Theo's Steaks & Seafood Menu

9144 Indianapolis Blvd, Highland, IN 46322
  • Deposits/Reservations

    • Deposit $100: 5-15people

      This deposit is for a 5-15 person reservation for our dining room. This deposit is non-refundable, and comes off bill at the end of your visit. At least 80% of party must show within 15 minutes of appointment or deposit is forfeited. One check per party. DO NOT MAKE PAYMENT UNTIL SPEAKING WITH THEO’S Host or Management. PLEASE PROVIDE INFORMATION BELOW: • Name • Phone Number • Date of Reservation • Time of Reservation • Number of People Attending Cancellation Refund Policy 7 Days Prior To Event Excluding Holidays
      $114.00
    • Deposit- $200: 25-30 People

      This is for a private party room for (a minimum of) 25 to (maximum) of 30 guests. Final count must be given 48 hours before event. If 80% of your guests are not present for the party you will Forfeit the Deposit. If not, we will go by the count given previously. One check per party. DO NOT MAKE PAYMENT UNTIL SPEAKING WITH THEO’S Host or Management. PLEASE PROVIDE INFORMATION BELOW: • Name • Phone Number • Date of Reservation • Time of Reservation • Number of People Attending Cancellation Refund Policy 7 Days Prior To Event Excluding Holidays
      $228.00
    • Deposit - $600 60-100 People

      This is for a private party room for (a minimum of) 60 to (maximum) of 100 guests. Final count must be given 48 hours before event. If 80% of your guests are not present for the party you will Forfeit the Deposit. If not, we will go by the count given previously. One check per party. DO NOT MAKE PAYMENT UNTIL SPEAKING WITH THEO’S Host or Management. PLEASE PROVIDE INFORMATION BELOW: • Name • Phone Number • Date of Reservation • Time of Reservation • Number of People Attending Cancellation Refund Policy 7 Days Prior To Event Excluding Holidays
      $684.00
    • Deposit- $400 40-60 People

      This is for a private party room for (a minimum of) 40 to (maximum) of 60 guests. Final count must be given 48 hours before event. If 80% of your guests are not present for the party you will Forfeit the Deposit. If not, we will go by the count given previously. One check per party. DO NOT MAKE PAYMENT UNTIL SPEAKING WITH THEO’S Host or Management. PLEASE PROVIDE INFORMATION BELOW: • Name • Phone Number • Date of Reservation • Time of Reservation • Number of People Attending Cancellation Refund Policy 7 Days Prior To Event Excluding Holidays
      $456.00
  • Dinner | Appetizers

    • Theos House Pretzel

      Served with our home made artesian beer cheese.
      $12.50
    • Shrimp Cocktail

      Colossal shrimp served chilled with our house cocktail sauce.
      $21.65
    • Calamari Fritto

      Served with our house cocktail sauce.
      $17.05
    • Crab Cakes

      Our award winning blend, topped with sauteed spinach, and a spicy remoulade sauce.
      $21.65
    • Saganaki (OPA!)

      Greek cheese pan fried and flamed table side with brandy.
      $15.95
    • Bruschetta

      Minced plum tomato, garlic, onions, fresh basil, tossed with EVOO. Served on a rustic Italian bread and drizzled with balsamic glaze.
      $13.65
    • Oyster Rockefellar (6)

      Chesapeake bay area oysters, served with spinach, bacon and dolloped with bechamel. Served on a rustic Italian bread and drizzled with balsamic glaze.
      $22.75
    • Raw Oysters (6)

      Freshly shucked oysters on the half shell.
      $20.50
    • Fried Shrimp

      Served with cocktail sauce.
      $21.65
    • Quart Of Lemon Rice Soup

      16 oz of our Award Winning Lemon Rice Soup
      $17.10
    • Shrimp Deghone

      $22.75
  • Dinner | Entree Salads

    • Greek Country Salad

      Romaine lettuce blend, Kalamata olives, green peppers, Feta cheese, cucumbers, onions, pepperoncini and Greek dressing. Note : Cannot be discounted.
      $17.05
    • Caesar Salad

      Romaine lettuce blend, Parmesan cheese, hard boiled eggs and croutons. Note : Cannot be discounted.
      $13.65
    • Wedge Salad

      Crisp wedge lettuce, topped with Blue cheese crumbles, tomato, onion, and chopped bacon. Served with Blue cheese dressing. Note : Cannot be discounted.
      $17.05
  • Dinner | USDA Prime Steaks

    • 18 Oz. Strip Steak

      18 oz. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $56.95
    • Center Cut Filet

      9 oz. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $52.40
    • Bone-In Ribeye

      26 oz. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $63.80
    • Porterhouse

      28 oz. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $68.35
    • Theo's Special Filet

      Filet topped with crabmeat, and our chef’s Bearnaise sauce. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $56.95
    • Surf & Turf

      9 oz. Center cut filet mignon and 12-14 oz. South African lobster tail. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $172.10
    • Rack Of Lamb

      Domestic lamb rack served lollipop style. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, house salad, and side.
      $54.70
    • BBQ Ribs

      Full slab meaty pork ribs, mopped with our signature smoked BBQ sauce. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, house salad, and side.
      $34.15
    • White Marble Farms Pork Chops

      Twin pork chops grilled to perfection. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, house salad, and side.
      $34.15
  • Dinner | Chicken

    • Chicken Piccata With Mushrooms

      Twin boneless chicken breasts, lightly floured and sauteed with mushrooms, capers, and Chablis wine. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad, and side.
      $30.75
    • Chicken Marsala With Mushrooms

      Twin boneless chicken breasts, lightly floured and sauteed with mushrooms and Marsala wine. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad, and side.
      $30.75
    • Mediterranean Chicken

      Twin boneless chicken breast lightly floured and topped with tomatoes, spinach, Kalamata olives, and Feta cheese. Served on a bed of marinara. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad, and side.
      $34.15
  • Dinner | Pasta

    • Fettuccine Pasta

      Served with Alfredo or marinara. Accompanied by soup or salad.
      $22.75
    • Lobster Ravioli

      Served with a creamy crabmeat sauce. Accompanied by soup or salad.
      $41.00
    • Shrimp & Scallops Alfredo

      Served with a creamy crabmeat sauce. Accompanied by soup or salad.
      $34.15
  • SIDES

    • Loaded Baked Potato

      $4.60
    • Baked Potato

      $3.45
    • French Fries

      $3.45
    • Grilled Asparagus

      $6.85
    • Grilled Vegetables

      $6.85
    • Loaded Mashed Potato

      $4.60
    • Mashed Potato

      $3.45
    • Oven Brown Potatoes

      $3.45
    • Vegetables

      $3.45
  • Dinner | Wild Caught Seafood

    • Alaskan King Crab Legs

      2 lb. split, ready to eat. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $212.00
    • Canadian Lake Perch

      Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $30.75
    • Double South African Lobster Tail

      2 12 -14 oz. tails. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $177.80
    • Scottish Salmon

      Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $33.05
    • Shrimp (Sea Of Cortez U10 Shrimp)

      Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $34.15
    • South African Lobster Tail

      12 - 14 oz. tail. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad and choice of side.
      $98.00
    • Surf & Surf

      12 -14 oz. South African lobster tail and 1 lb. Alaskan king crab legs. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $227.95
  • Lunch | Wild Caught Seafood

    • Alaskan King Crab Legs

      2 lb. split, ready to eat. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $212.00
  • Dessert

    • Carrot Cake

      $17.10
    • CheeseCake

      $13.70
  • Deposits/Reservations

    • Deposit $100: 5-15people

      This deposit is for a 5-15 person reservation for our dining room. This deposit is non-refundable, and comes off bill at the end of your visit. At least 80% of party must show within 15 minutes of appointment or deposit is forfeited. One check per party. DO NOT MAKE PAYMENT UNTIL SPEAKING WITH THEO’S Host or Management. PLEASE PROVIDE INFORMATION BELOW: • Name • Phone Number • Date of Reservation • Time of Reservation • Number of People Attending Cancellation Refund Policy 7 Days Prior To Event Excluding Holidays
      $114.00
    • Deposit- $200: 25-30 People

      This is for a private party room for (a minimum of) 25 to (maximum) of 30 guests. Final count must be given 48 hours before event. If 80% of your guests are not present for the party you will Forfeit the Deposit. If not, we will go by the count given previously. One check per party. DO NOT MAKE PAYMENT UNTIL SPEAKING WITH THEO’S Host or Management. PLEASE PROVIDE INFORMATION BELOW: • Name • Phone Number • Date of Reservation • Time of Reservation • Number of People Attending Cancellation Refund Policy 7 Days Prior To Event Excluding Holidays
      $228.00
    • Deposit - $600 60-100 People

      This is for a private party room for (a minimum of) 60 to (maximum) of 100 guests. Final count must be given 48 hours before event. If 80% of your guests are not present for the party you will Forfeit the Deposit. If not, we will go by the count given previously. One check per party. DO NOT MAKE PAYMENT UNTIL SPEAKING WITH THEO’S Host or Management. PLEASE PROVIDE INFORMATION BELOW: • Name • Phone Number • Date of Reservation • Time of Reservation • Number of People Attending Cancellation Refund Policy 7 Days Prior To Event Excluding Holidays
      $684.00
    • Deposit- $400 40-60 People

      This is for a private party room for (a minimum of) 40 to (maximum) of 60 guests. Final count must be given 48 hours before event. If 80% of your guests are not present for the party you will Forfeit the Deposit. If not, we will go by the count given previously. One check per party. DO NOT MAKE PAYMENT UNTIL SPEAKING WITH THEO’S Host or Management. PLEASE PROVIDE INFORMATION BELOW: • Name • Phone Number • Date of Reservation • Time of Reservation • Number of People Attending Cancellation Refund Policy 7 Days Prior To Event Excluding Holidays
      $456.00
  • Lunch | Appetizers

    • Theos House Pretzel

      Served with our home made artesian beer cheese.
      $11.35
    • Shrimp Cocktail

      Colossal shrimp served chilled with our house cocktail sauce.
      $17.05
    • Calamari Fritto

      Served with our house cocktail sauce.
      $14.80
    • Crab Cake

      Our award winning blend, topped with sauteed spinach, and a spicy remoulade sauce.
      $18.20
    • Saganaki (OPA)

      Greek cheese pan fried and flamed table side with brandy.
      $14.80
    • Brushetta

      Minced plum tomato, garlic, onions, fresh basil, tossed with EVOO. Served on a rustic Italian bread and drizzled with balsamic glaze.
      $11.35
  • Lunch | Fresh Salads

    • Miss Julie Anne

      Turkey, ham, Cheddar cheese, Swiss cheese, avocado, tomato, egg and fruit. All salads are accompanied by lemon rice soup, and choice of dressing.
      $17.05
    • Greek Country Salad

      Kalamata olives, green peppers, Feta cheese, green onions, and potato salad. All salads are accompanied by lemon rice soup, and choice of dressing.
      $14.80
    • Cobb Salad

      Fried chicken breast, bacon, tomato, avocado, egg, and Blue cheese. All salads are accompanied by lemon rice soup, and choice of dressing.
      $19.35
    • Crab Louie

      Crabmeat blend, avocado, egg and fruit. All salads are accompanied by lemon rice soup, and choice of dressing.
      $14.80
    • Seafood Cobb Salad

      Crabmeat, shrimp, avocado, bacon, egg and blue cheese. All salads are accompanied by lemon rice soup, and choice of dressing.
      $27.35
    • Chicken Caesar Salad

      Chicken, Parmesan cheese, croutons and egg tossed in Caesar dressing. All salads are accompanied by lemon rice soup.
      $18.20
    • Super Bowl Salad

      Grilled chicken, American cheese, Mozzarella cheese, tomato, egg and avocado. All salads are accompanied by lemon rice soup, and choice of dressing.
      $18.20
    • Theo’s Steak Salad

      Blue cheese, tomato, egg and fruit. All salads are accompanied by lemon rice soup, and choice of dressing.
      $23.90
    • BBQ Chicken Salad

      Fried chicken breast, onion rings, avocado, bacon, pepperoncini, drizzled with homemade BBQ ranch dressing. All salads are accompanied by lemon rice soup.
      $15.95
    • Blue Cheese Wedge Salad

      Iceberg wedge, served with bacon, Blue cheese crumbles, tomatoes, red onion, egg and croutons. All salads are accompanied by lemon rice soup, and choice of dressing.
      $17.05
  • Lunch | Sandwiches

    • Reuben

      Our signature corned beef, sauerkraut and Swiss cheese. Served on marble rye bread. All sandwiches are served with lemon rice soup, French fries, and fruit.
      $20.50
    • Italian Beef

      Slow roasted tri tip beef, grilled onions, peppers, and mozzarella cheese. Served on brioche bun. All sandwiches are served with lemon rice soup, French fries, and fruit.
      $20.50
    • Theo's Steak Sandwich

      Our Prime Steak, broiled to order and topped with Mozzarella cheese, mushrooms, and onions. Served on French roll. All sandwiches are served with lemon rice soup, French fries, and fruit.
      $26.20
    • Chicken Malibu Sandwich

      Country fried chicken breast, baked Virginia ham, and Mozzarella cheese. Served on brioche bun. All sandwiches are served with lemon rice soup, French fries, and fruit.
      $20.50
    • Chicken Legend Sandwich

      Specials seasoned chicken breast, served with spicy mayo, avocado and bacon. Served on brioche bun. All sandwiches are served with lemon rice soup, French fries, and fruit.
      $20.50
  • Lunch | Steak Burgers

    • Theo's Burger

      Blue cheese crumbles, onions, Nueskes bacon, and mushrooms Our steak burgers are ground fresh in house from the trimmings of ribeye, tenderloin and strip steaks. Burgers are accompanied by lemon rice soup, French fries, and fruit.
      $20.50
    • BBQ Bacon Burger

      American cheese and crispy bacon. Our steak burgers are ground fresh in house from the trimmings of ribeye, tenderloin and strip steaks. Burgers are accompanied by lemon rice soup, French fries, and fruit.
      $20.50
    • The Classic Burger

      Our steak burgers are ground fresh in house from the trimmings of ribeye, tenderloin and strip steaks. Burgers are accompanied by lemon rice soup, French fries, and fruit.
      $17.05
    • Patty Melt

      Mozzarella cheese, sauteed white onions on marble rye. Our steak burgers are ground fresh in house from the trimmings of ribeye, tenderloin and strip steaks. Burgers are accompanied by lemon rice soup, French fries, and fruit.
      $20.50
    • West Coast Burger

      Mozzarella cheese, avocado, bruschetta, and spicy mayo. Our steak burgers are ground fresh in house from the trimmings of ribeye, tenderloin and strip steaks. Burgers are accompanied by lemon rice soup, French fries, and fruit.
      $20.50
  • Lunch | USDA Prime Steaks

    • 18 Oz. Strip Steak

      18 oz. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad and choice of side.
      $50.15
    • Center Cut Filet

      9 oz. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $45.55
    • Bone-In Ribeye

      26 oz. Accompanied by soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $59.25
    • Porterhouse

      28 oz. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $59.25
  • Lunch | Wild Caught Seafood

    • Scottish Salmon

      Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad and choice of side.
      $26.20
    • Shrimp (Sea Of Cortez U10 Shrimp)

      Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad and choice of side.
      $27.35
    • Canadian Lake Perch

      Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad and choice of side.
      $25.05
    • Alaskan King Crab Legs

      2 lb. split, ready to eat. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $212.00
  • Lunch | Chicken

    • Chicken Picatta With Mushrooms

      Twin boneless chicken lightly floured and sauteed with mushrooms, capers, and Chablis wine. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad, and side.
      $25.05
    • Chicken Marsala With Mushrooms

      Twin boneless chicken lightly floured and sauteed with mushrooms, capers, and Chablis wine. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad, and side.
      $25.05
  • Dinner | USDA Prime Steaks

    • 18 Oz. Strip Steak

      18 oz. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $56.95
    • Bone-In Ribeye

      26 oz. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $63.80
    • Center Cut Filet

      9 oz. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $52.40
    • Porterhouse

      28 oz. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $68.35
    • Surf & Turf

      9 oz. Center cut filet mignon and 12-14 oz. South African lobster tail. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $172.10
    • Theo's Special Filet

      Filet topped with crabmeat, and our chef’s Bearnaise sauce. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad, and choice of side.
      $56.95
    • Rack Of Lamb

      Domestic lamb rack served lollipop style. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, house salad, and side.
      $54.70
    • White Marble Farms Pork Chops

      Twin pork chops grilled to perfection. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, house salad, and side.
      $34.15
    • BBQ Ribs

      Full slab meaty pork ribs, mopped with our signature smoked BBQ sauce. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, house salad, and side.
      $34.15
  • Dinner | Appetizers

    • Bruschetta

      Minced plum tomato, garlic, onions, fresh basil, tossed with EVOO. Served on a rustic Italian bread and drizzled with balsamic glaze.
      $13.65
    • Calamari Fritto

      Served with our house cocktail sauce.
      $17.05
    • Crab Cakes

      Our award winning blend, topped with sauteed spinach, and a spicy remoulade sauce.
      $21.65
    • Saganaki (OPA!)

      Greek cheese pan fried and flamed table side with brandy.
      $15.95
    • Shrimp Cocktail

      Colossal shrimp served chilled with our house cocktail sauce.
      $21.65
    • Theos House Pretzel

      Served with our home made artesian beer cheese.
      $12.50
    • Oyster Rockefellar (6)

      Chesapeake bay area oysters, served with spinach, bacon and dolloped with bechamel. Served on a rustic Italian bread and drizzled with balsamic glaze.
      $22.75
    • Raw Oysters (6)

      Freshly shucked oysters on the half shell.
      $20.50
    • Fried Shrimp

      Served with cocktail sauce.
      $21.65
    • Quart Of Lemon Rice Soup

      16 oz of our Award Winning Lemon Rice Soup
      $17.10
  • Dinner | Chicken

    • Chicken Marsala With Mushrooms

      Twin boneless chicken breasts, lightly floured and sauteed with mushrooms and Marsala wine. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad, and side.
      $30.75
    • Chicken Piccata With Mushrooms

      Twin boneless chicken breasts, lightly floured and sauteed with mushrooms, capers, and Chablis wine. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad, and side.
      $30.75
  • Dinner | Entree Salads

    • Greek Country Salad

      Romaine lettuce blend, Kalamata olives, green peppers, Feta cheese, cucumbers, onions, pepperoncini and Greek dressing. Note : Cannot be discounted.
      $17.05
  • SIDES

    • Mashed Potato

      $3.45
    • French Fries

      $3.45
    • Oven Brown Potatoes

      $3.45
    • Vegetables

      $3.45
    • Grilled Vegetables

      $6.85
    • Grilled Asparagus

      $6.85
    • Loaded Baked Potato

      $4.60
    • Loaded Mashed Potato

      $4.60
    • Baked Potato

      $3.45
  • Dinner | Wild Caught Seafood

    • Surf & Surf

      12 -14 oz. South African lobster tail and 1 lb. Alaskan king crab legs. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $227.95
    • Alaskan King Crab Legs

      2 lb. split, ready to eat. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $212.00
    • Canadian Lake Perch

      Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $30.75
    • Double South African Lobster Tail

      2 12 -14 oz. tails. Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $177.80
    • Scottish Salmon

      Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $33.05
    • Shrimp (Sea Of Cortez U10 Shrimp)

      Accompanied by lemon rice soup or house salad and choice of side.
      $34.15
    • South African Lobster Tail

      12 - 14 oz. tail. Accompanied by lemon rice soup, or house salad and choice of side.
      $98.00

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms