crisp greens & garden vegetables tossed with choice of dressing, topped with Gorgonzola, crumbled bacon & artichoke hearts.
$18.40
Toojay's Cobb
Fresh lettuce blend diced chicken breast, ham, red onions, crumbled bacon, tomatoes, hard boiled eggs & cheddar.
$19.10
Crispy Chicken Salad
Crispy fried chicken tenders atop fresh fresh lettuce blend and garden vegetables. Served with your choice of dressing on the side.
Try it Buffalo or Nashville Hot style.
$16.10
Traditional Caesar Salad
Fresh romaine tossed with our own Caesar dressing with croutons and parmesan cheese.
$14.95
Choose Too!
Choose your own TooJay's combo!
Cup of Soup & Half Hand Sliced or Salad Sandwich
Your Choice of Soup & Your Choice of Half Sandwich. Served with cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$16.90
Cup of Soup & Café-Sized Hand Tossed Salad
Your Choice of Soup & Your Choice of Salad.
$16.10
Deli Sandwiches
Served with coleslaw & a dill pickle on choice of freshly baked Artisan Rye, Wheat, Challah, Wrap, or Brioche Bun
Hot Pastrami
Seasoned, cured & piled sky high. Served with cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$17.25
Hot Corned Beef
Hand trimmed and steamed to bring out the full flavor. Served with cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$16.70
Turkey Breast
All natural, whole breast turkey, hand sliced to order. Served with cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$17.05
Turkey BLT
All natural, whole breast turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato hand sliced to order. Served with cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$20.45
Turkey Avocado
Slow roasted turkey breast, fresh avocado, arugula, tomato and lemon garlic aioli. Served with cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$20.00
Roast Beef
Tender slices of rare roast beef lightly seasoned to perfection. Served with cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$17.15
Beef Brisket
Juicy braised brisket, sliced lean and served hot. Served with cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$17.85
Beef Salami
Hand trimmed & steamed to bring out the full flavor
$17.15
Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap
Grilled chicken breast, fresh romaine and creamy Caesar dressing. Served with cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$16.10
Deli Classics
Deli Tower
3 Deli meats and 2 cheeses of your choice accompanied with lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers and fresh baked bread.
$36.80+
The 6 LB Mighty Jay
(Feeds 8-12 People) A piled high, 6 pound sandwich containing layers of turkey, roast beef, corned beef, Swiss, coleslaw, lettuce and tomatoes. Served with cole slaw, potato salad and pickles.
$97.75
Triple J
Corned beef, roast beef, turkey and Swiss cheese rolled with Cole slaw and homestyle Russian dressing. Served with cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$17.95
Toojay's Classic
Corned beef and pastrami. A bit of heaven. Served with cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$17.95
Combo Deli Platter
Choice of any 3 fresh sliced meats served on a bed of lettuce with cole slaw, potato salad, pickle and Artisan rye bread.
$20.25
Reuben
Our classic hot corned beef, sauerkraut & Swiss with homestyle Russian dressing on grilled Artisan rye. Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$19.10
Turkey Reuben
Our classic turkey, sauerkraut & Swiss with homestyle Russian dressing on grilled Artisan rye. Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$19.10
Rachel 2.0
Our classic hot pastrami, now with, creamy coleslaw & Swiss with homestyle Russian dressing on grilled Artisan rye. Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$19.10
Turkey Rachel 2.0
Our classic turkey, now with, creamy coleslaw & Swiss with homestyle Russian dressing on grilled Artisan rye. Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$19.10
Beef Brisket Dip
Lean brisket, caramelized onions and provolone, baked in a French bread loaf with horseradish sauce and French onion au jus for dipping. Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$21.50
Classic Salads & Sandwiches
Classic Deli Salad Sandwich
Served on a fresh baked Artisan Rye, Wheat, Challah, Wrap or Brioche Bun. Served with coleslaw & a dill pickle.
$14.40+
Classic Deli Salad Platter
Your choice of deli salad served on a bed of crisp lettuce with fresh vegetables & Artisan rye bread.
$14.95+
T.J.'s Trio Platter
Choose three - Dill Chicken, Traditional Chicken, Tuna, Shrimp, or Egg Salad.
$19.00
Stuffed Tomato
A vine ripe tomato filled with your choice of Dill Chicken, Traditional Chicken, Tuna, Shrimp or Egg Salad.
$17.85
Hot Handhelds & Burgers
Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
Open Faced Tuna Melt
All white albacore tuna on Artisan rye with tomato, home style Russian dressing & melted Muenster.
Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$19.90
Grilled Cheese
Choose your favorite cheese and we’ll grill it on your choice of bread. Also available with bacon and tomato.
Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$14.75
Philly Grilled Cheese
Thinly sliced roast beef, green & red peppers, onions, American & Provolone on grilled challah.
Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$17.25
Cuban Grilled Cheese
Our version of the South Florida classic! Ham, corned beef, dill pickles, yellow mustard, Swiss on grilled challah. Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$19.00
Monterey Chicken Sandwich
Marinated chicken breast with avocado, tomato, Swiss cheese, arugula, and lemon garlic aioli.
Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$18.05
Chicken Tender Dinner
Original, Buffalo, or Nashville Hot Style
Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$20.15
Deli Dogs
Two all-beef franks grilled to perfection, with your choice of toppings. Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$13.60
Hot Ham & Swiss
Ham & Swiss on grilled Artisan rye bread with a side of honey mustard. Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$16.70
Classic BLT
Stacked with five slices of smokehouse bacon & served on toasted Challah. Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
Make it an ultimate by upgrading to a pound of bacon!
$14.85
Patty Melt*
Grilled burger topped with chipotle mayonnaise, caramelized onions & Swiss on grilled Artisan rye. Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
*Substitute with a black bean burger for no additional cost.
$15.75
Build Your Own Burger
All burgers are served on a brioche bun. Includes choice of cheese & one sauce.
Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$16.00
Pastrami Burger
Juicy sirloin rolled in our pastrami rub, topped with tender pastrami, caramelized onions, Swiss & chipotle mayonnaise. Served with French fries and a dill pickle.
$20.15
Anytime Breakfast
All day items come with French fries after 11am on weekdays and after 2pm on weekends, if applicable.
Create Your Own Omelet
Your choice of meat, veggies and cheese. Served with your choice of bread and side.
$15.90
The NEO Scramble* (Nova, Eggs, & Onion)
Nova Salmon, diced onion & a hint of cream cheese folded into a delicious scramble, topped with Everything Bagel seasoning. Served with your choice of bread and side.
*Nova Salmon is cured cold smoked fish that is uncooked.
$20.70
Nova Salmon Platter
Slow smoked Nova Salmon on a bed of lettuce
$23.80
California Fruit Salad
Fresh cantaloupe, honeydew, pineapple, red grapes, strawberries & raisins, served with vanilla yogurt & topped with toasted almonds.
$14.95
Nova on a Bagel*
Freshly sliced smoked salmon served on a bagel with cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion. Served with fresh fruit.
*Nova Salmon is cured cold smoked fish that is uncooked.
$19.35
T.J.’s Ultimate Omelet
Three eggs, smokehouse bacon, country style sausage, smoked ham, onions, mushrooms, peppers, potatoes and choice of cheese. Served with your choice of bread and side.
$17.25
Nova Tower
Thinly sliced Nova Salmon with Capers, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onion, Cucumbers, Cream Cheese, Bagel Chips and Bagels of Choice.
$44.85+
Pastrami & Swiss Omelet
Three eggs, Pastrami, & Swiss.
$16.70
Classic Comforts
All dinners come with House or Caesar Salad, or cup of soup
Toojay's Shepherd's Pie
Ground beef, tender vegetables topped with mashed potatoes & melted Muenster. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$20.60
Grilled Chopped Sirloin
Grilled to order, topped with caramelized onions & mushroom demi-glace with mashed potatoes & a fresh vegetable. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$24.15
Stuffed Cabbage Dinner
Tender cabbage leaves stuffed with ground beef & rice, topped with sweet & sour sauce. Served with a fresh vegetable and your choice of soup or salad.
$24.15
Liver and Onions
Grilled to order, topped with caramelized onions & mushroom demi-glace, with mashed potatoes & a fresh vegetable. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$20.70
Beef Brisket Platter
Lean, tender brisket & crisp potato pancakes topped with mushroom demi-glace, served with a fresh vegetable and your choice of soup or salad.
$26.45
Country Fried Steak
Homestyle Country Fried Steak & mashed potatoes topped with country gravy & served with a fresh vegetable and your choice of soup or salad.
$21.30
Traditional Turkey Dinner
Tender oven roasted turkey, mashed potatoes & cornbread stuffing, topped with our turkey gravy. Served with a fresh vegetable, cranberry sauce and your choice of soup or salad.
$25.20
Atlantic Salmon with Dill Hollandaise Sauce
Salmon baked with our dill butter & topped with a silky dill Hollandaise, with mashed potatoes & a fresh vegetable. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$28.20
Everything Salmon
Everything Bagel Seasoning crusted salmon served with potato pancakes, a fresh vegetable and your choice of soup or salad.
$28.20
Fish & Chips
Two Atlantic Cod fillets lightly battered & flash fried, served with french fries, coleslaw, tartar sauce and your choice of soup or salad.
$21.30
Chicken Capri
Sautéed with mushrooms, artichoke hearts & capers in a lemon butter white wine sauce. Served with mashed potatoes, a fresh vegetable and your choice of soup or salad.
$25.75
Garlic Chicken Pasta
Sautéed with broccoli and sweet red peppers tossed with penne pasta in a creamy garlic sauce. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$20.50
Chicken Tender Dinner
Original, Buffalo, or Nashville Hot Style.
Served with French fries, Cole slaw and a dill pickle.
$20.15
Meat Lasagna
Fresh ground beef and ricotta cheese baked with layers of pasta, plenty of mozzarella and topped with provolone and parmesan.