The Pony Bar Menu

1444 1st Ave., New York, NY 10021
  • SHAREABLES

    • THE PONY HAPPY FAMILY

      House-cut chips, salsa, guacamole & warm queso
      $12.00
    • CAULIFLOWER BITES

      Tossed in Buffalo sauce (U-Pick Temp) or General Tso's
      $12.00
    • TWO SOFT BAKED PRETZELS

      Mustard and warm pimento cheese
      $12.00
    • PIGS IN A BLANKET

      Schaller & Weber cheddarwurst sausage, Branston pickle, curry sauce & mustard
      $12.00
    • LARGE BASKET OF FRIES

      Get 'em LOADED
      $9.00
    • GAME DAY BOWL CHILI

      Large bowl of chili, sides of house-cut tortilla chips, shredded cheddar, & sour cream
      $12.00
    • NACHOS

      House-baked tortilla chips, melted cheddar, black beans, sides of sour cream, salsa, jalapeños, & guac dabs
      $13.00
    • QUESADILLA

      Marinated steak or marinated chicken, melty cheddar cheese & sides of sour cream, salsa, guac & jalapeños
      $12.00
    • TACO

      Steak, pork, chicken, shrimp, or black beans (vegan). All tacos are double-wrapped soft corn tortillas with cilantro, radishes & guac dabs
      $5.00
    • SKILLET MAC & CHEESE

      Spiral pasta, creamy three-cheese bechamel, toasted breadcrumbs
      $12.00
  • WINGS & TENDIES

    • THE PONY BAR'S FAMOUS DOUBLE-FRIED WINGS

      5 Jumbo Wings
      $12.00
    • THE PONY BAR'S FAMOUS DOUBLE-FRIED WINGS

      10 Jumbo Wings
      $17.00
    • THE PONY BAR TENDIES

      Crispy, fried, buttermilk-marinated tenders, tossed in your choice of sauce: Buffalo (Mild, Medium, or Hot), BBQ, Garlic Parm, General Tso's Mango Habanero, or Nude. All wings come with side of blue cheese & sticks
      $14.00
  • SANDWICHES

    • FLAT-TOP PONY BAR BURGER

      6oz Angus burger, iceberg, tomato, lettuce, pickles, soft potato bun
      $16.00
    • IMPOSSIBLE BURGER

      Vegan impossible burger, iceberg, tomato, pickles, soft potato bun
      $16.00
    • PONY BAR GRILLED CHEESE

      Thick sliced Pullman loaf, 3-cheese blend (American, cheddar, Parmesan-Reggiano)
      $16.00
    • PULLED PORK

      House pulled pork, side of slaw, soft potato bun
      $16.00

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms