Tobies Pizzeria Menu

2424 W New Orleans St, Broken Arrow, OK 74011
  • 10" Pizzas

    • Cheesy Chuckles (10)

      5 Cheese Blend
      $16.38
    • Mother Load (10)

      Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Salami, Canadian Bacon,\r\nItalian Sausage, Black Olives, Green olives, Green\r\nPeppers, Onions, Jalapenos
      $25.07
    • Pickle My Fancy (10)

      Bacon, Dill Pickles, Fried Pickles, Drizzled With\r\nRanch
      $23.61
    • Home Wrecker (10)

      Re-Fried Beans, Beef, Salsa, Topped with Onions,\r\nCheddar Cheese, Lettuce & Tomatoes
      $22.29
    • Spicy Supreme (10)

      Pepperoni, Jalapeños, Sausage, Green Peppers,\r\nBlack Olives, Onions
      $21.11
    • Garden Party (10)

      Fresh tomatoes, spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, and onions on a 10" pizza crust with classic marinara sauce and melted cheese.
      $17.48
    • Beast Feast (10)

      Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Ham, Sausage,\r\nItalian Sausage, Beef
      $24.14
    • Wanna Bet (10)

      Ghost Pepper Cheese, Canadian Bacon, Sriracha\r\nSausage, Jalapenos
      $22.43
    • Crazy Lady (10)

      Balsamic Glaze Sauce, Garlic Roasted Tomatoes,\r\nBasil, Drizzled With Balsamic Glaze
      $17.15
    • Backyard Burger (10)

      Mustard Sauce, Beef, Bacon Crumbles, onions
      $20.97
    • Aloha Ha Ha (10)

      Canadian Bacon, Ham, Pineapple Chunks,\r\nMandarin Oranges
      $21.11
    • American Pie (10)

      Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Sausage, Green Peppers,\r\nOnions
      $21.11
    • Mother Clucker (10)

      BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Bacon Crumbles, Onions,\r\nDrizzled With BBQ Sauce
      $22.03
    • Pep-Pep Hooray (10)

      Three types of pepperoni provide a rich, meaty flavor.
      $17.48
    • 10" BYO Pizza

      Build-your-own 10" pizza. Choice of sauce, cheese, and topping. Sauces: Alfredo, Balsamic Glaze, BBQ, Garlic Butter, Marinara, Tobie’s, Creamy Italian. Cheeses: Cheddar, Five Blend, Ghost Pepper, Mozzarella. Toppings range from meats to vegetables.
      $19.65
  • 12" Pizzas

    • Cheesy Chuckles (12)

      5 Cheese Blend
      $18.36
    • Mother Load (12)

      Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Salami, Canadian Bacon,\r\nItalian Sausage, Black Olives, Green olives, Green\r\nPeppers, Onions, Jalapenos
      $28.37
    • Pickle My Fancy (12)

      Bacon, Dill Pickles, Fried Pickles, Drizzled With\r\nRanch
      $26.25
    • Home Wrecker (12)

      Re-Fried Beans, Beef, Salsa, Topped with Onions,\r\nCheddar Cheese, Lettuce & Tomatoes
      $24.67
    • Spicy Supreme (12)

      Pepperoni, Jalapeños, Sausage, Green Peppers,\r\nBlack Olives, Onions
      $24.67
    • Garden Party (12)

      Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions, Black Olives,\r\nBanana Peppers
      $19.35
    • Beast Feast (12)

      Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Ham, Sausage,\r\nItalian Sausage, Beef
      $26.39
    • Wanna Bet (12)

      Ghost Pepper Cheese, Canadian Bacon, Sriracha\r\nSausage, Jalapenos
      $25.07
    • Crazy Lady (12)

      Balsamic Glaze Sauce, Garlic Roasted Tomatoes,\r\nBasil, Drizzled With Balsamic Glaze
      $19.02
    • Backyard Burger (12)

      Mustard Sauce, Beef, Bacon Crumbles, onions
      $24.93
    • Aloha Ha Ha (12)

      Canadian Bacon, Ham, Pineapple Chunks,\r\nMandarin Oranges
      $23.75
    • American Pie (12)

      Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Sausage, Green Peppers,\r\nOnions
      $24.67
    • Mother Clucker (12)

      BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Bacon Crumbles, Onions,\r\nDrizzled With BBQ Sauce
      $24.41
    • Pep-Pep Hooray (12)

      Covered in 3 Different Types of Pepperoni
      $23.61
    • 12" BYO Pizza

      Build your own 12" pizza. Select from an array of sauces like Alfredo, BBQ, or no sauce. Choose cheese options including Cheddar or Mozzarella. Add one topping from choices like Anchovies, Bacon, or Pineapple.
      $22.29
  • 14" Pizzas

    • Cheesy Chuckles (14)

      5 Cheese Blend
      $20.78
    • Mother Load (14)

      Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Salami, Canadian Bacon,\r\nItalian Sausage, Black Olives, Green olives, Green\r\nPeppers, Onions, Jalapenos
      $31.67
    • Pickle My Fancy (14)

      Bacon, Dill Pickles, Fried Pickles, Drizzled With\r\nRanch
      $28.76
    • Home Wrecker (14)

      Re-Fried Beans, Beef, Salsa, Topped with Onions,\r\nCheddar Cheese, Lettuce & Tomatoes
      $26.78
    • Spicy Supreme (14)

      Pepperoni, Jalapeños, Sausage, Green Peppers,\r\nBlack Olives, Onions
      $26.78
    • Garden Party (14)

      Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions, Black Olives,\r\nBanana Peppers
      $21.99
    • Beast Feast (14)

      Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Ham, Sausage,\r\nItalian Sausage, Beef
      $29.95
    • Wanna Bet (14)

      Ghost Pepper Cheese, Canadian Bacon, Sriracha\r\nSausage, Jalapenos
      $29.03
    • Crazy Lady (14)

      Balsamic Glaze Sauce, Garlic Roasted Tomatoes,\r\nBasil, Drizzled With Balsamic Glaze
      $21.22
    • Backyard Burger (14)

      Mustard Sauce, Beef, Bacon Crumbles, onions
      $26.65
    • Aloha Ha Ha (14)

      Canadian Bacon, Ham, Pineapple Chunks,\r\nMandarin Oranges
      $26.39
    • American Pie (14)

      Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Sausage, Green Peppers,\r\nOnions
      $26.78
    • Mother Clucker (14)

      BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Bacon Crumbles, Onions,\r\nDrizzled With BBQ Sauce
      $26.78
    • Pep-Pep Hooray (14)

      Covered in 3 Different Types of Pepperoni
      $26.25
    • 14" BYO Pizza (14)

      14" Build Your Own Pizza \nChoice of one sauce, including Alfredo, BBQ, and others. Choose one cheese like Mozzarella or Cheddar. Select one topping from options like Pepperoni, Mushrooms, or Bacon.
      $24.93
  • 10" Gluten Free Crust

    • Cheesy Chuckles (10)

      5 Cheese Blend
      $16.38
    • Mother Load (10)

      Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Salami, Canadian Bacon,\r\nItalian Sausage, Black Olives, Green olives, Green\r\nPeppers, Onions, Jalapenos
      $20.89
    • Pickle My Fancy (10)

      Bacon, Dill Pickles, Fried Pickles, Drizzled With\r\nRanch
      $19.68
    • Home Wrecker (10)

      Re-Fried Beans, Beef, Salsa, Topped with Onions,\r\nCheddar Cheese, Lettuce & Tomatoes
      $18.58
    • Spicy Supreme (10)

      Pepperoni, Jalapeños, Sausage, Green Peppers,\r\nBlack Olives, Onions
      $17.59
    • Garden Party (10)

      Fresh vegetables like bell peppers, onions, tomatoes, spinach, and mushrooms on a 10" gluten-free pizza crust.
      $17.48
    • Beast Feast (10)

      Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Ham, Sausage,\r\nItalian Sausage, Beef
      $20.12
    • Wanna Bet (10)

      Ghost Pepper Cheese, Canadian Bacon, Sriracha\r\nSausage, Jalapenos
      $18.69
    • Crazy Lady (10)

      Balsamic Glaze Sauce, Garlic Roasted Tomatoes,\r\nBasil, Drizzled With Balsamic Glaze
      $17.15
    • Backyard Burger (10)

      Mustard Sauce, Beef, Bacon Crumbles, onions
      $17.48
    • Aloha Ha Ha (10)

      Canadian Bacon, Ham, Pineapple Chunks,\r\nMandarin Oranges
      $17.59
    • American Pie (10)

      Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Sausage, Green Peppers,\r\nOnions
      $17.59
    • Mother Clucker (10)

      BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Bacon Crumbles, Onions,\r\nDrizzled With BBQ Sauce
      $18.36
    • Pep-Pep Hooray (10)

      Covered in 3 Different Types of Pepperoni
      $17.48
    • 10" BYO Pizza Gluten Free

      Build-your-own 10" gluten-free pizza with options for sauce, cheese, and toppings. Choices include a variety of sauces, cheeses, and numerous toppings like meats, vegetables, and more. Customizable to your preference.
      $19.65
  • 14" Gluten Free Crust

    • Cheesy Chuckles (14)

      5 Cheese Blend
      $20.78
    • Mother Load (14)

      Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Salami, Canadian Bacon,\r\nItalian Sausage, Black Olives, Green olives, Green\r\nPeppers, Onions, Jalapenos
      $26.39
    • Pickle My Fancy (14)

      Bacon, Dill Pickles, Fried Pickles, Drizzled With\r\nRanch
      $23.97
    • Home Wrecker (14)

      Re-Fried Beans, Beef, Salsa, Topped with Onions,\r\nCheddar Cheese, Lettuce & Tomatoes
      $22.32
    • Spicy Supreme (14)

      Pepperoni, Jalapeños, Sausage, Green Peppers,\r\nBlack Olives, Onions
      $22.32
    • Garden Party (14)

      Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions, Black Olives,\r\nBanana Peppers
      $21.99
    • Beast Feast (14)

      Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Ham, Sausage,\r\nItalian Sausage, Beef
      $24.96
    • Wanna Bet (14)

      Ghost Pepper Cheese, Canadian Bacon, Sriracha\r\nSausage, Jalapenos
      $24.19
    • Crazy Lady (14)

      Balsamic Glaze Sauce, Garlic Roasted Tomatoes,\r\nBasil, Drizzled With Balsamic Glaze
      $21.22
    • Backyard Burger (14)

      Mustard Sauce, Beef, Bacon Crumbles, onions
      $22.21
    • Aloha Ha Ha (14)

      Canadian Bacon, Ham, Pineapple Chunks,\r\nMandarin Oranges
      $21.99
    • American Pie (14)

      Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Sausage, Green Peppers,\r\nOnions
      $22.32
    • Mother Clucker (14)

      BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Bacon Crumbles, Onions,\r\nDrizzled With BBQ Sauce
      $22.32
    • Pep-Pep Hooray (14)

      Covered in 3 Different Types of Pepperoni
      $21.88
    • 14" BYO Gluten Free Pizza

      Build your own 14" gluten-free pizza. Choose from varied sauces like Alfredo or BBQ, cheeses like Cheddar or Mozzarella, and toppings including Anchovies, Artichoke Hearts, and Bacon.
      $24.93
  • Appetizers

    • Fried Pickles

      Half Pound of Battered Fried Pickles to a Crisp Perfection
      $12.66
    • Cheese Bread

      Gooey Goodness of 5 cheese blend and garlic butter.
      $11.87
    • Parmesan Bites

      Garlic Butter Glazed Parmesan Seasoned Bites
      $11.47
    • Fried Mushrooms

      Half Pound of Battered Shrooms Fried to Perfection
      $12.66
    • Fresh Potato Chips

      Thin Chips Fried Crispy, Sea Salted & Served With a Side of Home made\r\nFrench Onion Dip
      $10.41
    • Wisconsin Cheese Curds

      Half pound of Cheese Curds
      $12.79
    • Fried Green Beans

      What else can be said\r\nHalf Pound Portion
      $12.66
    • Everything Garlic Bread

      Loaf of Bread Covered in Our Garlic Butter and Topped with our Everything\r\nBagel Mix
      $8.04
    • Bread Sticks (4)

      Covered in Garlic Butter
      $6.45
    • Mozzarella Half Moons (4)

      Herb Battered Mozz Fried and Drizzled with Balsamic Glaze & Fresh Basil
      $11.87
    • Fried Ravioli

      Deep Fried Nacho Cheese filled Ravioli
      $9.23
    • Fries

      Crinkle cut Fries\r\nMake Them Loaded +$3.00 (Bacon, Cheese, Jalapeños, & a drizzle of ranch)
      $10.41
    • Tater Kegs

      Five Giant tots stuffed with your choice of\r\nloaded potato or jalapeño.
      $10.41
    • Crab Tater Kegs

      Five Large Tater Tots stuffed with Crab, Cheese, and Scallions.
      $12.74
    • Pretzel Bites W/ Cheese

      Baked Pretzel bites, salted with a side of cheddar cheese sauce. (10)
      $10.55
    • Mozzarella Sticks (6)

      Golden, crispy mozzarella sticks served with a side of marinara sauce.
      $11.87
    • Meatballs (6)

      Beef and pork meatballs typically served with marinara sauce and parmesan cheese.
      $9.23
    • Jalapeno Tater Kegs

      Jumbo tater tots stuffed with jalapenos, cheddar cheese, and bacon.
      $10.41
  • Salads

    • Citrus Salad

      Crisp Lettuce, Diced Ham, Bacon, Mandarin Oranges, & Mozzarella Cheese\nChoice of Dressing
      $14.37
    • Club Salad

      Crisp Lettuce, Bacon, Cheddar, Tomatoes, Onions, Black Olives, Croutons & Your Choice of Chicken, Ham or Turkey
      $15.30
    • Italian Salad

      Crisp Lettuce, Ham, Turkey, Pepperoni, Salami, Cheddar, Tomatoes, Onions, Black Olives, Green Olives, Banana Peppers, & Croutons
      $18.33
    • Sidekick Salad

      Crisp Lettuce, Tomatoes, Black Olives, Croutons, & Cheddar Cheese
      $5.27
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad

      Crisp Lettuce, Chicken Breast, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Mozzarella Cheese, Croutons, Tomatoes & House-Made Ranch Dressing
      $15.69
  • Sandwiches

    • Classic Italian Sub

      Ham, Salami, Cheese, \r\nLettuce, Tomato, Onion\r\nChoice of Dressing- Creamy Italian if Not Specified
      $14.24
    • Turkey Breast & Cheese

      Turkey & Cheese\nLettuce, Tomato, Onion\nChoice of Dressing- Creamy Italian if Not Specified\n
      $13.05
    • Ham & Cheese

      Honey Baked Ham &Cheese\nLettuce, Tomato, Onion\nChoice of Dressing- Creamy Italian if Not Specified
      $13.05
    • Chicken Breast & Cheese

      Chicken, Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion Choice of\nDressing\nLettuce
      $13.58
    • Meatball Sub

      Meatballs & Cheese\nSmothered in Marinara
      $13.19
    • The Tobester

      Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone & Cheese, \nCreamy Italian, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, & Pickles
      $13.58
    • Hokey Pokey Hoagie

      LIMITED QUANITY DAILY\r\nRoast Beef, Provolone\r\nCheese, & Italian Giardiniera Relish\r\n Served Warm With Au Jus
      $16.49
  • Pasta

    • Spaghetti

      Noodles & Red Sauce\r\n\r\nPASTA SERVED WITH A SIDEKICK\r\nSALAD & GARLIC BREAD STICKS
      $11.60
    • Fettuccine Alfredo

      Tossed in Creamy Alfredo Sauce Served\r\non a Bed of Fettuccine Topped with\r\nFresh Parmesan\r\nPASTA SERVED WITH A SIDEKICK\r\nSALAD & GARLIC BREAD STICKS
      $15.69
    • Lasagna

      Limited quantity, layered lasagna\r\npasta with ricotta cheese, beef, pork\r\nsausage, Italian sausage, and\r\nmozzarella cheese.\r\nPASTA SERVED WITH A SIDEKICK\r\nSALAD & GARLIC BREAD STICKS
      $17.41
  • Sweets

    • Cinnamon Bites

      Cinnamon roll bites typically include dough coated with cinnamon and sugar, topped with vanilla icing.
      $7.91
    • Cake Donut Holes W/ Cinnamon & Sugar

      Cake donut holes typically tossed in a cinnamon and sugar mixture.
      $8.30
    • Funnel Cake Fries

      Crispy, golden funnel cake sticks, dusted with powdered sugar, perfect for dipping
      $9.89
    • Bavarian Cream Pizza

      A pizza base topped with bavarian cream, typically garnished with fresh fruits and a light dusting of powdered sugar.
      $17.01
    • Chocolate Chip Pizza

      Sweet Pie and Chocolate Chips
      $18.33
    • Cherry Pizza

      Tender, flaky crust filled with tart cherries, typically topped with a crumbly dutch crunch.
      $18.33
    • Apple Pie Pizza

      Crispy cinnamon flour tortilla topped with warm maple rum apples, walnut sprinkle, blueberries, and cinnamon basil ice cream.
      $18.33
    • S'Mores Pizza

      Chocolate, marshmallows, and graham cracker crumbs on a pizza crust.
      $18.33
    • Oreo Pizza

      A sweet pizza crust topped with crushed Oreo cookies, chocolate sauce, and a dusting of powdered sugar.
      $18.33
  • Wings

    • Traditional 1/2 Pound

      Half-pound of chicken wings with sauce options: Buffalo, BBQ, sweet chili, garlic honey, teriyaki, and more.
      $12.92
    • Traditional 1 Pound

      One pound of chicken wings. Choice of sauce: Buffalo, BBQ, Sweet Chili, Garlic Parmesan, Honey BBQ, Mango Habanero, or Teriyaki. Options for other sauces or no sauce available.
      $19.65
    • Boneless 1/2 Pound

      Half-pound boneless chicken wings. Choice of sauces: Buffalo, BBQ, Sweet Chili, Garlic Parmesan, Teriyaki, and more. Option for sauce on the side or no sauce.
      $14.51
    • Boneless 1 Pound

      1 pound of chicken wings. Choose from a variety of sauces including Buffalo, BBQ, Sweet Chili, Garlic Parmesan, Mango Habanero, Teriyaki, and more.
      $20.71
  • N/A Bevs

    • 2 Liter Pepsi

      Refreshing 2-Liter Pepsi: Crisp, Effervescent Classic Cola
      $5.27
    • 2 Liter Dr Pepper

      A 2-liter bottle of Dr Pepper, known for its unique blend of 23 flavors.
      $5.27
    • 2 Liter Sierra Mist

      A sparkling lemon-lime soda that typically offers a crisp and refreshing citrus flavor, perfect for quenching your thirst.
      $5.27
    • 2 Liter Mountain Dew

      2-liter bottle of Mountain Dew, a citrus-flavored soda known for its refreshing and bubbly taste.
      $5.27
    • 2 Liter Diet Dr Pepper

      A 2-liter bottle of Diet Dr Pepper, offering the same blend of 23 flavors as the original, without the calories.
      $5.27
    • 2 Liter Diet Pepsi

      A sugar-free, low-calorie cola with a crisp, refreshing taste, perfect for sharing or stocking up.
      $5.27
    • 2 Liter Orange Crush

      A large bottle of zesty orange soda, typically enjoyed for its refreshing citrus flavor.
      $5.27
    • Redbull

      Invigorating Energy Surge: The Classic Red Bull Experience
      $3.96
  • Sandwiches

    • Classic Italian Sub

      Ham, Salami, Cheese, \nLettuce, Tomato, Onion\nChoice of Dressing- Creamy Italian if Not Specified
      $14.24
    • Turkey Breast & Cheese

      Turkey & Cheese\nLettuce, Tomato, Onion\nChoice of Dressing- Creamy Italian if Not Specified\n
      $13.05
    • Ham & Cheese

      Honey Baked Ham &Cheese\nLettuce, Tomato, Onion\nChoice of Dressing- Creamy Italian if Not Specified
      $13.05
    • Chicken Breast & Cheese

      Chicken, Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion Choice of\nDressing\nLettuce
      $13.58
    • Meatball Sub

      Meatballs & Cheese\nSmothered in Marinara
      $13.19
  • Wraps

    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Crispy Fried Buffalo Chicken\r\nChunks, Lettuce, Cheddar\r\nCheese, Tomato, Bacon, In\r\nHouse Ranch
      $13.32
  • Sauce's

    • Ranch

      Made fresh in house.
      $1.44
    • Marinara

      Rich tomato sauce blended with garlic, onions, and herbs.
      $1.44
    • Blue Cheese

      Rich and creamy blue cheese sauce featuring tangy blue cheese crumbles blended into a smooth, velvety dressing.
      $1.44
    • Jalapeno Ranch

      Made fresh in house.
      $1.44
    • Fiery Honey

      A blend of sweet honey with a spicy kick.
      $1.44
    • Creamy Italian

      Rich and smooth Italian dressing with a blend of herbs and spices.
      $1.44
    • Honey Mustard

      Smooth blend of honey and mustard with a hint of spices.
      $1.44
    • Tobie's Sauce

      Made in house
      $1.44
    • French Onion Dip

      Made fresh in house.
      $1.44
    • Icing

      Smooth, sweet icing perfect for topping cakes, cookies, and pastries.
      $3.15
    • Cheese Sauce

      Rich and creamy blend of melted cheese, perfect for dipping or drizzling over your favorite dishes.
      $1.97

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms