Thirsty Pagan Brewing Menu

4.6
(1,150+ Reviews)
$Brewpub
  • Appetizers and Salads

    • TPB Bread #1 Original Cheese And Fresh Garlic (Vegetarian)

      Fresh garlic, mozzarella cheese & house blend of Italian spices sprinkled across the top, baked on a 10" pizza crust, served with scratch made red sauce for dipping!
    • TPB Bread #2 Margherita (Vegetarian)

      Fresh garlic base, fresh tomatoes, basil & mozzarella cheese baked on a 10" pizza crust!
    • TPB Bread #3 Artichoke, Spinach, And Cheese (Vegetarian)

      Fresh garlic base, artichoke hearts, spinach & mozzarella cheese baked on a 10" pizza crust!
    • Stuffed Mushrooms (Gluten-Free When Served Without Bread, Vegetarian)

      Mushroom caps filled with fresh garlic, parmesan, herbs & mozzarella cheese baked until bubbly. Served with a side of crispy baked bread.
    • Loaded Pretzel

      Our original pretzel cut into bite sized morsels covered in mozzarella, cheddar and bacon!
    • Reuben Rollups

      Our house pizza dough stretched out and stuffed with sauerkraut, corned beef, swiss cheese & scratch made 1000 island dressing. We then bake it to a golden brown and sprinkle caraway seeds on top. Served with even more scratch made 1000 island on the side!
    • Pretzel And Scratch Made Mustard (Vegetarian)

      We bake a large soft pretzel golden brown, salt it, and serve it with our scratch made mustard!
    • Bohemian Salad (Vegetarian)

      Fresh spring greens, red onions, red pepper, mushrooms, feta, sun-dried tomatoes, black olives & pepperoncini. Served with a side of one of our scratch made dressings: vinaigrette, dill pickle vinaigrette, or ranch. Served with a side of baked bread.Try it with Chicken!
    • Side Salad (Vegetarian)

      Spring Greens, tomatoes, red onions and cheddar. Served with a side of one of our scratch made dressings: vinaigrette, dill pickle vinaigrette, or ranch. Served with baked bread until 3PM.
  • Specialty Pizzas (All substitutions and half & half instructions are subject to a charge)

    • Derailed (Well Done Bake)

      Scratch made spicy beer sausage, pepperoni, salami, ham, black olives, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, spinach, garlic & pepperoncini.
    • TPB Special

      Scratch made spicy beer sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions & green peppers.
    • Garden Pizza (Vegetarian)

      Fresh garlic, mushrooms, onions, black olives, green peppers, spinach & pepperoncini.
    • Mediterranean Pizza (Vegetarian)

      Fresh garlic, feta, spinach & sun-dried tomatoes.
    • Chicken Alfredo Pizza

      Scratch made chicken Alfredo sauce, red peppers, broccoli, spinach, & roasted chicken.
    • Pizza Diane

      Scratch made spinach and basil pesto topped with chicken, feta cheese, tomato & spinach.
  • Build Your Own Pizza 10"/13"/16" (All substitutions and half & half instructions are subject to a charge)

    • Build Your Own Pizza 10"/13"/16"

      Ingredients: Scratch made spicy beer sausage • pepperoni • ham • bacon • salami • chicken • mushrooms - onions • green Peppers • red peppers • pepperoncini • jalapenos • black olives - green olives • kalamata olives • sun-dried tomatoes • tomatoes • spinach - broccoli • fresh garlic • pineapple • feta cheese • cheddar cheese
    • 6" Personal Pizza (Cheese & Sauce Included - Pick Any 3 Ingredients)

      Ingredients: scratch made spicy beer sausage • pepperoni • ham • bacon • salami • chicken • mushrooms - onions • green peppers • red peppers • pepperoncini • jalapenos • black olives - green olives • kalamata olives • sun-dried tomatoes • tomatoes • spinach - broccoli • fresh garlic • pineapple • Feta cheese • cheddar cheese
    • Calzone (Cheese & Sauce Included - Pick Any 3 Ingredients)

      Ingredients: Scratch made spicy beer sausage • pepperoni • ham • bacon • salami • chicken • mushrooms - onions • green peppers • red peppers • pepperoncini • jalapenos • black olives - green olives • kalamata olives • sun-dried tomatoes • tomatoes • spinach - broccoli • fresh garlic • pineapple • feta cheese • cheddar cheese
    • Cauliflower Crust Pizza (Cheese & Sauce Included - Pick Any 3 Ingredients) *Sauce Served On The Side

      Ingredients: scratch made spicy beer sausage • pepperoni • ham • bacon • salami • chicken • mushrooms - onions • green peppers • red peppers • pepperoncini • jalapenos • black olives - green olives • kalamata olives • sun-dried tomatoes • tomatoes • spinach - broccoli • fresh garlic • pineapple • feta cheese • cheddar cheese
  • Sides of scratch made sauce (Large/Small)

    • Sauce Sides

      Pizza Sauce • Ranch • Vinaigrette • Dill Pickle Vinaigrette • Mustard • Alfredo
  • Scratch made desserts

    • Cheesecake Bites Or Platter

      Ask for our current selection!
    • Burntwood Black Brownie

      A decadent, fudgy brownie made with our house brewed Burntwood Black.
    • Vanilla Ice Cream

      A big scoop of creamy vanilla ice cream.
  • House Beers & Seasonal Brews

    • North Coast Amber

      Traditional Amber Ale made with Munich and caramel malts. This amber is medium-bodied and has a sweet bready finish. ≈5.8% ABV 16 IBU
    • Derailed Ale

      This APA is brewed with Columbus, Glacier, and Cascade hops. The citrus notes from the hops balance out the malty sweetness. ≈5.6% ABV 31 IBU
    • Burntwood Black

      Brewed with seven varieties of malted barley, this brew has a subtle roasty-ness of chocolate & coffee. A well balanced beer suitable for anybody. ≈5.5% ABV 19 IBU
    • India Pagan Ale

      The Pagan version of a West Coast IPA. It brings loads of hop aroma and flavor as well as a smooth malt backbone.≈6.8% ABV 68 IBU
    • Lawn Chair

      This light ale is a sweet introductory beer to the microbrew industry. Easy to drink – Easy on the Eyes≈6.0% ABV 15 IBU
    • Seasonal Beers

      Ask about our current selection of seasonal brews!

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Havanas
Havanas
4.8
(200 Reviews)
Restaurant
Kostas Gyros
Kostas Gyros
4.7
(579 Reviews)
Gyro
How Sweet It Is Cakes
How Sweet It Is Cakes
4.7
(97 Reviews)
Dessert shop
Top Hat Tavern
Top Hat Tavern
4.3
(232 Reviews)
Bar
Bucktales Cantina & Grill
Bucktales Cantina & Grill
4.5
(322 Reviews)
Bar & grill, American, Family
Shortys Pizza & Smoked Meats
Shortys Pizza & Smoked Meats
4.1
(1,074 Reviews)
Restaurant, Bar & grill
Builder's Saloon
Builder's Saloon
4.1
(250 Reviews)
Bar
Spirit Room
Spirit Room
4.7
(318 Reviews)
Cocktail bar, Bar, Lounge
Wissota Chophouse - Superior/Duluth
Wissota Chophouse - Superior/Duluth
4.3
(162 Reviews)
Steak house
The Tap on Tower
The Tap on Tower
4.8
(37 Reviews)
Bar

(715) 394-2500

1615 Winter St, Superior, WI 54880


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms