The Sayville Inn Menu

4.5

(250+ Reviews)

Weekly Specials Starters Soups Sayville Tacos Salads Tavern Classics Flatbread Sandwiches Entrees Homemade Desserts Kids Menu Wine Draft Beer Bottle Beer Super Bowl Food Choices

Weekly Specials
- Corned Beef Reuben Egg Rolls
  Swiss, Sauerkraut, side of Russian and Mustard
  $13.00
- Mussels White
  Garlic Ciabatta
  $14.00
- Fried Flounder Sandwich
  Coleslaw, Tartar, Brioche Bun, side of Pickle Chips, Shoestring Fries
  $18.00
- Grilled Salmon With Cucumber Dill Sauce
  Garlic Mashed Potatoes and Broccoli
  $29.00
- Corned Beef And Cabbage
  Boiled Potatoes, Carrots, Irish Soda Bread
  $25.00
- Traditional Shepherd's Pie
  $20.00
- Lemon Parmesan Penne
  Grilled Chicken, Garlic Ciabatta
  $19.00
Starters
- John Scott's Wings
  Choice of Buffalo, Honey BBQ or Old Bay, celery, bleu cheese
  $15.00
- Boneless Wings
  Choice of Buffalo, Honey BBQ or Old Bay, celery, bleu cheese
  $12.00
- Eggplant Towers
  Lightly fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil pesto
  $14.00
- Mozzarella Sticks
  Beer-battered, marinara
  $10.00
- Bowl Of Chili
  Served in a crock, topped with melted cheddar jack cheese
  $9.00
- Pretzel Bites
  Cheese dipping sauce
  $9.00
- Chicken Tenders
  Original w/ BBQ or Buffalo w/ bleu cheese
  $12.00
- Feta-Spiked Hummus
  Olives, cucumbers, grilled pita
  $14.00
- Firecracker Calamari
  Chipotle Thai chili glaze
  $15.00
- Macaroni & Cheese
  Signature house blend
  $11.00
- Buffalo Popcorn Shrimp
  Crumbled bleu, bleu cheese dressing, celery
  $15.00
- Sayville Nachos
  Melted cheddar jack, chili, jalapenos, sour cream & salsa
  $13.00
- Avocado Toast
  Ciabatta, feta, pico de gallo
  $12.00
- French Fries
  Shoestring or waffle, Sayville Sauce
  $7.00
- Disco Fries
  Shoestring, brown gravy, melted mozzarella
  $12.00
- Margherita Cauliflower Crust Pizza
  Mozzarella, diced tomatoes, basil, balsamic glaze
  $14.00
- Coconut Shrimp
  Lightly fried, coconut battered, Thai chili marmalade
  $18.00
- Chips & Guacamole
  Fresh made guacamole with corn tortilla chips
  $12.00
Soups
- New England Clam Chowder
  $9.00
- Manhattan Clam Chowder
  $9.00
- Long Island Half N' Half
  $9.00
- French Onion Soup
  Homemade croutons, melted mozzarella
  $9.00
Sayville Tacos
- Baja Fish Tacos
  The House Specialty! Coconut beer batter, pico de gallo, chipotle slaw & tequila lime aioli
  $18.00
- Steak Tacos
  Grilled sirloin, mixed greens, chipotle slaw, frizzled onions & Sriracha mayo
  $20.00
- Buffalo Chicken Tacos
  Lettuce, tomato, red onion & bleu cheese dressing
  $16.00
- Beer Braised Short Rib Tacos
  Mixed greens, chipotle slaw, red onion & Sayville Sauce
  $20.00
- Grilled Salmon Tacos
  Chipotle slaw, mango black bean salsa & tequila lime aioli
  $19.00
- Dirt Candy Tacos
  Vegetables medley, feta, red onions & Sayville Sauce
  $15.00
- Grilled Shrimp Tacos
  Chipotle slaw, field greens, pico de gallo & tequila lime aioli
  $18.00
Salads
- House Salad
  Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onion & House Vinaigrette
  $9.00
- Iceberg Wedge
  Smoked bacon, tomato, crumbled bleu cheese & House Vinaigrette
  $13.00
- All Kale Caesar
  Chili croutons, parmesan, creamy Caesar dressing
  $11.00
- Grilled Salmon Salad
  Kale, red onion, tomato, parmesan & lemon vinaigrette
  $20.00
- Chicken & Field Greens
  Walnuts, craisins, crumbled bleu, tomato, red onion & House Vinaigrette
  $18.00
- Seared Steak Salad
  Sirloin, portobello, tomato, red onion, crumbled bleu & House Vinaigrette
  $22.00
- Chicken Milanese
  Fried cutlet, field greens, tomato, red onion, parmesan & lemon vinaigrette
  $19.00
- Chopped Salad
  Chopped iceberg, tomato, red onion, cucumber, fresh mozzarella, bacon, grilled chicken, house vinaigrette
  $19.00
Tavern Classics
- Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich
  American, bacon, lettuce, tomato, Sayville Sauce
  $19.00
- Hot Coffee Burger
  Melted mozzarella, jalapenos & Sayville Sauce
  $17.00
- Black & Blue Burger
  Melted bleu cheese, frizzled onions & steak sauce
  $17.00
- Teddy Roosevelt Burger
  Melted swiss, sauteed mushrooms, parmesan
  $17.00
- BBQ Bacon Burger
  Melted cheddar, frizzled onions, BBQ sauce
  $18.00
- Middle Road Burger
  Short rib, melted mozzarella, caramelized onions, Au Jus, toasted garlic english muffin
  $20.00
- Tuscan Burger
  Tomato, fresh mozzarella, red onion, basil, balsamic glaze
  $18.00
- California Chicken Wrap
  Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, red onion, avacado, bacon, firecracker sauce
  $18.00
- Turkey Burger
  Feta, guacamole, field greens
  $16.00
- Portobello Burger
  Roasted mushroom and red pepper, fresh melted mozzarella & tequila lime aioli
  $16.00
Flatbread Sandwiches
- Short Rib French Dip
  Horseradish sour cream, frizzled onions, Au Jus
  $20.00
- Shrimp Po' Boy
  Popcorn shrimp, lettuce, tomato Sayville Sauce
  $19.00
- Cajun Chicken
  Lettuce, tomato, red onion, Ranch dressing
  $18.00
- Veggie
  Black bean, lettuce, tomato, red onion, roasted red pepper & portobello, cauliflower, Sayville Sauce
  $16.00
Entrees
- BBQ Ribs
  Homemade BBQ, shoestring french fries
  $26.00
- Coconut Shrimp
  Coconut beer-battered, shoestring, corn salad, Thai chili marmalade
  $25.00
- Cajun Steak Frites
  Cajun gravy, shoestring fries & Sayville Sauce
  $29.00
- Lemon Parmesan Chicken
  Parmesan dusted, with mashed potatoes & vegetables of the day
  $24.00
- Fish & Chips
  Coconut beer-battered, waffle fries, key lime tartar sauce
  $23.00
- Grilled Cajun Salmon
  Tarragon butter sauce, garlic mashed potatoes, vegetable of the day
  $29.00
- Pasta Of The Day
  Served With garlic ciabatta
Homemade Desserts
- Tollhouse Cookie Pie
  Homemade chocolate chip pie, topped with Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge
  $11.00
- Brownie Chip Sundae
  Homemade chocolate chip brownie topped with Vanilla ice cream & hot fudge
  $10.00
- Rice Krispy Treat Pie
  Rice Krispy treat crust, layered with chocolate peanut butter fudge & Cookies and Cream ice cream
  $11.00
- Riverbottom Pie
  Coffee ice cream, Oreo cookie crust
  $11.00
- Mint Chip Pie
  Rice Krispy treat crust, hot fudge, whipped cream
  $11.00
- Peanut Butter Pie
  Housemade, whipped cream
  $9.00
- Root Beer Float
  Vanilla ice cream, whipped cream
  $7.00
- Kids Sundae
  Chocolate, Vanilla, Cookies & Cream or Mint Chip topped with whipped cream and hot fudge
  $6.00
Kids Menu
- Grilled Chicken & Vegetables
  $9.00
- Burger & Fries
  $8.00
- Cheeseburger & Fries
  $9.00
- English Muffin Pizza
  $8.00
- Chicken Fingers & Fries
  $8.00
- Penne Marinara Or Butter
  $8.00
- Grilled Cheese & Fries
  $8.00
Wine
- Vicolo Pinot Grigio
  $10.00
- Rex Goliath Chardonnay
  $9.00
- Kendall Jackson Chardonnay
  $12.00
- Fetzer Riesling
  $8.00
- Dancing Bull Cabernet
  $8.00
- Cartlidge & Browne Cabernet
  $10.00
- Rodney Strong
  $11.00
- Elsa Bianca Malbec
  $9.00
- Hob Nob Pinot Noir
  $8.00
- Cecchi Chianti
  $10.00
- Juliette Rose
  $9.00
- Liberty Creek White Zinfandel
  $9.00
- La Marca Prosecco
  $10.00
Draft Beer
- Blue Point Toasted
  $7.00
- Grennport Otherside IPA
  $7.00
- Sam Adams Summer Ale
  $7.00
- Montauk Wave Chaser IPA
  $7.00
- New Belgium Voodoo Ranger IPA
  $7.00
- Stella Artois
  $7.00
- Guinness
Bottle Beer
- Amstel Light
- Bells Two Hearted Ale
- Blue Point Hoptical Illusion IPA
  $6.00
- Blue Moon
  $6.00
- Bud Light
- Budweiser
- Coors Light
- Corona
  $6.00
- Corona Light
  $6.00
- Dogfish Head 60 Min IPA
  $6.00
- Heineken
- Heineken Light
- Michelob Ultra
- Miller Lite
- Montauk Juicy IPA
  $8.00
- Montauk Summer Ale
  $6.00
- Montauk Watermelon
  $6.00
- O'Doul's
- Omission Pale Ale GF
  $6.00
- Peroni
  $6.00
- Red Bridge
Super Bowl
- AFC Package
  ½ Tray Wings, ½ Tray Buffalo Chicken Meatballs, ½ Tray Cheeseburger Sliders
  $135.00
- NFC Package
  ½ Tray Wings, Pick 2: ½ Tray Lemon Parm Chicken, ½ Tray Penne alla Vodka or ½ Tray Sausage and Peppers
  $160.00
- Championship Package
  ½ Tray Wings, ½ Tray Cheeseburger Sliders, ½ Tray Lemon Parm Chicken, ½ Tray Penne alla Vodka, ½ Tray Sausage and Peppers
  $250.00
- 1⁄2 Tray Wings
  Buffalo, Old Bay, or Honey BBQ
  $55.00
- ½ Tray Boneless Wings
  Buffalo, Old Bay, or Honey BBQ
  $50.00
- ½ Tray Buffalo Chicken Meatballs
  $50.00
- ½ Tray Chicken Tenders
  Plain, Buffalo, Old Bay or Honey BBQ
  $55.00
- ½ Tray Mozzarella Sticks
  Original or Buffalo Style
  $60.00
- ½ Tray Popcorn Shrimp
  Plain, Buffalo, or Firecracker
  $55.00
- ½ Tray Calamari
  Plain or Firecracker
  $60.00
- ½ Tray Cheeseburger Sliders
  9 pieces
  $45.00
- ½ Tray Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sliders
  9 pieces
  $50.00
- ½ Tray Coconut Shrimp
  $65.00
Food Choices
- Wings
  Buffalo, Plain, or Old Bay, Honey BBQ (GF N/A),
  $55.00
- Boneless Wings
  Buffalo, Honey BBQ, Plain, or Old Bay
  $50.00
- Chicken Meatballs
  Buffalo or Marinara
  $50.00
- Meatballs
  Swedish or Marinara
  $50.00
- Chicken Tenders
  Plain, Buffalo, Honey BBQ, or Old Bay
  $55.00
- Mozzarella Sticks
  Plain or Buffalo
  $60.00
- Popcorn Shrimp
  Plain, Buffalo, Firecracker
  $55.00
- Calamari
  Plain, Firecracker
  $60.00
- P.E.I. Mussels
  Fra Diavolo, White, or Marinara
  $60.00
- Cheeseburger Sliders
  $50.00
- Specialty Burger Sliders
  3 each Teddy, BBQ, Hot Coffee
  $55.00
- Tuscan Chicken Sliders
  $55.00
- Buttermilk Chicken Sliders
  $55.00
- Crab Cake Sliders
  $80.00
- Lobster Roll Sliders
  Available with 9 Pieces
- Baja Fish Tacos
  $60.00
- Steak Tacos
  $60.00
- Buffalo Chicken Tacos
  $60.00
- Short Rib Tacos
  $60.00
- Grilled Salmon Tacos
  $60.00
- Grilled Shrimp Tacos
  $60.00
- Assorted Tacos
  choose any 2 styles, 4 of each
  $60.00
- Coconut Shrimp
  $65.00
- Shrimp Cocktail
  $80.00
- Feta Spiked Hummus
  Pita, Vegetables
  $45.00
- Macaroni And Cheese
  $50.00
- Short Rib Macaroni And Cheese
  $65.00
- Crab Cake Balls
  $95.00
- Chili And Cheese
  $50.00
- Caprese Skewers
  $45.00
- Penne Alla Vodka
  $55.00
- Fettuccine Alfredo
  $55.00
- Cajun Penne Pasta
  $55.00
- Pesto Penne Pasta
  $55.00
- Short Rib Penne Pasta
  $70.00
- Pasta Bolognese
  $65.00
- Lemon Parmesan Penne
  $55.00
- Pasta Primavera
  $55.00
- Lasagna
  $65.00
- Baked Ziti
  Meatless
  $55.00
- Cheese Ravioli Caprese
  $60.00
- Lobster & Crabmeat Ravioli
- Lemon Parmesan Chicken
  $65.00
- Tijuana Chicken
  served over rice
  $65.00
- Chicken Marsala
  $65.00
- Chicken Francese
  $65.00
- Chicken Parmesan
  $65.00
- Chicken Parmesan Ala Vodka
  $65.00
- Chicken Teriyaki
  $65.00
- Chicken Stir Fry
  $65.00
- Chicken Fajitas
  tortillas, salsa, sour cream on side
  $65.00
- Steak Stir Fry
  $75.00
- Sliced Sirloin
  $125.00
- Marinated Sliced Skirt Steak
  $125.00
- Marinated Sliced Flank Steak
  $125.00
- Sliced Pork Loin
  $80.00
- Meatloaf And Gravy
  $70.00
- Sausage And Peppers
  $60.00
- Garlic Lime Shrimp
  served over rice
  $65.00
- Shrimp Scampi
  Over Spaghetti
  $65.00
- Eggplant Parmesan
  $55.00
- Eggplant Towers
  9 Towers
  $55.00
- Seafood Paella
  served over rice
  $95.00
- Jambalaya
  Chicken, Shrimp, Sausage, and rice
  $75.00
- Grilled Cajun Salmon
  $80.00
- Broiled Flounder
  with Crabmeat Stuffing
  $125.00
- House Salad
  $30.00
- Kale Caesar Salad
  $30.00
- Chicken And Field Greens
  Craisin, Walnuts, Crumbled Bleu
  $50.00
- Watermelon And Feta Salad
  Seasonal
  $45.00
- Chopped Salad
  with Chicken
  $50.00
- Corn Salad
  $25.00
- Coleslaw
  $25.00
- Fries
  Shoestring* or Waffle
  $30.00
- Garlic Mashed, Roasted Potatoes, Sweet Potato Mashed
  $35.00
- Grilled Vegetables
  $35.00
- 16oz Signature Dressings
  House or Lemon Vinaigrette
  $10.00
- 16oz Sauces
  Buffalo, Honey BBQ (can not be made gluten free), Sayville, or Firecracker
  $10.00
- 16oz Brown Gravy
  $10.00
- Homemade Ice Cream Pie
  Mint Chip, Rice Krispie, River Bottom, Tuxedo
  $85.00