Tipsy Mermaid Conch House & Cocktails Menu

4.0
(200+ Reviews)
  • Tonight's Special

    • Cobia Special

      $31.00
  • Oysters

    • Pink Moon

      $4.00
    • Oyster Rockefeller

      Classic Rockefeller with Bacon
      $5.00
      Oyster Rockefeller
    • Beau Soleil

      $4.00
  • Party Starters

    • 4 Wives of Hemingway Ceviche

      Ceviche with shrimp, conch, scallop, mahi. Mango sweet & habanero spicy. Gluten Free blue corn tortilla chips.
      $18.00
      4 Wives of Hemingway Ceviche
    • Bikini Lettuce Wraps

      Gulf shrimp & grilled pineapple salsa, island slaw, toasted coconut, pickled onions.
      $18.00
      Bikini Lettuce Wraps
    • Brie & Blue Flatbread

      Soft Brie cheese, grilled chicken, arugula, blueberry reduction
      $16.00
      Brie & Blue Flatbread
    • Buffalo Shrimp

      1/2 pound beer battered Gulf shrimp bites with Spicy Bird Pepper Buffalo sauce, Gorgonzola crème
      $18.00
      Buffalo Shrimp
    • Caprese Flatbread

      burrata cheese, nut free pesto, roasted tomatoes, Parmesan, Romano, Asiago cheeses, balsamic reduction
      $16.00
      Caprese Flatbread
    • Coconut Crack Conch

      A Caribbean delicacy, habanero guava dipping sauce with island slaw
      $18.00
      Coconut Crack Conch
    • Coconut Shrimp

      Island slaw, habanero guava marmalade dipping sauce
      $18.00
      Coconut Shrimp
    • Conch & Shrimp Fritters

      Habanero guava marmalade & key lime mustard
      $21.00
      Conch & Shrimp Fritters
    • Crispy Chicken Sliders

      3 crispy chicken sliders on Hawaiian slider rolls with bacon, ranch, crispy pickles, fried jalapeño with small Cuban black beans & rice
      $16.00
      Crispy Chicken Sliders
    • Cuban Cigars

      3 flour tortillas filled with Mojo pork, honey ham, Swiss cheese, crispy pickles, flash-fried with Key Lime mustard
      $16.00
      Cuban Cigars
    • Figgy Flatbread

      Caramelized onions, Gorgonzola, arugula, fig reduction
      $16.00
      Figgy Flatbread
    • Southernmost Smoked Fish Dip

      Cool & creamy smoked white fish & Gulf shrimp dip topped with pickled onions, red peppers, fried jalapeños, and Gluten Free blue corn tortilla chips
      $14.00
      Southernmost Smoked Fish Dip
    • Marky Mark

      Cuban bread crostini with Mojo steak, horseradish crème, scallions, and balsamic reduction
      $18.00
      Marky Mark
    • Meat Lover Flatbread

      Applewood smoked bacon, honey ham, peppercorn ranch, caramelized onions, white cheddar, arugula
      $16.00
      Meat Lover Flatbread
    • Medianoche Sliders

      3 Cubano sliders on Hawaiian rolls with Mojo pork, honey ham, crispy pickles, Swiss cheese, house mustards with Cuban black beans & rice
      $16.00
      Medianoche Sliders
    • Miss Key West Drunken Shrimp

      Beer steamed Key West Peel 'n Eat shrimp, tequila lime cocktail sauce, Cuban bread for dipping. Caught from the only shrimp boat in Key West's Marina, the 'Miss Key West'
      $18.00
      Miss Key West Drunken Shrimp
    • Off the Hook Pickles

      Beer battered, Key Lime mustard & secret Frita sauce
      $9.00
      Off the Hook Pickles
    • Steak Carpaccio

      Thinly sliced RARE steak, Parmesan, Romano & Asiago, fried capers, arugula, horseradish crème, and Truffle oil
      $16.00
      Steak Carpaccio
  • Salads & Chowder

    • Burrata Panzanella

      Cuban bread croutons, mixed greens, grape tomatoes, crushed pistachios, white balsamic dressing, creamy burrata cheese & balsamic reduction
      $16.00
      Burrata Panzanella
    • Caesar

      Chopped Romaine, creamy Caesars dressing, Parmesan, Romano & Asiago, Cuban bread croutons
      $11.00
      Caesar
    • Conch Chowder

      Key West style with conch, tomatoes, potatoes, and pork
      $10.00
      Conch Chowder
    • Hemingway House

      Chopped Romaine, fried avocado, red pepper, applewood smoked bacon, queso fresco, Cuban bread croutons, toasted coconut, and pineapple mojito dressing
      $14.00
      Hemingway House
    • Steak Salad

      Mixed greens, grape tomatoes, white balsamic dressing, Certified Angus Beef Mojo steak, gorgonzola, and shoestring potatoes
      $18.00
      Steak Salad
    • Wedge

      Iceberg wedge, grape tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, Gorgonzola, pickled onions, balsamic reduction, Gorgonzola dressing
      $12.00
      Wedge
  • Sandwiches & Tacos

    • Ana's Cubano Mix

      Mojo pork, honey ham, crispy pickles, Swiss cheese, house mustards, Cuban bread
      $18.00
      Ana's Cubano Mix
    • Cheeseburger in Paradise

      1/2 # burger, lettuce and tomato, pickles, Heinz 57 & crispy potato fries. Just the way Jimmy Buffett liked it.
      $18.00
      Cheeseburger in Paradise
    • Dockside BLT

      Blackened or beer battered mahi mahi, applewood smoked bacon, mixed greens, tomato, Key Lime tartar, grilled sourdough
      $22.00
      Dockside BLT
    • Frita Burger

      1/2 # burger, Swiss cheese, shoestring potatoes, secret Frita sauce, over easy egg, Brioche bun
      $18.00
      Frita Burger
    • Island Life Tacos

      Beer battered or sautéed Gulf shrimp, grilled pineapple salsa, island slaw, guacamole, pickled onions, sriracha honey, queso fresco, with Cuban black beans & rice, gluten free blue corn chips & salsa
      $21.00
      Island Life Tacos
    • Lazy Way Lane Mahi Mahi

      Blackened or beer battered mahi mahi, habanero guava marmalade, island slaw, guacamole, shoestring potatoes, and Brioche bun
      $22.00
      Lazy Way Lane Mahi Mahi
    • Mahi Mahi Reuben

      Blackened or beer battered mahi mahi, 1000 island slaw, Swiss cheese, horseradish crème, grilled sourdough
      $22.00
      Mahi Mahi Reuben
    • Papa's Steak Sandwich

      Mojo steak, sriracha honey, caramelized bacon & onions, fried jalapeños, shredded lettuce, horseradish crème, Cuban bread
      $28.00
      Papa's Steak Sandwich
    • Spicy Rooster

      Crispy chicken tossed in spicy Bird Pepper buffalo sauce, fried jalapeños, lettuce, Gorgonzola crème, crispy pickles, and Brioche bun
      $16.00
      Spicy Rooster
    • Surf 'N Turf Tacos

      2 soft flour tortillas with a layer of cheese filled with Certified Angus Beef steak tossed in chimichurri and blackened Gulf shrimp served with a side of Cuban black beans and rice with Gluten Free blue corn chips and salsa
      $23.00
      Surf 'N Turf Tacos
    • Truman Po' Boy

      Beer battered Gulf shrimp, Cajun remoulade, lettuce, tomatoes, crispy pickles, Cuban bread
      $18.00
      Truman Po' Boy
    • Chicken Caesar Wrap

      $18.00
  • Party Time

    • 305 Seafood Pasta

      Squid Ink pasta, Gulf shrimp, Bay scallops, fire-roasted tomatoes, burrata cheese, Parmesan, Romano & Asiago, white wine garlic pesto sauce
      $29.00
      305 Seafood Pasta
    • A Moveable Feast Bowl

      Cuban black beans & rice, Mojo pork, pickled onions, guacamole, mango & jicama escabeche, fried jalapeños, grilled pineapple salsa, queso fresco
      $19.00
      A Moveable Feast Bowl
    • Blackened Mahi Mahi

      Blackened mahi mahi served over carrot & fire roasted tomato purée, your choice of broccolini or grilled asparagus, nut free pesto & Heirloom tomatoes
      $31.00
      Blackened Mahi Mahi
    • Boca Gnocchi

      Norwegian Smoked Salmon, fire-roasted tomatoes, sautéed vegetables, fried capers, creamy lemon dill sauce
      $26.00
      Boca Gnocchi
    • Coconut Crusted Mahi Mahi

      Coconut Crusted mahi mahi topped with mango escabeche & served with Cuban black beans & rice
      $31.00
      Coconut Crusted Mahi Mahi
    • Coconut Curry Seafood

      Mahi mahi, Gulf shrimp, wild mix mushrooms, coconut rice, and red peppers topped with cilantro served with crostinis
      $28.00
      Coconut Curry Seafood
    • Fantasy Fest Filet 6oz

      6oz Certified Angus Beef filet over purple potato mash, asparagus or broccolini, crispy onion rings, and Gorgonzola cream
      $44.00
      Fantasy Fest Filet 6oz
    • Fish 'N Chips

      Beer battered Pacific Cod, Island slaw, key lime tartar sauce
      $28.00
      Fish 'N Chips
    • La Trattoria Gnocchi

      Decadent wild mixed mushrooms with Gorgonzola cream sauce
      $21.00
      La Trattoria Gnocchi
    • Mushroom & Truffle Ragu Pappardelle

      Wild mixed mushrooms in light white wine garlic sauce, Parmesan, Asiago, Ramano cheese and truffle oil
      $26.00
      Mushroom & Truffle Ragu Pappardelle
    • Seafood & Grits

      Gulf shrimp, Maine scallops, creamy Gruyère grits, bacon & wild mix mushrooms, Coconut Rum glaze or Southern Caribbean style
      $31.00
      Seafood & Grits
    • The Calvin Coolidge Steak & Frites

      Grilled & sliced 9 oz Certified Angus Beef Mojo center-cut Sirloin steak, chimichurri, crispy fries, Gruyère fondue, mini Caesar salad
      $31.00
      The Calvin Coolidge Steak & Frites
  • The After Party

    • Key Lime Pie

      House made graham cracker crust, sweet & tart pie topped with whip cream & toasted coconut & fresh strawberries
      $11.00
      Key Lime Pie
    • Piña Colada Bread Pudding

      House made bread pudding topped with Coconut Rum glaze, whipped cream & fresh strawberries, toasted coconut
      $11.00
      Piña Colada Bread Pudding
    • Whole Key Lime Pie

      PLEASE ALLOW 24 HOURS FOR PICK UP
      $80.00
      Whole Key Lime Pie
  • Chowder, Salads & Appetizers

    • 4 Wives of Hemingway Ceviche

      Ceviche with shrimp, conch, scallop, mahi. Mango sweet & habanero spicy. Gluten Free blue corn tortilla chips.
      $18.00
      4 Wives of Hemingway Ceviche
    • BAHAMA VILLAGE CONCH CHOWDER

      Key West style with conch, tomatoes, potatoes, pork
      $10.00
      BAHAMA VILLAGE CONCH CHOWDER
    • BRIE & BLUE FLATBREAD

      Soft Brie cheese, grilled chicken, arugula, blueberries, blueberry reduction
      $16.00
      BRIE & BLUE FLATBREAD
    • BURRATA PANZANELLA

      Cuban bread croutons, arugula, grape tomatoes, crushed pistachios tossed in white balsamic dressing, topped with creamy burrata cheese & balsamic reduction
      $15.00
      BURRATA PANZANELLA
    • CAPRESE FLATBREAD

      House made nut-free pesto, burrata cheese, roasted tomatoes, Parmesan, Romano & Asiago cheeses, balsamic reduction
      $15.00
      CAPRESE FLATBREAD
    • CAPTAIN TIM'S CONCH & SHRIMP FRITTERS

      Key West shrimp & Bahamian conch with habanero guava marmalade & Key Lime mustard
      $21.00
      CAPTAIN TIM'S CONCH & SHRIMP FRITTERS
    • Cuban Cigars

      3 flour tortillas filled with Mojo pork, honey ham, Swiss cheese, crispy pickles, flash-fried with Key Lime mustard
      $16.00
      Cuban Cigars
    • FIGGY FLATBREAD

      Caramelized onions, Gorgonzola cheese, arugula, fig reduction
      $15.00
      FIGGY FLATBREAD
    • Off the Hook Pickles

      Beer battered, Key Lime mustard & secret Frita sauce
      $9.00
      Off the Hook Pickles
    • HEMINGWAY HOUSE

      Chopped Romaine, fried avocado, red pepper, applewood smoked bacon, queso fresco, Cuban bread croutons, toasted coconut, pineapple mojito dressing
      $14.00
      HEMINGWAY HOUSE
    • LOUIE'S CEASAR

      Chopped Romaine, Caesar dressing, Parmesan, Romano & Asiago, Cuban bread croutons Make It BLT style- add applewood smoked bacon pieces & grape tomatoes $3 Calvin style- add Mojo steak & shoestring potatoes $12
      $11.00
      LOUIE'S CEASAR
    • Meat Lover Flatbread

      Applewood smoked bacon, honey ham, peppercorn ranch, caramelized onions, white cheddar, arugula
      $16.00
      Meat Lover Flatbread
    • MISS KEY WEST DRUNKEN SHRIMP

      Beer steamed Key West peel 'n eat shrimp, Tequila Lime cocktail sauce, Cuban bread for dipping. Caught from the ONLY shrimp boat in Key West's Marina, the "Miss Key West"
      $18.00
      MISS KEY WEST DRUNKEN SHRIMP
    • SOUTHERNMOST FISH DIP

      Cool & creamy smoked white fish & shrimp dip topped with pickled onions, red peppers, fried jalapeños. Served with Gluten Free blue corn tortilla chips
      $14.00
      SOUTHERNMOST FISH DIP
    • Steak Salad

      Mixed greens, grape tomatoes, white balsamic dressing, Certified Angus Beef Mojo steak, gorgonzola, and shoestring potatoes
      $18.00
      Steak Salad
    • Wedge

      Iceberg wedge, grape tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, Gorgonzola, pickled onions, balsamic reduction, Gorgonzola dressing
      $12.00
      Wedge
  • Brunchy

    • Avocado Toast

      Open-faced sour dough, guacamole, creamy burrata cheese, queso fresco, crushed pistachios, pickled onions, balsamic reduction, arugula salad
      $16.00
      Avocado Toast
    • B Cafe Steak & Eggs

      4 oz sliced Certified Angus Beef Mojo center cut Sirloin steak topped with 2 sunny side up eggs on Cuban bread crostinis, chimichurri, Pesto potatoes, and mushroom crème sauce
      $21.00
      B Cafe Steak & Eggs
    • Boca Bagel

      house-made dill schemer, Norwegian smoked salmon, fried capers, pickled onions, arugula, guacamole, arugula salad
      $14.00
      Boca Bagel
    • Chicken 'n Waffle

      Crispy chicken tenders, savory bacon waffle, sunny side up egg, candied bacon crumbles, blueberries Choice of: coconut rum glaze, mushroom gorgonzola crème or sriracha honey
      $16.00
      Chicken 'n Waffle
    • Fantasy Fest Bowl

      Pesto potatoes, white cheddar, your choice of egg, applewood smoked bacon crumbles, fried jalapeños, scallions, pickled onions, queso fresco, guacamole, fire roasted salsa. Also available as a wrap.
      $16.00
      Fantasy Fest Bowl
    • French Toast

      Hawaiian rolls stuffed with strawberry & guava cream cheese topped with whip cream, toasted coconut, coconut rum glaze
      $15.00
      French Toast
    • Shrimp & Grits

      parmesan & bacon grits, 3 large Gulf shrimp, pesto
      $16.00
      Shrimp & Grits
    • Ultimate Croque Madame

      Open-faced Cuban bread, house mustards, honey ham, applewood smoked bacon, white cheddar, Guyère fondue, sunny side up egg, arugula salad
      $17.00
      Ultimate Croque Madame
  • Crêpes

    • La Engelberg Crêpe

      Norwegian Smoked Salmon, dill cream cheese, fried capers, pickled onions, arugula salad
      $14.00
      La Engelberg Crêpe
    • La G-Foolio Crêpe

      Mojo steak, applewood smoked bacon, Mushroom & Gorgonzola crème, pickled onions, arugula salad
      $16.00
      La G-Foolio Crêpe
    • La Layton Crêpe

      Nutella meringue, strawberries, whip cream
      $11.00
      La Layton Crêpe
    • La Lenny Crêpe

      Strawberry guava cream cheese, strawberries, whip cream
      $10.00
      La Lenny Crêpe
    • La Li-Li Crêpe

      Powdered sugar, whip cream
      $8.00
      La Li-Li Crêpe
    • La Lynn-O Crêpe

      Ham, swiss, caramelized onions & mushrooms, gruyère fondue, arugula salad
      $14.00
      La Lynn-O Crêpe
    • La-Ti-Da Crêpe

      Thinly sliced Mojo steak, Brie cheese, caramelized onions, horseradish crème, arugula salad
      $16.00
      La-Ti-Da Crêpe
  • Hand Helds

    • Breakfast Club BLT

      Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, Key Lime tartar, fried or over easy egg, guacamole, crispy shoestring potatoes, sour dough, crispy fries
      $16.00
      Breakfast Club BLT
    • Hangover Tacos

      Pesto potatoes, applewood smoked bacon, fried eggs, sriracha honey, guacamole, pickled onions, queso fresco on 2 flour tortillas, side of Cuban black beans & rice, Gluten Free blue corn chips & salsa
      $18.00
      Hangover Tacos
    • Havana OHH-LA-LA

      Mojo pork, honey ham, applewood smoked bacon, fried egg, white cheddar, crispy shoestring potatoes, garlic cilantro aioli, Cuban bread, fries
      $16.00
      Havana OHH-LA-LA
    • Last Flight Out Caesar Wrap

      Blackened Key West shrimp, Romaine lettuce, cherry tomatoes, house made Caesar dressing, Cuban bread croutons, crispy fries
      $18.00
      Last Flight Out Caesar Wrap
    • Lost Boy Waffle Grilled Cheese

      Savory bacon waffle, white cheddar, applewood smoked bacon, tomatoes, guacamole, garlic cilantro aioli, crispy fries
      $14.00
      Lost Boy Waffle Grilled Cheese
    • Mahi Mahi Reuben

      Blackened or beer battered mahi mahi, 1000 island slaw, Swiss cheese, horseradish crème, grilled sourdough, crispy fries
      $22.00
      Mahi Mahi Reuben
    • Wrap Me Up, Papa

      Certified Angus Beef chimichurri steak, mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, red peppers, white balsamic
      $22.00
      Wrap Me Up, Papa
  • Steamed Bagels

    • Double Trouble on Duval Bagel

      Jalapeño schmear, Mojo steak, sautéed onions & mushrooms, fried egg, white cheddar, crispy shoestring potatoes. Served with a side of crispy pesto potatoes.
      $13.00
      Double Trouble on Duval Bagel
    • Hemingway's Bodega

      Jalapeño schmear, honey ham, white Cheddar, applewood smoked bacon, fried egg, sriracha honey. Served with side of pesto potatoes.
      $11.00
      Hemingway's Bodega
    • LGBT BAGEL

      Lettuce, guacamole, Bacon schmear, tomato, applewood smoked bacon, cilantro garlic aioli. Served with side of crispy pesto potatoes.
      $11.00
      LGBT BAGEL
    • Tipsy Jambon Bagel

      Brie cheese, honey ham, arugula, house mustard, served with pesto potatoes
      $11.00
      Tipsy Jambon Bagel
  • Breakfast Sides

    • Add 1 Egg

      $3.00
    • Bagel with cream cheese

      $6.00
    • Crostinis(4)

      $3.00
    • Cuban Black Beans & Rice

      $3.00
    • Fries

      $6.00
    • Fruit Cup

      $5.00
    • Grilled Chicken

      $8.00
    • Plain Bacon Waffle

      $5.00
    • Salt n Vinegar Fries

      $7.00
    • Side 4Pcs Applewood Smoked Bacon

      $6.00
    • Side Arugala Salad

      $6.00
    • Side Candied Bacon

      $5.00
    • Side Cesar Salad

      $6.00
    • Side Country Ham

      $6.00
    • Side Cream Cheese

      $2.00
    • Side Grilled Sourdough

      $2.00
    • Side Guacamole

      $3.50
    • Side Pesto Potatoes

      $5.00
    • Side Smoked Salmon

      $9.00
    • Side Two Eggs

      $6.00
    • Sliced Avocado

      $3.00
    • Truffle Fries

      $9.00
    • Side Parm Grits

      $6.00
  • Sweet Finishes

    • Key Lime Pie

      House made graham cracker crust, sweet & tart pie topped with whip cream & toasted coconut & fresh strawberries
      $11.00
      Key Lime Pie
    • Piña Colada Bread Pudding

      House made bread pudding topped with Coconut Rum glaze, whipped cream & fresh strawberries, toasted coconut
      $11.00
      Piña Colada Bread Pudding
    • Whole Key Lime Pie

      PLEASE ALLOW 24 HOURS FOR PICK UP
      $80.00
      Whole Key Lime Pie

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Speedy Cafe
Speedy Cafe
2.3
(3 Reviews)
Restaurant
Arby's
Arby's
4.0
(686 Reviews)
American, Deli, Sandwich shop
Philadelphia Steak & Fries
Philadelphia Steak & Fries
4.6
(1,268 Reviews)
Cheesesteak, Sandwich shop
Taco Bell
Taco Bell
3.1
(789 Reviews)
Breakfast, Burrito, Lunch
Squealers Award Winning Barbeque
Squealers Award Winning Barbeque
4.3
(1,731 Reviews)
Barbecue, Restaurant
GetGo Café + Market
GetGo Café + Market
2.1
(34 Reviews)
Cafe
Midday Deli & Catering
Midday Deli & Catering
4.7
(182 Reviews)
Sandwich shop
Traders Brewing Company
Traders Brewing Company
4.8
(125 Reviews)
Brewery
Otis Spunkmeyer Inc
Otis Spunkmeyer Inc
5.0
(2 Reviews)
Dessert shop
Harlan Bakeries
Harlan Bakeries
4.0
(4 Reviews)
Bakery

(317) 973-8795

135 S Main St, Zionsville, IN 46077


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms