The Proper Pie Company Menu

4.4

(500+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Kids Favorites Proper Steak Pies Proper Chicken Pies Proper Fish and Chips Proper Sides Proper Snacks Proper Homemade Sweets Soda & Water

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Banger Rolls
  2 handmade banger rolls with delicious pork sausage - a great snack hot or cold.
  $5.95
- Steak, Potato, Onion, and Cheese
  Handmade with tender steak, potato, onion and some cheese, all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry.
  $8.65
- Chicken Curry
  Handmade with tender pieces of chicken in a mild, but tangy, curry sauce, all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry.
  $8.65
- Cod and Chips
  Our freshly sourced succulent cod with our handmade double cooked chips (fries) in our own secret light and crispy ale batter is delicious on its own or with extra sides!.
  $15.05
- Eccles Cake
  The quintessential English sweet handmade with raisins, butter and brown sugar, wrapped in our signature puff pastry
  $2.85
- Scottish Shortbread
  A slice of our handmade Scottish shortbread is unbeatable with an afternoon cup of tea or coffee.
  $2.85
- Steak and Ale
  Handmade with chopped tender steak, diced potato and traditional ale (which one is our secret!), all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry.
  $8.65
- Mr Pibb
  An intensely flavored, refreshing, spicy cherry alternative to regular cola.
  $3.45
- Chips
  Our hand cut double cooked chips (fries) are the real deal.
  $3.45
- Portion of Chips
  $2.75
- Mushy Peas
  A Northern English favorite as well as a great accompaniment to our delicious fish & chips or Proper Pies.
  $3.45
- Gravy
  Our rich beef based gravy is a compliment to any of our Proper Pies.
  $3.45
Kids Favorites
All things fun for kids.
- Portion of Chips
  $2.75
Proper Steak Pies
- Steak and Ale
  Handmade with chopped tender steak, diced potato and traditional ale (which one is our secret!), all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry.
  $8.65
- Steak, Potato, Onion, and Cheese
  Handmade with tender steak, potato, onion and some cheese, all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry.
  $8.65
Proper Chicken Pies
- Chicken Curry
  Handmade with tender pieces of chicken in a mild, but tangy, curry sauce, all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry.
  $8.65
Proper Fish and Chips
- Homemade Tartar Sauce
  Our own handmade Tartar sauce is made entirely with fresh ingredients (proper pickles, mayonnaise and capers) and is a perfect accompaniment to our delicious fish & chips.
  $1.25
- Cod and Chips
  Our freshly sourced succulent cod with our handmade double cooked chips (fries) in our own secret light and crispy ale batter is delicious on its own or with extra sides!.
  $15.05
- Chips
  Our hand cut double cooked chips (fries) are the real deal.
  $3.45
Proper Sides
- Curry Sauce
  A great accompaniment for our delicious fish and chips or any of our Proper Pies
  $3.45
- Mushy Peas
  A Northern English favorite as well as a great accompaniment to our delicious fish & chips or Proper Pies.
  $3.45
- Gravy
  Our rich beef based gravy is a compliment to any of our Proper Pies.
  $3.45
Proper Snacks
- Banger Rolls
  2 handmade banger rolls with delicious pork sausage - a great snack hot or cold.
  $5.95
Proper Homemade Sweets
- Scottish Shortbread
  A slice of our handmade Scottish shortbread is unbeatable with an afternoon cup of tea or coffee.
  $2.85
- Eccles Cake
  The quintessential English sweet handmade with raisins, butter and brown sugar, wrapped in our signature puff pastry
  $2.85
- Scone
  Our famous English scones (plain, raisin or cranberry) are a treat at any time of day.
  $2.85
Soda & Water
- Mr Pibb
  An intensely flavored, refreshing, spicy cherry alternative to regular cola.
  $3.45
- Fountain Diet Coke
  A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
  $3.45
- Lemonade
  $3.45
- Fountain Sprite
  The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
  $3.45
- Fountain Coke
  The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
  $3.45